The story does a fantastic job of describing every little detail to create a realistic scene. The location of the cottage, for instance, is made evident in the first few lines. The remainder of the story is set up with strong feelings of place and atmosphere. Descriptions like "thin wisps of snow being blown over miles of ice covering the expansive lake" were well-written bits of prose. These particulars not only improve the story's mood but also help the reader feel more rooted in the scene.

Brandon is a well-developed character with distinct motivations and an engaging internal conflict. His actions are motivated by his desire to maintain the family cottage and his remorse for missing his grandmother's final Christmas celebration, which makes him likable and interesting. Brandon's character is given more nuance through the use of flashbacks to his early years. His fears and traumas are revealed by memories like falling through the ice and finding a dead man on the shore, which gives him a more complex and realistic personality.

Your dialogue reads as genuine and feels natural, which helps to highlight the characters' relationships and personalities. For instance, Brandon and Lisa's discussion regarding Millie's voodoo and witchcraft beliefs is amusing and insightful about their relationship. Additionally, the dialogue serves to advance the plot and heightens the tension. For instance, the story's climax is set when John tells Brandon about the power outage and the necessity to fix the light at the boathouse.

Your combination of mystery and suspense was really effective, especially during the Brittingham Boathouse scenes. There's a sense of intrigue and unease brought about by the strange smell, the appearance of the wet man, and the abrupt change in the light of the lighthouse. These suspenseful elements give the story more depth and tension while keeping the reader interested and eager to find out what the story's secrets are.

Lisa is a supportive character, and I think that's probably why is as complex of a character as Brandon. She's primarily Brandon's sounding board for ideas and experiences. You could deepen her development by giving her more autonomy and discovering her personality by revealing her goals, her past, and her connection to Brandon. She'll become a more complex and engaging character if you show her interacting with other characters and having her own objectives and conflicts. Stories are enriched and are able to become more immersive when characters—regardless of the size of their role—appear as full-fledged living entities "outside" of the page. Sprinkling some small details into the story can go a long way into creating a dramatic sense of reality for readers.

The story jumps around a lot, like when Johnny and Brandon discuss Millie's beliefs and then find themselves at the boathouse. This shift can break reader immersion because it pulls them out of the story and makes them focus on the logistics of the scene instead—where they are and when they are, relative to what happened before the shift. It leaves reader feeling jumbled around in space and time a result. It's a easy fix, though! You can make scene changes more seamless to encourage a more organic flow to the story. For instance, you could insert one or two sentences to explain the shift in time or place and close the gap between scenes.

The mention of shadow people is fascinating but I think they and the appearance of Brandon's grandmother's ghost could use some further clarification. There might be questions raised by readers regarding these paranormal components. One way of fixing this would be to simply give the supernatural aspects of the story some additional context or background. It can be done by adding more dialogue, giving Brandon an internal monologue, or introducing myths or folklore that describe these phenomena within the setting of the story.

Although family and tradition are mentioned in passing in the story, these topics could be expanded upon to give the story more substance. For instance, a deeper examination of Brandon's wish to maintain the family cottage would emphasize the value of family ties and traditions. Consider adding more sequences or instances that highlight the value of tradition and family in Brandon's life. Illustrate how these facets of his upbringing have influenced his decisions and values, giving his character and the story's central theme a lot more depth.

The story combines realistic elements like the power outage and fixing the light at the boathouse with supernatural elements like the ghost of Brandon's grandmother. The harmony between these components, though, could be more balanced. Make sure the story's tone and themes are consistent with the supernatural components. This will keep readers interested in the story and help them to suspend their disbelief.

Your story is captivating and fascinating due to a number of its strong points. There is a strong sense of place because the setting, especially the cottage and its surroundings, are described in vivid detail. The story has depth because the themes of family and tradition are present throughout. The supernatural components—the ghost of Brandon's grandmother and references to the shadow people—create a spooky atmosphere that will pique any reader's interest. The story also skillfully creates suspense and mystery by building tension, particularly during the scenes at the boathouse.

There are some minor things within the story that could be strengthened. More character development for the supporting cast, especially Lisa, could give the story more nuance and complexity. Enhancing the narrative's overall flow could also create smoother scene transitions and pacing. Furthermore, maintaining the reader's interest and ability to suspend disbelief may be aided by making the supernatural elements more clear and balancing them with the realistic aspects of the narrative.

Your storytelling has a lot of potential! Keep writing and honing your craft.

Write on