This week: The Butler Did It Edited by: Carol St.Ann  
More Newsletters By This Editor 
 
1. About this Newsletter
2. A Word from our Sponsor
3. Letter from the Editor
4. Editor's Picks
5. A Word from Writing.Com
6. Ask & Answer
7. Removal instructions
| This past week, while researching whodunits where (one of the staff) did it, I came across this information on a mystery writers discussion board and was so intrigued, I had to share it. Hopefully you’ll enjoy its fun facts as much as I did. Kudos and thanks to Cecil Adams. |
| ASIN: B07YXBT9JT |
Product Type: Kindle Store
|
Amazon's Price: $ 4.99
|
|
Ever wonder where the expression, “The butler did it” came from?
Here is the edited, condensed version of what I’ve learned:
The expression “the butler did it” is commonly attributed to novelist Mary Roberts Rinehart (1876-1958), who, in 1930, published The Door, in which (spoiler alert) the butler does it. But the words “the butler did it” do not appear in the book, and Rinehart was hardly the first crime writer to implicate the servant class in her detective fiction.
One of the earliest was the writer who largely created the genre, Arthur Conan Doyle. In “The Musgrave Ritual,” from The Memoirs of Sherlock Holmes (1893), the butler, Brunton, is found dead beside the chest that had contained the Musgrave family treasure — “the butler, guilty of betrayal and theft, paid with his life for his perfidy,” as the Oxford Companion to Crime & Mystery Writing puts it. In Agatha Christie’s The Murder of Roger Ackroyd (1926), suspicion initially falls on Ackroyd’s butler, owing to his criminal past.
Still, crime-fiction writers of the day tended to think that casting one of the hired help as the culprit was cheating. (That is, it was only okay for the butler to be suspected of doing it.) Essayist, S.S. Van Dine confirms this when he opines, “A servant must not be chosen by the author. The culprit must be a decidedly worth-while person (who) wouldn’t ordinarily come under suspicion.” Noting the indifferent classism here, let’s follow it up with this clarification from the Oxford Companion: “Because the butler can move about the house in the course of his duties with complete freedom, so taken for granted by the other characters that no one pays attention to him, he makes an ideal culprit.”
Keeping this in mind, it’s no surprise, then, that traditional writers of the day felt the help as culprit was too easy. At the same time, the more adventurous writers argued that having the butler do it is the perfect opportunity to inject the resentments of the working-class into the world of those who fancy themselves high society sophisticates. Still, few writers took the bait, because, once the notion had been fixed in the popular mind by Ms. Rinehart’s book, it became an easy target for satirists like Damon Runyon and P.G. Wodehouse.
All that said, I think it fair and just that we give Rinehart her due. Even though the four famous words were never penned by her, she gets the credit for having made them a cliche.
As always, thank you for sharing some of your time and allowing me to share my interest in writing with you! I do hope you find this helpful or informative.
Until next time,
Carol
Source Citations:
Oxford Companion to Crime & Mystery Writing
“Twenty Rules for Writing Detective Stories” essay 1928 S.S. Van Dine
“What, No Butler?” story 1933 Damon Runyon
The Butler Did It novel 1957 P.G. Wodehouse’s
CecilAdams / Straightdope
|
If you’ve got a mystery in your head:
Try out your mystery chops here:
Flesh it out here:
Workshop it here with dedicated, in-depth reviews:
In the meantime, enjoy these two great short stories:
| |  | Invalid Item
This item number is not valid.
#2256850 by Not Available. |
"Working the house" by WakeUpAndLive~doingNaNo'24 |
Have an opinion on what you've read here today? Then send the Editor feedback! Find an item that you think would be perfect for showcasing here? Submit it for consideration in the newsletter!
https://www.Writing.Com/go/nl_form
Don't forget to support our sponsor!
| ASIN: B07YJZZGW4 |
|
Amazon's Price: Price N/A
Not currently available. |
|
Are you writing a mystery? Feel free to hawk it here. Share your hints and experiences.
I’ll award an MB to anyone who directs me to a good Butler (or household staff member) did it story (um, or poem) here on WDC. |
| ASIN: B083RZ2C5F |
|
Amazon's Price: Price N/A
Not currently available. |
|
To stop receiving this newsletter, click here for your newsletter subscription list. Simply uncheck the box next to any newsletter(s) you wish to cancel and then click to "Submit Changes". You can edit your subscriptions at any time.
|
Mystery: June 15, 2022 Issue [#11408]
View Portfolio
Visit Notebook
Send Gift Points
Awards
Badges
Send Email
Community Newsfeed
General Discussion
Sponsored Items
Book of Trinkets
Static Items
Books
Groups
Interactive Stories
Audio
Campfire Creatives
Community Notes
Crossword Puzzles
Documents
Folders
Images
In & Outs
Madlibs
Photo Albums
Polls
Product Reviews
Quizzes
Survey Forms
Web Pages
Word Searches
