 Drama: February 17, 2010 Issue [#3559] |
  Drama
This week: Do You Dare to Offend? Edited by: esprit  
More Newsletters By This Editor 
1. About this Newsletter
2. A Word from our Sponsor
3. Letter from the Editor
4. Editor's Picks
5. A Word from Writing.Com
6. Ask & Answer
7. Removal instructions
"There is no rule on how to write. Sometimes it comes easily and perfectly: sometimes it's like drilling rock and then blasting it out with charges."
(Ernest Hemingway)
|
| ASIN: B07N36MHWD |
Product Type: Kindle Store
|
Amazon's Price: $ 7.99
|
|
Do You Dare to Offend?
My previous newsletter on banned and challenged books made me think of the writer's position in the conflict. Writer's don't write to hurt anyone, and most don't purposely target any group with the intention to do harm--at least fiction writers don't. They write about life, and the good writers spell it out clearly so it's believable.
But the threat of being 'politically incorrect' and called all sorts of names, or worse, lies heavy in the back of our minds now-a-days, and while it is important to be mindful of others, it has caused many writers to become afraid to say exactly what they mean. It's an uncomfortable place to be in when we have to decide which way to go--be honest or possibly offend. They tend to squirm around concise words and finally just take the easy way out--whitewashing the truth.
Why are they so afraid? Anyone listening to the news in the last week or so heard about the big fiasco in the government when one political figure told his group, which was meeting privately behind closed doors by the way, that what they were proposing was retarded. Nothing stays behind closed doors, and someone is always offended by words--count on it. My goodness, what an uproar. If this happens between peers in private, imagine putting an offending word in a book for the public to read. The result is writers who are afraid to say what they mean.
Imagine you have a friend or family member who would make a great character. She's fat, a lesbian, and an alcoholic. You know if she reads your book, she's going to recognize herself and be peeved out of her mind. You also know the readers are going to tell you that you shouldn't have called her 'fat' or used the word 'dyke.' What do you call a four-hundred pound lesbian? Perhaps 'differently-sized?' She calls herself a dyke and for the story to work, it needs to be included, but writers are afraid to write it the way it is.
What you decide will make the difference between a story with meat on its bones or something that offends no one, but won't be a good story, either. It won't tell any truths about life. If you think that 'differently-abled' is an appropriate synonym for 'crippled,' or that 'appearance-challenged' is a better use of the English language than 'ugly,' you're limiting your story-telling possibilities.
We're not all the same. We are fat and thin and skinny; we are smart and stupid, geniuses and retards; we are straight and queer and everything in between; we are sick and healthy; we are tall and short; we are moral and immoral, good and evil; we are honest and we are liars. We come in two sexes, male and female. We're not black or white, red or yellow...we are various shades of brown.
Using only non-offensive language to censor this fact is not going to change the fact. Nor is it going to change the fact that Aunt Mamie is fat and stinks of sweat even on cool days, or that she's a rude, self-centered, demanding woman who thinks the world owes her something because she's a lesbian. She is who she is---a person and an individual. She is not a member of a class, nor is she an archetype or a symbol, and you can't compare her to any other people you know. She is who she is. And if you try to sugar-coat her to keep from offending people who are looking for the chance to be offended, you are going to end up eviscerating everything about her that makes her interesting and unique--that becomes a great character that readers will remember.
Say what you mean.
Humanity is worth getting to know in the form that it takes. People as they really are are fascinating, challenging, diverse, wonderful, awful, amazing, complex, many-faceted, colorful.
Don't sacrifice your writing or your characters because you're afraid of offending or afraid to face the nuts that come out of the woodwork when you say what you mean.
Write the words that tell your story, even if they hurt. Take a stand, knowing that the only way you are ever going to say something that matters is if you have the guts to say anything in the first place. Walk away from the weasel words, admit that death waits for you at the end of your life, and call your character short or fat or skinny or stupid or ugly or perverted.
Thanks for reading.
** Image ID #1528027 Unavailable **
********************
|
Have an opinion on what you've read here today? Then send the Editor feedback! Find an item that you think would be perfect for showcasing here? Submit it for consideration in the newsletter!
https://www.Writing.Com/go/nl_form
Don't forget to support our sponsor!
| ASIN: 0910355479 |
|
Amazon's Price: $ 13.99
|
|
Comments on "Invalid Entry"
By: billwilcox
Comment: Great newsletter!
You said, "Kids generally choose their books according to issues they are dealing with. I think you've come upon a hidden secret that even kids don't know they know.
Good stuff 
Thanks, Bill!
By: Just call me Omni
Comment: OK, I am mad. I grew up reading Judy Blume. I am very upset that this kind of censorship is going on. Her books were realistic and even though they were written in the 70's (?) they are still very relevant to today's youth.
As far as Harry Potter. My daughter was below reading level when she started 4th grade but reading the 4th or 5th book that year brought her reading level up to an 8th grade level. I remember parents being upset that the books were so large and 'difficult' for their children. I knew that my daughter loved the series and come Hell or high water, she was going to read and understand every word in that book.
This all makes me sad. I can almost forgive schools...almost, but public libraries should carry almost everything.
I've heard that many kids went back to reading when Potter was released--it surprised many.
A school district in Calif. (Riverside) actually banned a Collegiate Dictionary from the grammar schools a few weeks ago. It contained a word 'one' (1) mother objected to. Yet, the school teaches the subject in health class--go figure.
By: Pepper 
Comment: You are absolutely right when you say that young adult readers demand honesty and realism from their books. However, as a middle school teacher, I would caution writers not to take that to an extreme. If people want teachers producing readers, then we need more works like The Bluford High Series and Tears of a Tiger that deliver in ways can still be used in the classroom.
Thanks for the tip!
By: scribbler
Comment: It always amazed me that any of Lois Lowry's work was ever banned. When I was a kid in 6th grade a teacher who saw that I loved reading suggested that I try her book 'Number the Stars' about the Holocaust. I was instantly a fan. In grade 8 our class read 'The Giver' which was already one of my favourite books. I'm thankful that my school board (I'm from Ontario) saw how important the book was, enough to make it a mandatory read. Even now, as a 20 year old I still cite her as one of my favourite authors.
I believe it was 'challenged', not actually banned, which means it was placed on higher shelves so the short people wouldn't be tempted. It 'challenged' them to ask a taller student to hand it down. 
By: StephBee 
Comment: I discovered Blubber in 5th grade and found Judy Blume's honesty refreshing. For me, a definite YA read!
I agree, Steph. Thanks! 
We always appreciate the feedback, thanks!
Editors:
Joy 
Adriana Noir
esprit
|
| ASIN: 1542722411 |
|
Amazon's Price: $ 12.99
|
|
To stop receiving this newsletter, click here for your newsletter subscription list. Simply uncheck the box next to any newsletter(s) you wish to cancel and then click to "Submit Changes". You can edit your subscriptions at any time.
|
This printed copy is for your personal use only. Reproduction
of this work in any other form is not allowed and does violate its copyright. |
View Portfolio
Visit Notebook
Send Gift Points
Awards
Badges
Send Email
