![]() |
This is a continuation of my blogging here at WdC |
|
This will be a blog for my writing, maybe with (too much) personal thrown in. I am hoping it will be a little more interactive, with me answering questions, helping out and whatnot. It follows on from the old one, which is now full. An index of topics from old and new can be found here: "Writing Blog No.2 Index" Feel free to comment and interact. And to suggest topics! |
| A Naming Pitfall One of my Discord servers is run by an independent (small) publisher. He recently shared something with all of us (we are mostly creatives on the server) that inspired this post. Here’s a copy-paste: If you are creating creatures or monsters or races or aliens for your stories please do NOT use names of things that already exist. You are giving the reader an unrealistic expectation and it is very difficult to go against the image they have in their head. I could list the examples here but it is a lot. Here is two. We had a story subed with “trolls” that were formless blobs and we had a story subed with “orcs” that were killer whales that live on land. I can get orcs being like orcas but Tolkien and D&D has taken ownership of that creature. Find a new words please! This is something that I have seen in a few stories and books for a while – the appropriation of a name of something that has a definite meaning or image, and changing it up. While I get the subversion aspect, as the publisher said above, there are reader expectations. This is not just monsters, though (that’s just apparently what the publisher is dealing with most often); I have read a book series where there are “knights” and yet they act and behave like blood-money mercenaries. It didn’t make sense, and judging by the reviews, I was not the only one to think that. Another is taking a common acronym or initialisation and giving it a new meaning. For example, in science-fiction stories, FTL is “faster than light” and is a form of travel convenient for crossing vast distances. However, I have read a book where a gun was FTL – Fluctuating Temporal Latency. Seriously. The gun could speed up or slow down the time in which another person was existing. But, again, the reviews all asked why use the same initialisation as Faster Than Light, which everyone knows? So, yeah, be inventive and utilise whatever you want. But, remember, if your readers do not gel with the changes you inflict upon them, it will affect their enjoyment of the entire work. |