Andrew expected this, as this had happened in many other towns, and pulled out a chest. He closed his eyes, opened said chest, and reached in. After 3 seconds he pulled out a muffin...which, really, looked like a cupcake. It was pretty much the same muffin Natalie ate, but with blue icing. Eyes still shut, Andrew ate the muffin in two bites and Natalie watched in amazement as Andrews body began to glow...
Meanwhile, Kurly was wandering about the shop, looking for something to do. She ended up going in the muffin storage area, which, conveniently, had a mirror in it. She noticed the mirror and took a better look at herself. She still looked a lot like a doll, with the exception that she now had a mouth...and apparently some organs. She looked at her diaper and found it, surprisingly, wet. As weird as it was, she kind of liked it. It made her seem much cuter.
One transformation into a female later, Andrew's--or should I say Andrea's, new panties started thickening, and thickening, and thickening. Seconds later, the panties, now a diaper, stopped growing. The diaper was 12" thick, reaching down to her knees. "Wow," Natalie said in amazement, "that's crazy." Andrea blushed at this comment. "So, you feel better?" Natalie smiled. "Yes. I do." Suddenly, there was a beeping heard between them. Natalie checked her watch. "Oh shoot! I'm gonna be late for school! C'mon Kurly--" it was then she realized her doll wasn't in the room. "Kurly? Kurly, where are you?!" Andrea noticed Natalie looked ready to have a nervous break-down. "I'm sure we'll find her," she told her "she can't have gone too far. I'll help you look." They started looking around when they heard a clatter a minute later. "Oh no, she must be in the storage room!" Thus, they ran off to the source of the sound...well, Andrea waddled. "So," Natalie started saying to Andrea, "I got a chance to look over the menu while you were changing. Are those chocolate ones in there too?" Andrea shook her head. "No, they're not. I prefer to keep them in a different, more secure room since the *effects work once unless a higher rank is consumed,* so it'd be wasting if any thieves broke in and started eating all the muffins." When they finally reached the door, they opened it and found Kurly and a few muffins floating around her. "Huh," Natalie said in surprise, "I didn't think she'd have powers too."
*Example: Someone eats a Bronze Chocolate Cuteness[1/2 orig. age]. Eating another won't regress them further. However, if they eat a silver one, they will be regressed further...but that only makes them 1/4 their original age or 1/2 current age.
And no, eating a gold and then a silver will not regress or progress.
Note for C2: We'll be following Natalie for a while. Don't worry, we'll eventually get back to Andrew/ea...and we'll meet a new character. But that's for later.
Note for both choices: Being the first customer ever for the bakery [in this town], Natalie gets a watch that allows her to call Andrew/ea and have him/her send muffins.