Lonewolf,
I'm so glad you decided to enter this into the Adam West contest this month. This was a great story! It was original and engaging, and I was hooked from the beginning.
The idea of ancient technology is fascinating to me! I once wondered, if you drem a line from Stone Henge to the center of the Mayan civilizatiojns, and from the mysterious mounds in the United Styates midwest to the Egyption pyramids, could the intersection of those lines represent the whereabouts of sunken Atlantis? Interesting...but not as interesting as your Resurrection Machine. Let's take a look at what makes this thing tick.
Introduction ▶︎I think we are all interested in history. Even if we don't have a favorite epoch or subject, something about the past draws us in. Perhaps it's because the past ties us all together. Using history to introduce the present had me hooked right away. The discovery of lost things has always called to me, as well, and Ken's finds, albeit fictional, were fascinating to me as I read. And that was just the first few paragraphs! Great hook.
Setting ▶︎ The Lab: Kenneth's lab/research facility was engrossing. So many unnamable artifacts and discoveries, so many pieces to so many puzzles. But I was also able to understand some of what he was seeing and doing. We've watched the History Channel and seen how the scientists do their thing. So as Kenneth did his research, it was sort of like watching a documentary on a a strange and wonderful one-of-a-kind find. Like most other elements of the story, this drew me in and kept me there.
The Hospital: Marcus' mospital room was not overly described; it didn't need to be. We've all been in those rooms. We all know the beeping, the hissing, the sad and sunken eyes, the tubes... By not going into too much detail, you let us, as the readers, immerse ourselves in an enviroment familiar to us. Very effective.
The Machine: As he built the contraption in his garage, I was able to imagine it vividly. It was organic, somehow wise in construction. Stone and green. Strength and technicality. You set this section up so well, one almost wishes it was a little longer. (Only because it was so cool, not because it really needed to be longer. )
Characters ▶︎Most good short stories only have one or two settings, one or two main characters. I appreciated being able to keep my focus on just a couple of primaries here.
Kenneth: I thoroughly enjoyed this character. As mentioned, I love to discover things, to dig and find out how things work. While I don't have the tenacity or knowledge to investigate on the scale of Mr. Anderson, just reading about such discoveries is tantalizing. I think you did the character justice by having him not only discover things but cross reference them, get second opinions, look at supporting documents and findings. It all lent to the overall believability of the character.
Marcus: A man resigned to his fate but still goverened by love, Marcus is less a driver in this story than the source of the climax itself. His quiet exhaustion is deeply felt—at least it was by me. But in the end, he's going to die, so for the love of his nephew, why not give this one last crazy grasp a try? Another good character.
Plot/Arc ▶︎Immortality? Avoidance of loss? The concept of resurrection can be quite philisophically stimulating. I foudn it interesting, however, that that discussion was kept in the background of this piece. This story focused on doining something, building something, saving something. "Why" and "What if" were left out of the equation of the story...but the questions were there, especially at the end. Hiding the Big Question in plain site in a story is an interesting trick, and it doesn't always pay off. This time, it paid dividends.
Mechanics ▶︎I always like to note when a person's writing is clean, technically. I found no orphaned sentence fragments, misplaced ideas, transient commas. everything felt right and tight. I appreciate that, because it makes the reading that much easier. And for me, the easier the reading is, the more energy I can dedicate to enjoying the story. Nicely done.
Conclusion ▶︎The way teh Resurrection machine morked, pulsated, everything—the sequence was written really well! I was especially impressed with teh description of the machine after it had done its work. It was still intact, but its fuel had been spent and it was subtly different. Excellent work.
However, this is the one area I had the slightest issue. I felt the last line was not definitive. “They won’t let you keep this,” Marcus continued. “And they won’t let it remain what it is.”
This is definitive and intuitive. "They," no matter from which society, will never leave altruism and beneficince alone. It will always be changed to something else, something for profit or something for violence. At least that's what history has shown us.
But the last line suggest that the machine will be okay, simply by Kenneth not letting it be hushed up—as if one person can truly stop "them" once "they" have put their minds to something. Something about those last lines just seemed loose to me, like there was something not quite tied up.
Understand, this is a very little thing I'm talking about here, in a terrific story. Just offering this reader's opinion.
This was a great take on the title. It was original in the extreme, engaging, and really interesting! The cure for death has obsessed humankind for millennia. The solution to the problem, found in ancient sources, makes one wonder why it was lost in the first place. Even though Marcus and Kenneth don't want it to be forgotten again, maybe it was hidden in the past for good reason. For if we all can live forever, what new hell would that unleash?
Thanks for this awesome entry, my friend!
This review offered by
Jeffrey
——————————
  " The Power Reviewers Group"  
 ![Power Review Image - Triple Guitar [#2194837]
~Click here to join a fun reviewing group~ ~Click here to join a fun reviewing group~](https://www.writing.com/main/images/action/display/ver/1770755738/item_id/2194837.jpg) Image # 2333342 over display limit. -?-
Please note that my reviews are intended to be
respectful and encouraging.
If you feel I have been rude, cruel,
or otherwise inappropriate,
please report this review to a moderator.
|