Jeffrey Meyer's (centurymeyer35) Reviews

Review Requests: ON
903 Public Reviews Given
908 Total Reviews Given
Review Style
I prefer to offer an in-depth review of others' writing. I will note the things I like, things that may not work as well for me as a reader, and supportive suggestions.
I'm good at...
Mechanics and meaning. I'm no expert, but I can tell where a comma does and doesn't belong, and I can see where a meaning might be excellently conveyed or a bit muddled thereby. I'm also good at recognizing the overall spirit of a piece as a whole, despite mechanics, grammar, and such.
Favorite Genres
General fiction, some sci-fi, drama, some poetry
Least Favorite Genres
Fan-fiction, politics
Favorite Item Types
Character-driven stories
Least Favorite Item Types
Articles. Essays are okay, but they're not my favorite.
I will not review...
Stories about giants or shrinking--I just don't "get" them. I am also unlikely to review 5,000+ word pieces unless the GP compensation is commensurate with the effort I will have to put into it.
Public Reviews
1
1

Review of The Sacred Realm of Trust  

Review by centurymeyer35Mail Icon
In affiliation with The Power Reviewers Group  
Rated: E | (4.0)
D,

It is interesting how the legends of fairies differ from one culture to another, and from one time to another. In Celtic tradition, fairies were often prankish or even near-malevolent little buggers, going so far as to kidnap human babies to raise as their own. In the US, we think in terms of Disney's Tinkerbell, a tiny flying female with a penchant for making good things happen. (The ironic thing there is that, in
Peter Pan, Tinkerbell's original goal was to make Wendy fall from the sky--killing her! Not exactly the sweetheart we see her as, now!)

But in any culture, their relationship with humans is of a secret nature, be it for good or ill, as is the case in your story. And you story also fulfills a need so many children seem to have: the need for a safe, private relationship with someone. Many children have make-believe friends; Monu has a fairy. In either case, there is the private safety to " have a silent exchange to their heart’s content" that a child can't always get with siblings or parents. You've demonstrated that need very nicely here.

This was a charming story, and a positive way to start my morning. Well done!

--Jeffrey Meyer
--Power Reviewers' Group
2
2

Review of What If.  

Review by centurymeyer35Mail Icon
In affiliation with The Power Reviewers Group  
Rated: E | (4.0)
Kevin,

The title of this piece is interesting here, and pulled me right in, although I still don't quite understand it: "What I If." Still, very interesting.

I think this asks some very good questions. Having just finished a book by William L Shirer called
The Rise and Fall of the Third Reich, the question of Hitler sat well with me. What if this incredible orator, this barreling force of personality and persuasion had preached peace, love? Or even economics or science or something? What if he hadn't been crazy as a ****house rat and twice as evil? What if...?

Your questions about each of this historical turning points are both humorous and thought-provoking. Like Carlin, embedding truth in the cushion of humor often makes it more palatable and easier to mentally digest.

I wondered, though
probably because of my personal religious bentif the question of Christ had been the last line, the most important question of all, how much more powerful might the piece have been? Totally a personal opinion, but I mean...what if?

Nice work.


This review offered by
Jeffrey

*Strong**Floral1*WDC Power Reviewers Group*Floral1**Explode*

Image for reviews and emailsQuill 2025 Nominee

Please note that my reviews are intended to be
respectful and encouraging.
If you feel I have been rude, cruel,
or otherwise inappropriate,
please report this review to a moderator.


 
3
3

Review of The Earring  

Review by centurymeyer35Mail Icon
In affiliation with The Power Reviewers Group  
Rated: E | (4.0)
This is a cute story, as one comes to expect from you. It is interesting, isn't it, how our first reaction to things is blame or suspicion? When resolution comes in the form of innocence, thoughunlike in this caseit's even more interesting how often anger is the next emotion.

"Tom has en earring in his pocket. He must be cheating on me!"

"Here, honey, I'm afraid I lost the other earring."

"I thought you were doing something wrong! Be more careful!"
*Frown*

People are weird. Except in this nice little story. Hopefully the cake made everything better.

--Jeffrey
--Power Reviewers'' Group
4
4

Review of Toe in the Water  

for entry "On Getting Older
Review by centurymeyer35Mail Icon
In affiliation with The Power Reviewers Group  
Rated: 13+ | (4.5)
There is, in fact, a solution to the process of getting old... but it pretty drastic and very final. *Skull*

You used a phrase that resonated very strongly with me:
"our happy presumption of immortality." What a true and frightening statement! When we are in our 20s and even our 30s, death is a theory, not a fact. We might have lost some friends to car accidents, war, may disease, but somehow the concept of death still doesn't apply to us personally. We are immune to this specter, and we tend to live life accordingly: dangerously, carelessly, frighteningly. It's when 40 and 50 roll around, when contemporaries start passing from heart attacks, diabetes, stroke; that's when we realize we're not immortal, that death is a personal destination, and that getting old is the incresingly unstable vehicle we ride to get there.

This short essay has a lot of impact, especially for those of us of that age who are feeling it.

But I suspect many younger readers will still put on their capes and super-suits, go out on Saturday nights, and tempt the fates with their supposed immortality one more time. I just hope we still see them in the years to come.

Very nice, succinct writing.

--Jeffrey
--Power Reviewers' Group
5
5

Review of The Part No One Speaks On  

Review by centurymeyer35Mail Icon
In affiliation with The Power Reviewers Group  
Rated: E | (3.5)
"Life Goes on."

"The world's not gonna stop for my broken heart."

"You'll get over it."

So many cliches and easy answers are out there to "help" us "deal" with grief. But the grief of grief, as you explain here, is something we don't consider. It happens, and we have to face it, but we don't expect it. We don't expect that we really
can continue living in the face of loss, that our own worlds do go on, even when it seems like they shouldn't.

We forget. We don't forget the people, but we forget the
immediacy of them. We don't forget the sound of their voice, but we loose touch with the impact of it. We don't forget the loss; we forget to keep hurting from it.

It seems like a betrayal to the departed, like a cheat, like insincerity. But it's just a part of life, part of staying sane and staying alive.

This was a very intuitive commentary on something we all feel but rarely see coming.

I'd like to offer, constructively, that paragraph breaks between complete thoughts would help here; and line breaks between those paragraphs would further help the reader comfortable consume this important piece.

Good topic here. Write on, Lee!



This review offered by
Jeffrey

*Strong**Floral1*WDC Power Reviewers Group*Floral1**Explode*

Image for reviews and emailsQuill 2025 Nominee

Please note that my reviews are intended to be
respectful and encouraging.
If you feel I have been rude, cruel,
or otherwise inappropriate,
please report this review to a moderator.


 

6
6

Review of Flight To Nowhere  

Review by centurymeyer35Mail Icon
In affiliation with The Power Reviewers Group  
Rated: E | (5.0)
I like it! An interesting take on the unsuspecting boatman or the oblivious angel of death.

I think we all kind of knew where this was going, but (no pun intended) we enjoyed the trip.

I think the exploration here is not so much how one gets from here to the hereafter as much as the confusion, denial, acceptance, and inevitability of death. The little things matter, the little things are what cause the greater things that lead to the final things. Being late. Picking up Teddy. Checking a text. Not balancing the ladder because it will only be a second. Etc, etc... And in the final event, we
must be faced with some sort of confusion, mustn't we? When we hit our head on the corner or the cabinet, aren't we dazed for a second? Well how about when our soul is knocked clear of our worldly husk?!

Obviously, the topic is very interesting to me, thus I found this twilight-zone-ish story very engaging.

I am always a fan of cyclic writing, as well. I use the same device in
The Long Caravan (it's on here; look it up if you want). Because life is as cyclical as death is final. And Life-in-Death, having given up Her grip on the Ancient Mariner, perhaps, now has James circling the terminal (double meaning definitely intended) ferrying the dead to...wherever.

Great piece. Succinct and interesting, I would recommend this to anyone. No need to remind you, but goodness, my friend: Write On!




This review offered by
Jeffrey

*Strong**Floral1*WDC Power Reviewers Group*Floral1**Explode*

Image for reviews and emailsQuill 2025 Nominee

Please note that my reviews are intended to be
respectful and encouraging.
If you feel I have been rude, cruel,
or otherwise inappropriate,
please report this review to a moderator.


 



7
7

Review of Perpetually Purple  

Review by centurymeyer35Mail Icon
In affiliation with The Power Reviewers Group  
Rated: E | (4.0)
Charles,

As usual, your unique perspective gives us a window into a truly strange scene!

The opening lines are great, and they drew me right in. Something about the aristocracy denying reality so that they can go on being "proper" is very realistic. It's also so absurd as to be comical, which you articulate well here.
Well, yeah, they're violets, but not the whole plant!

Excellent way to tell us as the reader what was going on without coming out and saying it as exposition. Chesterton's battle against the impropriety of the virulent violets is humorous and engaging.
It ruins our perfect mountain view!

Again, the realistic absurdity of form over function is a perfect detail for this story!

Giovanni, the absent-minded scientist, is a great character. His penchant for thinking in rhyme is a great detail that gives him a singular personality.

One wonders what the main point of the story is, aside from its humor. Who's the hero? What is gained? Is there a message or moral? Personally, I don't think the story suffers for this potential ambiguity; I'm happy with it just being a funny story.

Let me offer one constructive criticism, however: blank lines between paragraphs allow the readers' eyes to rest while reading. It's less intimidating that a huge dark black of text. I would encourage you to take this into consideration moving forward. (You almost lost a half-star for it, but this was more than a three-and-a-halfer, hand down.)

I thoroughly enjoyed your story, Charles. It was funny, tongue-in-cheek realistic, and wackily absurd. I'm glad you offered this for our enjoyment!


This review offered by
Jeffrey
——————————
*Strong**Floral1*"The Power Reviewers Group*Floral1**Explode*


~Click here to join a fun reviewing group~Quill 2025 Nominee

Please note that my reviews are intended to be
respectful and encouraging.
If you feel I have been rude, cruel,
or otherwise inappropriate,
please report this review to a moderator.





 
8
8

Review of The Crystal Image  

Review by centurymeyer35Mail Icon
In affiliation with The Power Reviewers Group  
Rated: 18+ | (4.0)
O,

This is a nice little story of self-fulfilling prophecy. Aside from the content, which I'll get to in a minute, I liked the way you built the end into the middle. Brian seeing the future and
causing the future was played well. We do indeed reap what we sow, and Brian sowed only seeds of suspicion or mistrust. What I liked was that he didn't get in return exactly what he put out there. Caroline didn't become the bad guy based on Brian's visions; Brian himself became the villain and caused the vision he saw to become an eventual reality. Another interesting facet was that he never saw himself and Caroline in the ball, hinting to the reader that he was never wholesomely in love with his wife to begin with. One could infer that the casual love in a marriage, which sometimes seems to supplant true deep emotional connection, is more corrosive than (and can eventually lead to) active negative emotions.

Let me give you a detailed run-down of the elements of your story as they struck me.


*Right* Introduction *Star**Star**Star**HalfStar* ▶︎
*Tree2* Setting *Star**Star**Star**Star* ▶︎
*Man* Characters *Star**Star**Star**Star* ▶︎
*Reading* Plot/Arc *Star**Star**Star**Star* ▶︎
*Gear* Mechanics *Star**Star**Star**Star**Star* ▶︎
*Stop* Conclusion *Star**Star**Star**Star**HalfStar* ▶︎
*Construction* Constructive Comments ▶︎

This was a quick, enjoyable read reminding us not to be too hasty in what we only think we knowand not to be a meathead in general! *Laugh* With stories like this, the reader certainly does hope to read more; so I hope you Write On!

This review offered by
Jeffrey
——————————
*Strong**Floral1*"The Power Reviewers Group*Floral1**Explode*


~Click here to join a fun reviewing group~Quill 2025 Nominee

Please note that my reviews are intended to be
respectful and encouraging.
If you feel I have been rude, cruel,
or otherwise inappropriate,
please report this review to a moderator.





 
9
9

Review of The Resurrection Machine  

Review by centurymeyer35Mail Icon
In affiliation with The Power Reviewers Group  
Rated: E | (5.0)
Lonewolf,

I'm so glad you decided to enter this into the Adam West contest this month. This was a great story! It was original and engaging, and I was hooked from the beginning.

The idea of ancient technology is fascinating to me! I once wondered, if you drem a line from Stone Henge to the center of the Mayan civilizatiojns, and from the mysterious mounds in the United Styates midwest to the Egyption pyramids, could the intersection of those lines represent the whereabouts of sunken Atlantis? Interesting...but not as interesting as your Resurrection Machine. Let's take a look at what makes this thing tick.

*Right* Introduction ▶︎
*Tree2* Setting ▶︎
*Man* Characters ▶︎
*Reading* Plot/Arc ▶︎
*Gear* Mechanics ▶︎
*Stop* Conclusion ▶︎


This was a great take on the title. It was original in the extreme, engaging, and really interesting! The cure for death has obsessed humankind for millennia. The solution to the problem, found in ancient sources, makes one wonder why it was lost in the first place. Even though Marcus and Kenneth don't want it to be forgotten again, maybe it was hidden in the past for good reason. For if we all can live forever, what new hell would
that unleash?

Thanks for this awesome entry, my friend!


This review offered by
Jeffrey
——————————
*Strong**Floral1*"The Power Reviewers Group*Floral1**Explode*


~Click here to join a fun reviewing group~ Image #2333342 over display limit. -?-

Please note that my reviews are intended to be
respectful and encouraging.
If you feel I have been rude, cruel,
or otherwise inappropriate,
please report this review to a moderator.





 
10
10

Review of A Face for Murder  

Review by centurymeyer35Mail Icon
In affiliation with The Power Reviewers Group  
Rated: E | (3.5)
Silvern,

You paint a dark, dystopian world in this. I wonder if it reflects your worldview or if it's purely fiction. It's always interesting for me to ponder how much of the story is the author's own view/experience, and how much is made up. I'd like to share with you what I got out of your story and to offer some observations along the way.


*Right* Introduction *Star**Star**Star**HalfStar* ▶︎
*Tree2* Setting *Star**Star**Star* ▶︎
*Man* Characters *Star**Star**Star**HalfStar* ▶︎
*Reading* Plot/Arc *Star**Star**Star* ▶︎
*Gear* Mechanics *Star**Star**Star**Star* ▶︎
*Stop* Conclusion *Star**Star**Star**Star* ▶︎

Though this carried a dark tone throughout, it was a thought-provoking story about a Government out of control. As the government here in US takes an increasingly and alarmingly greater and greater degree of control, this is a timely piece for me to read.

Whether it be about darkness or light, oppression or hope, Write On, my friend!


This review offered by
Jeffrey
——————————
*Strong**Floral1*"The Power Reviewers Group*Floral1**Explode*


~Click here to join a fun reviewing group~ Image #2333342 over display limit. -?-

Please note that my reviews are intended to be
respectful and encouraging.
If you feel I have been rude, cruel,
or otherwise inappropriate,
please report this review to a moderator.





 
11
11

Review of Unquenchable Desire  

Review by centurymeyer35Mail Icon
In affiliation with The Power Reviewers Group  
Rated: E | (4.5)
Raskolnik,

This has a dark undercurrent that keeps it interesting and ends it on a slightly uncomfortable note
to its strength. It hearkens to the obsession of fans to their pop idols; but here, that obsession is to the tune of pop idols. The reader can easily identify (this reader, at least) with the haughty look the stewardess gives the narrator of the story. The unattainable dream is a common theme for all of us. But the fixation on that dream often erodes the mind and eclipses the goal itself, the obsession becoming its own self-feeding animal.

Very nice short about how easily we can get lost in the chase of a dream.

--Jeffrey
12
12

Review of Walking the Wild Cheese  

Review by centurymeyer35Mail Icon
In affiliation with The Power Reviewers Group  
Rated: E | (5.0)
Lonewolf,

This is an absolutely charming tale of what adventure feels like to a young person. It brings back to me memories of my own adventures. I didn't need to go anywhere nearly as exotic as the Swiss Alps; there was a little belt line of trees down the road from my house was, in my imagination, an entire unknown forest for me to explore.

The positive and gentle way the adult in this story communicates with the children is so important. It reminds us that not everything has to be vulgar or scary to be intense. Just his cadence, lowering his voice, the glint the reader can see in his eyes
all these things make for a great storytelling.

I was impressed that you chose this title. For one thing, it has very personal origins. Our chihuahua, who passed only a few months ago, was nicknamed "The Cheese." When he was wearing his collar, he was a domesticated animal. But when he had no collar on, he was "wild." So, if you could get Cheeko to walk with you with no collar or leash, you were "walking the wild Cheese." But trying to make that into story... It's not a challenge
I would have quickly accepted! *Smile*

The adventure you set up was so interesting, with the cheeses being set loose into the wild. I can't even put my finger on why it works so well, but somehow, releasing the cheeses into the wild, giving them volition of their own, giving them an allure for adventureres...well, I might as well have been in class with the rest of the kids. I was hanging on every word.

Also very interesting is how much more can be found on an adventure, as you demonstrate. The true find was not the cheese, but the love. But that never would have been found without risk, without being willing to sacrifice something, without giving unto another. And isn't a relationship with another person the greatest adventure of all? And that's what I take from this story
not the love of adventure, but the love of love, and the lengths we sometimes have to go to find it.

Mechanically, I thought this was done very well. It's mostly dialog-driven, which can be difficult (for me, at least). You managed to keep the dialog from getting confusing or boring by using short lines, as one
would with children. And your insertions of their reactions was perfect. Say a few words; see the reaction; another few words; a new reaction... Really good technique, and great pacing. Spelling and punctuation all seemed goodI didn't find any wild commas wandering around with the cheeses. *Wink*

The end was quite clever, I think, and quite instructive. It hints to the reader that adventure can be found anywhere, even in the most mundane of things. It's all about how you look at things. A first is a first, even if it's "just" a trip to Red Lobster. We can make anything full of wonder for our children, and thus grow them into
people who are full of wonder. If abuse has a generational cycle, so does nurturing.

This was a very nice story, sir. Thank you so much for reminding us to view life through the eyes of wonder.



This review offered by
Jeffrey

*Strong**Floral1*WDC Power Reviewers Group*Floral1**Explode*

Image for reviews and emails Image #2333342 over display limit. -?-

Please note that my reviews are intended to be
respectful and encouraging.
If you feel I have been rude, cruel,
or otherwise inappropriate,
please report this review to a moderator.


 

13
13

Review of Dawn Duo  

Review by centurymeyer35Mail Icon
In affiliation with The Power Reviewers Group  
Rated: E | (4.5)
Raskolnik,

This is an interesting little snapshot. A brief ethereal glimpse into earth at her most honest, you managed to avoid a lot of the more common tropes. Even what could be taken for dryads were handled well.
"...naked, not obscene; stripped of all excess, even shame."

I thought this was a brilliant line. It stripped all vulgarity from the scene and made it as innocent as the day before Eve took that fateful first bite.

The way the "spirits" appeared and then disappeared fit the piece well, almost like it was an hallucination brought on by fatigue. Strauss was an interesting choice. One might have expected lute or flute to accompany such an event, probably due to historical portrayals; the more concrete and human music is somewhat puzzling, but by no means takes away from the story.

This is a nice vignette of nature at her most pure and potent; and the thought of going back to work to complete anything as real or meaningful as the scene being nothing short of ludicrous.

Nice job.

--Jeffrey (Power Reviewers' Group)
14
14

Review of World Was  

Review by centurymeyer35Mail Icon
In affiliation with The Power Reviewers Group  
Rated: E | (4.5)
Mr. Greene,

This was a good little story. I like the idea of a black hole in a wormhole. Unique idea (at least to me). It was a good attention grabber.

*Person* Bahb and Errl aren't very well defined in this story, though; this is more of a cautionary parable to us readers not to kill ourselves by killing each other.

*Gear* Mechanically, I think you did well. I didn't find any glaring spelling or punctuation errors, and the organization was well thought out and presented.

I'll offer just a couple of constructive notes:
*Idea* Consider using wider line breaks, perhaps setting the line spacing to 2.0. The packed writing was a little uncomfortable to the eye.

*Idea* In the same vein, a larger font would make it easier to read on-screen, as well...at least to older buggers like me.

*Idea* Have another look at the synopsis. It sounds like it's going to be a goofy story, so the reader is kind of tripped up by the straight-up sci-fi of it. For me, it sounded like it was going to be a knock-ff of Hitchhiker's Guide to the Galaxy (which I'm glad it wasn't, because I hate that book).

I would, indeed, like to read a but more of the adventures of Bahb and Errl. This was a good story. Write On, sir!

This review offered by
Jeffrey

*Strong**Floral1*WDC Power Reviewers Group*Floral1**Explode*

Image for reviews and emails Image #2333342 over display limit. -?-

Please note that my reviews are intended to be
respectful and encouraging.
If you feel I have been rude, cruel,
or otherwise inappropriate,
please report this review to a moderator.


 

15
15

Review of On Thick Black Ice  

Review by centurymeyer35Mail Icon
In affiliation with The Power Reviewers Group  
Rated: E | (3.0)
Luna,

I rarely choose to review poetry because it is so subjective. But since you asked for a reaction, I thought I'd leave one.

I'm afraid I did not get an impact from this one. I
think it's about a romantic liaison with an exotic dancer, but I can't tell from what angle. I'm also not able to understand what the monsters are. Patrons? Vice squad? It's not clear to me what happened that was sad that ended this.

Again, I only offer these comments because you asked.

This review offered by
Jeffrey

*Strong**Floral1*WDC Power Reviewers Group*Floral1**Explode*

Image for reviews and emails Image #2333342 over display limit. -?-

Please note that my reviews are intended to be
respectful and encouraging.
If you feel I have been rude, cruel,
or otherwise inappropriate,
please report this review to a moderator.


 

16
16

Review of Crash Course in Responsibility  

Review by centurymeyer35Mail Icon
In affiliation with The Power Reviewers Group  
Rated: E | (4.0)
I was sure the guy driving the car was going to have been his boss. But then, that's my luck.

You did a great job describing a chronic drunk. "Smelling like last night's bar tab" was a good turn of phrase.

At least he finally got some trust back at the end!

Fun piece, my friend.
17
17

Review of Five Stars For Everything  

Review by centurymeyer35Mail Icon
Rated: E | (5.0)
Interesting outlook. Personally, I prefer to use the rating system, but I never give fewer than three stars. That's reserved for something that's too dense it error-filled to make sense. Sometimes someone will request a review. THEN I take it very seriously. If it's going to be a brutal review -- honeys, but brutal-- I'll send them an email first and ask them if they want me to continue.

I didn't mind getting varying stars, myself. It helps me to re-examine what I've write and see what I could do better. But that's just me.

18
18

Review of Earning His Stripes WC 200  

Review by centurymeyer35Mail Icon
In affiliation with The Power Reviewers Group  
Rated: E | (5.0)
Oh yeah. You GOT to earn your stripes. I have one son who thinks he should just walk into a job and everybody should just automatically respect and revere him. I keep telling him: "You gotta put your time in in the trenches, son!" I don't know if he'll ever learn.

For my part, I'm happy to do whatever the Company needs, even if it's emptying trashcans at the end of the day. And it's not out of fear of being fired; I just love the place I work.

I like this story reminding us that menial work doesn't have to be meaningless work. Nice job.

--Jeffrey
19
19

Review of Adventures in Literary Esoterica  

for entry "Opus
Review by centurymeyer35Mail Icon
In affiliation with The Power Reviewers Group  
Rated: 18+ | (5.0)
Jeff,

This is a nice take on the "inside job" theme. Modern art being what it is, I can easily see this being an installation in a gallery. The less I understand it, apparently, the better the art is considered! Nice job turning the story in those last couple of lines. I didn't see it coming which made the destination that much more enjoyable.

Great job!
--Jeffrey
20
20

Review of Getting a Wife...........  

Review by centurymeyer35Mail Icon
In affiliation with The Power Reviewers Group  
Rated: E | (4.5)
I certainly see the humor in this. It's rather strongly tongue-in-cheek, japing every stereotypical "old-fashioned" thought about women. That old dad wants sonny to bring the woman home for him emphasizes a generation gap and a difference in thinking between father and son, although this is mostly implied. The son is not the misogynist here; dad is. The son is just relating the nonsense his father spouted.

Quite nice for just a bit of fun, especially as it is in the context of a larger story and cant really be taken at face value as a standalone piece.

Nice rhyme and meter, to offer some mechanical notes. It read smoothly and quickly, without too much thought having to go into it, which is comfortable for the reader.

Fun work, my friend!


This review offered by
Jeffrey

*Strong**Floral1*WDC Power Reviewers Group*Floral1**Explode*

Image for reviews and emails Image #2333342 over display limit. -?-

Please note that my reviews are intended to be
respectful and encouraging.
If you feel I have been rude, cruel,
or otherwise inappropriate,
please report this review to a moderator.


 
21
21

Review of Grandma Rosewood  

Review by centurymeyer35Mail Icon
In affiliation with The Power Reviewers Group  
Rated: E | (4.0)
Lonewolf,

Your flair for metaphor and simile shine through again in this piece. "A rainbow caught in mid stride
" What an exquisite image. Even without the magic, it's a perfect way to capture the beauty of a sunset. The thought of witches being good as well as evil has been often explored, but is still the minority view. It is nice to read a story where the magic is clean and pure, and witches work only to heal the world. I wish more ordinary people would try to do the same.

Very nice story, sir.

--Jeffrey
22
22

Review of Valentine's Day  

Review by centurymeyer35Mail Icon
In affiliation with The Power Reviewers Group  
Rated: E | (5.0)
My goodness! You captured that nervous indecision just right! I've been there so many times. Honestly, I usually freeze up and botch the moment. But this is about John, and John lucked out in the extreme. The heart does indeed make the right choices for us sometimes. All the presents in the world weren't as valuable to Cynthia as just having John. And tagging on a long-lasting marriage which is no mean feat was a nice closer.

Great writing, my friend.

--Jeffrey
23
23

Review of Sarah Ebon  

Review by centurymeyer35Mail Icon
In affiliation with The Power Reviewers Group  
Rated: ASR | N/A (Review only item.)
Nick,

This is a warmhearted trip down memory lane
both for you and for the reader. I remember playing the same games, reading the same books. I didn't have a Sarah Ebon by my side though; it would have been so much better, I can see from your poem, if I had. An ode to an old friend, this speaks volumes about love.

I must confess, though, I was a little confused by the last line. I'm not sure if this is a eulogy to a friend who has passed or a living note of appreciation and thanks, looking forward to more years of friendship. I'm not sure if you intended that ambiguity or not, so I wanted to point it out.

One mechanical note I'd like to point out: the almost-rhythm is a tricky. In many lines, there is a meter, but that meter fails after three or four lines and moves to something very different. The broken timing really tripped me up; perhaps tightening it down to a truer tempo would alleviate that.

This is very nice poem about something I don't read much about: simple friendship
not romantic love and bitterness or loneliness; just the simple joy of a great friend. Nicely done.



This review offered by
Jeffrey

*Strong**Floral1*WDC Power Reviewers Group*Floral1**Explode*

Image for reviews and emails Image #2333342 over display limit. -?-

Please note that my reviews are intended to be
respectful and encouraging.
If you feel I have been rude, cruel,
or otherwise inappropriate,
please report this review to a moderator.


 
24
24

Review of Last Year On Fire  

Review by centurymeyer35Mail Icon
In affiliation with The Power Reviewers Group  
Rated: E | (4.0)
Emberly,

This is a deeply personal poem you've shared with us. One can identify, at least to some extent, the frustration of good intentions achieving exactly the wrong goals and hopes being proven futile over and over again.

This quote resonated with me, as I have a son who struggles with mental issues and substance abuse (clean for now, thankfully):
I cried alone while my son laughed somewhere else,
like my grief was invisible air he didn’t need to breathe.

When our pain goes unheeded and we are alone with our grief, the pit just seems to get so much deeper.

The structure you've chosen, such as it is, fits the mood. Your choice to use so many short lines works well here. Each one is like a little cut, and they all add up to a thousand little cuts that slowly bleed the soul. But in the end, the cuts heal. They leave scars, but they didn't bleed you dry. You survived.

Then again, survival is sometimes both a blessing
and a curse, in my experience anyway. One day feels victorious, but the next day feels like so much wasted effort trying to kick water uphill. I get the same sense lurking between the lines here.

I quite enjoyed this poem that I can only hope was cathartic to write.


This review offered by
Jeffrey

*Strong**Floral1*WDC Power Reviewers Group*Floral1**Explode*

Image for reviews and emails Image #2333342 over display limit. -?-

Please note that my reviews are intended to be
respectful and encouraging.
If you feel I have been rude, cruel,
or otherwise inappropriate,
please report this review to a moderator.


 
25
25

Review of Jared  

Review by centurymeyer35Mail Icon
In affiliation with The Power Reviewers Group  
Rated: E | (5.0)
Jared,

This is fantastic, man. The message of hope by itself is to be lauded, especially from someone like myself who tends to find the shadows on the sunniest of days. But beyond than, there's some great writing in such a short piece.
*Thought* "like a heartbeat relearning its pace" This was such a great analogy. for me it turned the sound of a hammer into the sound of many hammers. It was like adding stereo to a mono track.

*Thought* "the smell of wet ash" I often read of the smell of ash, the smell of brunt cloth, burnt wood. But the sodden, nasty smell of wet ash is so memorably pungent, such a smell of something have been extinguished, like the hope of the village. It's just such an important detail, and slipped in like a minor chord you didn't realize you heard until your eyes start to tear up.

*Thought* "he had a plan and a blister" A perfect way of stating that Jared was participating in healing his vision (ergo the blister) and that he was moving forward toward a leadership role, a forward-looking role. It uses Jared as that major chord, that positive note that represents the potential of recovery, whether its a town that's broken or a person or a person's spirit: with hard work and a sharp mind, there is such a thing as "forward."

I am very impressed by this short piece, thought not surprised, given much of your other work. Still, I think this would stand tall in many a contest.

What a joy to read, and a great way to start my day. What a way to Write On!


TThis review offered by
Jeffrey

*Strong**Floral1*WDC Power Reviewers Group*Floral1**Explode*

Image for reviews and emails Image #2333342 over display limit. -?-

Please note that my reviews are intended to be
respectful and encouraging.
If you feel I have been rude, cruel,
or otherwise inappropriate,
please report this review to a moderator.