hey, missy!
all right, here's #3--
this story was a blast--one of the strongest openings i've read in a long time, by anyone, published or not. wonderful tension, had that hairtrigger feel to it. outstanding.
""I need for you to listen to me, please. That's what I need, right now; you, listening to me. It's the only way forward. Can you do that? Can we try to understand one another? Can you listen?"
Corvey licked a bead of salty sweat from his upper lip and nodded, unblinkingly, at the olive skinned young man in front of him. "Yes. Yes, I can do that." His voice sounded more confident than he felt. "But I need you to listen to me first. Do we have a deal?"
"Go ahead, but you should know that my arms are getting tired and we don't want that to lead to any unpleasantness now, do we?""
we know right off these two men feel desperate as they negotiate with each other, almost begging the other to stay cool. we don't have a hint of the stakes, though, until the last line above about ". . . any unpleasantness . . .". good trip word. it's a cliche, but a strong and exciting one--i wondered for a moment if mobsters were involved, because of the pop culture associations with the phrase.
i wonder if moving mention of the gun barrel right to the fore would clarify the situation just a bit more? maybe i'm being too american about it, but a gun barrel in a first sentence will grab anyone's attention, i'll wager.
"Corvey looked down at the cold, grey, metal barrel of the twelve bore shot gun and shook his head so slightly that only his greying curls moved. He tore his gaze away from its dispassionate end to the conversation and looked once more at the man beyond it.
"This is my home." He began, looking for a way to convey all that the simple statement implied. "I'm retired. I have lost more people in my life than I have gained. The world is full of horror and fear, but not (and this is what I really need you to grasp), but not here. This is all I have. My home. My sanctuary. My little piece of England. You scare me. You have invaded my sanctuary.""
you create a wonderful feint, leading us down a somewhat expected path--we think we know what's going on, here. a young man, desperate for goods and/or money, has broken into an older man's home. we assume. you play on our tendencies well, and the potential horror of the situation boosts your feint. very well done.
" . . . twelve bore shot gun . . .": i think "twelve bore" should likely be hyphenated, and that "shot gun" is one word.
your writing is so clear, so efficient--no wasted words, and your dialogue feels very real in the rhythm of speech and repetition of particular words. the desperation (keep using that word, don't i?) comes through in their words and your details (beads of sweat).
i loved: ". . . its dispassionate end . . ." chilling, and we can easily imagine facing the possibility ourselves. oof. i also liked your quick description of each character--enough specifics to keep them separate in our minds as we read, but not so much the tension drains out of the story. difficult to pull off.
"Corvey paused. His eye was ticking and another bead of sweat was forming at the end of his nose, but he felt stronger now, somehow. "Just leave. Don't ever come back. We don't need to get the police involved." His eyes flickered toward the gun and he wished it away.
The young man looked at him quizzically. "And so that's it, is it? We had a deal. Now you listen; I have nothing and it doesn't matter. I only want to use what other people don't use. See this wall?" He dipped his head toward it and readjusted his grip. "Is this really you keeping people like me out? The world will allways be out there and this wall is just a tomb to you. Something penning you in and cutting you off from the world."
"But it's my wall," whispered Corvey.
"Only from your side," laughed the young man.
"You're a vandal. You'll break it.""
the dialogue here is great! feels like a real conversation, the give and take. i liked very much the different positions on "home" these men have--one built on security, the other on freedom.
you also convey the ebb and flow of the men's emotions through their words. ""But it's my wall,"" is plaintive, almost childlike, and that corvey's whispering at this point is powerful. i couldn't wait to find out what happened next.
i did think something was different, here. the path i thought this story was moving along suddenly felt not as familiar--what was this young man wanting this wall for, anyway? why is the wall such a big deal? i assumed he wanted stuff. i love that tingle of perking up at a turn in a story. i was gripped before, caught up in the tension & emotion, and now my brain was working, too. you woke me all the way up.
"feeling the blood ooze back into protesting muscles"
is an awesome description. just had to point that out. these characters feel so real because of bits like this. their humanity is so clear.
i admit, after discovering the young man's true intention, i was a bit de-energized. a clever and completely believable conclusion, for sure, but after the tension and excitement, i guess i was hoping for a more life & death solution--that the assumed struggle between these men was the actual struggle, and that they really were fighting for their respective beliefs in what "sanctuary" was. that their needs were opposed and exclusive of the other's--if one man got what he wanted, the other would necessarily lose out. i wanted to discover a solution to that situation, and the one presented was real, and true, but not quite as groundbreaking as i'd been wanting. jeez, i hope this makes sense.
"The young man raised his eyebrows and looked at the gun.
Corvey shrugged, 'Well I'm glad we talked."
"So am I. Can I use your wall?""
i loved the raised eyebrows--funny and eloquent. and placing these two back in their original positions-- talking about the wall-- but without the same tension between them, made a satisfying end to the story. felt almost like a stage play, in that respect.
you are so good with twists, and following the path of your story was delightful--your writing's so good, acme. seriously. thanks for another wonderful read!
|
|