WriterRick's (rick12221) Reviews

WriterRick

Review Requests: ON

967 Public Reviews Given

986 Total Reviews Given

1

Credit this reviewer

#4795836

Review of The Invisible Thread

Review by WriterRick

In affiliation with WdC SuperPower Reviewers Group

Rated: E

| (5.0)

This introduction is thought-provoking and ambitious, setting the stage for a deep exploration of humanity's connection to the universe. It successfully captures the reader's attention by weaving together ancient myths, philosophical inquiries, and modern scientific concepts. However, a few aspects could be refined to strengthen its impact:

Strengths:

Engaging Opening: The introduction starts powerfully, invoking humanity's timeless curiosity about the universe. The mention of myths, philosophies, and scientific discoveries immediately draws readers in.
Broad Appeal: By referencing a wide range of ideas—from Mesopotamian stargazing to quantum mechanics—the text bridges diverse perspectives, appealing to readers interested in both the spiritual and the scientific.
Fluid Transitions: The narrative transitions smoothly between historical contexts and modern ideas, creating a cohesive argument about interconnectedness.
Call to Action: The urgency to explore universal truths and address global crises (e.g., environmental issues) gives the introduction relevance and purpose.
Areas for Improvement:

Focus: The scope of the introduction is broad, which might overwhelm some readers. Narrowing the focus to a few key themes could make the argument more digestible. For example, rather than listing multiple cultures and philosophies, you could highlight two or three that exemplify the points most strongly.
Clarity: Some sentences are dense and layered, which may hinder readability. Simplifying these sections can help maintain the reader's engagement, especially for those less familiar with philosophical or scientific terminology.
Tone Consistency: While the tone is generally reflective, there are moments where it feels overly formal. A slightly more conversational tone could help readers connect with the material on a personal level.
Specificity: Phrases like "profound truths" and "interwoven fabric of existence" are compelling but somewhat abstract. Offering concrete examples or previews of the journey ahead can ground the narrative.
Suggestions:

Reframe the Central Question: Early on, explicitly state the main question driving the exploration. This will give readers a clear sense of direction.
Balance Complexity: Introduce complex ideas gradually, ensuring each concept is explained simply before moving on to the next.
Relate to Readers: Include a sentence or two that connects these universal themes to everyday experiences, helping readers see how this journey relates to their own lives.
Overall, this introduction sets a solid foundation for a captivating and meaningful exploration. With slight refinements in focus, tone, and clarity, it can become even more powerful and engaging.

WriterRick (WdC SuperPower Reviewers Group)

My review has been submitted for consideration in "Good Deeds Get CASH!" .

2

Credit this reviewer

#4795835

Review of Blessings

Review by WriterRick

In affiliation with WdC SuperPower Reviewers Group

Rated: E

| (5.0)

This short piece has a tranquil and meditative feel, like a prayer or a moment of quiet reflection. The structure is minimal and freeform, which works well to convey a sense of simplicity and sincerity. However, there are areas where the language could be slightly refined to enhance the flow and emotional resonance.

Here are some thoughts:

Imagery: The words "light" and "candle" create a visual that feels serene. You might expand on this to deepen the emotional connection. For example, consider describing the candle's glow or how it symbolizes warmth and hope.

Emotion: Phrases like "feel your heart" and "blessings that abound" evoke gratitude. To make this even more impactful, you could add sensory details—how does the heart feel in this moment of blessing?

Structure: The freeform style is effective, but the flow might benefit from minor adjustments. For example:

"Feel your heart / For the blessings" could be rewritten as "Feel your heart's embrace / of blessings," creating a softer rhythm.
Title: If this is part of a larger work or intended to stand alone, a title like Blessings by Candlelight or Light and Grace could add an inviting touch.

Overall, this piece captures a peaceful and reflective mood but could benefit from richer imagery or a touch more detail to immerse the reader fully in the moment.

WriterRick (WdC SuperPower Reviewers Group)

My review has been submitted for consideration in "Good Deeds Get CASH!" .

3

Credit this reviewer

#4795834

Review of Paperwork

Review by WriterRick

In affiliation with WdC SuperPower Reviewers Group

Rated: E

| (5.0)

This story, titled Paperwork, is an enjoyable blend of humor and light horror, effectively delivering an unexpected twist that adds intrigue and an amusing moral. Here’s an overall review:

Strengths:
Atmosphere and Tone:
The opening sets a vivid mood with stormy weather, creating an eerie and suspenseful tone that draws the reader in. The description of thunder, lightning, and pouring rain is well-executed and helps establish the story's mood.

Humor:
The humor tied to unfinished paperwork and its ghostly consequences is creative and makes the story stand out. The punchline at the end ties the narrative together and leaves readers smiling.

Pacing:
The buildup of suspense, from the initial scream to the investigation of the clerical room, is well-paced. It keeps the reader engaged as the tension escalates.

Surprise Twist:
The fake prank followed by the unexpected final scream is an effective twist. Just when readers think the mystery is resolved, the story leaves them with a chilling (and humorous) ending.

Areas for Improvement:
Character Development:
The story could benefit from giving a bit more personality to the characters. For example, fleshing out Bridgett’s role beyond her single line would make her more relatable.

Dialogue Flow:
Some of the dialogue, while functional, could feel more natural. For instance, “Stop! Don’t come any closer!” and “How could you do this to us?” could be rephrased to sound less formal and more conversational.

Clarity in the Ending:
The ending is deliberately ambiguous, which works for the mystery, but it might help to hint more strongly at whether the final scream was supernatural or part of the prank. This would ensure readers are left intrigued rather than confused.

Moral Integration:
While the moral is funny, its delivery could feel more integrated into the story. Mentioning the importance of completing paperwork earlier in the narrative might help tie the moral to the plot more cohesively.

Final Thoughts:
Paperwork is a fun, quirky tale with a clever concept and a memorable punchline. Strengthening the characters and polishing the dialogue would make it even more impactful, but as it stands, it’s an entertaining and lighthearted read with just the right amount of creepiness.

WriterRick (WdC SuperPower Reviewers Group)

My review has been submitted for consideration in "Good Deeds Get CASH!" .

4

Credit this reviewer

#4795546

Review of Unicorns and Luck

Review by WriterRick

In affiliation with WdC SuperPower Reviewers Group

Rated: E

| (5.0)

This is a charming and engaging fantasy story with a strong fairy tale feel. The premise of a young rabbit on a quest to save his burrow is delightful, and the elements of unicorns, leprechauns, and magical weather create a rich, whimsical world. Below are my thoughts on strengths and areas for improvement.

Strengths:
Engaging Worldbuilding: The concept of Bunny Burrow being dependent on a unicorn’s blessing is unique, and the details about magic weakening over time add depth to the setting.
Skip’s Character Arc: His transition from an uncertain adolescent to a hero willing to take responsibility for his burrow is well-paced and natural.
Classic Fantasy Elements: The inclusion of a hidden unicorn, a tricky leprechaun, and the idea of using a birthday wish as a magical key make the story feel timeless and immersive.
Dialogue Feels Natural: The characters, especially Skip, Troy, and Liam, have distinct voices that match their personalities.
Areas for Improvement:
Stronger Emotional Impact:

Skip agrees to the quest almost instantly. Adding a bit more internal hesitation or struggle would make his journey feel more impactful.
The sense of urgency could be heightened with descriptions of how dire things have become in Bunny Burrow (e.g., rabbits starving, homes buried in snow).
More Tension in Key Moments:

The scene where Troy tries to enter the burrow during the storm could use more sensory details. How does the wind feel? Does Skip hear the howling of desperate rabbits?
The interaction with the leprechaun is fun, but his agreement comes too easily. Maybe he tricks them first or sets up a test before giving them his luck.
Sentence Structure & Flow:

Some sentences could be restructured for smoother readability. For example:
"It was her who guided him into the council chamber." → "She was the one who guided him into the council chamber."
Watch for minor grammatical errors, such as missing commas or run-on sentences.
A More Satisfying Ending:

The resolution happens very quickly once Troy restores the magic. Consider adding a small epilogue where Skip reflects on his journey, or the council acknowledges him as more than just a young rabbit.
Final Thoughts:
This is a fantastic and imaginative story that feels like a modern fairy tale. With a little fine-tuning, it could be even stronger, especially in terms of emotional stakes and pacing. Keep up the great work!

WriterRick (WdC SuperPower Reviewers Group)

My review has been submitted for consideration in "Good Deeds Get CASH!" .

5

Credit this reviewer

#4795545

Review of Kentucky Sunbeam

Review by WriterRick

In affiliation with WdC SuperPower Reviewers Group

Rated: E

| (5.0)

The imagery is light and warm—“The air was warm and dry,” “Clouds parted, rays shone,”—which helps set a peaceful mood. The shift from past sadness to present happiness is subtle, making the moment feel natural rather than forced. The last stanza is particularly effective, as it personalizes the experience by bringing in someone else ("Thanked you for singing along."). This adds depth, making the happiness feel shared rather than solitary.

One minor suggestion: consider varying the phrasing of "I guess it was a good day!" in one or two stanzas to keep the repetition from becoming predictable. For example, "Today turned out just right!" or "A day I won’t forget!" could add variety while maintaining the theme.

Overall, this is a feel-good poem that captures the beauty of small, happy moments. It’s simple, heartfelt, and relatable.

WriterRick (WdC SuperPower Reviewers Group)

My review has been submitted for consideration in "Good Deeds Get CASH!" .

6

Credit this reviewer

#4795384

Review of Road Runner 9

Review by WriterRick

In affiliation with WdC SuperPower Reviewers Group

Rated: E

| (5.0)

This short piece captures the essence of determination and perseverance in a race. The narrator’s simple, straightforward style gives the story a raw and relatable feel. The focus on physical sensations—pumping arms, soaked shirt, pounding heat—helps pull the reader into the experience of the race.

The stumble near the finish line adds a moment of tension, making the final push to cross more satisfying. It’s a small but effective conflict that keeps the piece from being too straightforward. The ending is lighthearted and unexpected, with the mention of "food races," which might refer to fun runs often linked to eating contests or themed events. If that's the case, it could use a bit more context to clarify.

Some areas could be refined for flow. For instance, “The number 9 sign stuck to my shirt” could be smoother, maybe as “The number 9 stuck to my shirt.” Similarly, “fell on flat on my face” has an extra “on.” Small tweaks like these would improve readability.

Overall, this is a solid short piece with an engaging, relatable moment. It could benefit from slight clarifications and refinements, but it captures the physical and mental grind of a race well.

WriterRick (WdC SuperPower Reviewers Group)

My review has been submitted for consideration in "Good Deeds Get CASH!" .

7

Credit this reviewer

#4795382

Review of Cosmos's Months of the Year

Review by WriterRick

In affiliation with WdC SuperPower Reviewers Group

Rated: E

| (5.0)

Your piece captures the essence of each month with a mix of vivid imagery and humor. The tone is playful and engaging, making it an enjoyable read. Here are a few thoughts to enhance it further:

Consistency in Themes – Some months focus on nature (May, October, December), others on events (March, July, November), and some on personal struggles (April, August). Consider balancing these themes throughout for a more cohesive feel.

More Evocative Descriptions – "March launches March Madness" could be expanded beyond the sports reference to capture a broader sense of transition from winter to spring. Similarly, "July brings us July 4th picnics" could evoke fireworks, family gatherings, or the heat of mid-summer.

Refining Word Choice – "April the cruelest of all months - the tax man cometh for us all" is humorous, but "April is the cruelest month—the taxman looms over us all" would flow more smoothly.

A Stronger Ending – December’s line is good, but adding a final reflective touch could make it feel more complete, such as: December ends the year, snow covering the land in quiet remembrance.

Overall, it's a strong and creative reflection on the months. A little fine-tuning could make it even more poetic and memorable!

WriterRick (WdC SuperPower Reviewers Group)

My review has been submitted for consideration in "Good Deeds Get CASH!" .

8

Credit this reviewer

#4795000

Review of QUOTES AND WORDS OF WISDOM

Review by WriterRick

In affiliation with WdC SuperPower Reviewers Group

Rated: E

| (5.0)

This statement carries a strong, almost philosophical tone, emphasizing the significance of honor and the weight of surnames. However, the phrasing could be refined for clarity and impact. Here’s a slight revision:

"The surname of unpretentiousness is 'Honor.' Surnames shape the paths of their bearers—do not tarnish them!"

This keeps the original intent while improving readability and flow.

WriterRick (WdC SuperPower Reviewers Group)

My review has been submitted for consideration in "Good Deeds Get CASH!" .

9

Credit this reviewer

#4794998

Review of Puppet On A String

Review by WriterRick

In affiliation with WdC SuperPower Reviewers Group

Rated: E

| (5.0)

This piece does a great job of building suspense and eerie imagery. Here are some thoughts on how to refine it:

Strengths:
✅ Vivid Horror Imagery – The descriptions of the Thing’s face are chilling, especially the grinning mouth, missing features, and bubbling nose holes. The blending of unnatural elements (laser-like teeth, gnarling ears) makes it feel truly otherworldly.

✅ Strong Sensory Detail – The pounding heart, numbed muscles, and eerie sounds add to the tension. The protagonist’s fear is palpable.

✅ Surprising Twist – The sudden reveal of an auditorium and applause flips the scene unexpectedly, adding a layer of mystery.

Areas for Improvement:
🔹 Sentence Clarity & Flow – Some sentences feel cluttered or slightly awkward. For example:

"I was stiff. My muscles were numbed, cried out for comfort." → Could be smoother:
"I was stiff, my numbed muscles crying out for comfort."
🔹 Overloaded Descriptions – Some imagery is striking, but too many intense details in one place can overwhelm the reader. Consider simplifying a few, like:

"Its moonface was blotched and swollen as if it had a furious fight with a giant whose hands battered its face continuously."
→ "Its swollen moonface looked battered, as if a giant had pummeled it relentlessly."
🔹 Pacing of the Twist – The transition from sheer terror to an auditorium with applause is abrupt. Maybe adding a brief moment of disorientation before the reveal would help ease the shift.

Suggested Small Revision for Clarity & Impact:
"I felt my heart pounding, like deep drumbeats rising from within the earth. I dared not open my eyes. My body was stiff, my numbed muscles crying out for comfort. The night swirled around me, thick with darkness.

Yet, I saw its face clearly.

It grinned from ear to ear—though it had no ears, only slits that crackled and growled. Blackened teeth gleamed, flashing like sharp laser beams. It had no body, just the shifting silhouette of a humanoid. Its eyes, deep and red, flickered in and out of shadow. Where its nose should have been, two bubbling holes churned with burning liquid. Its swollen moonface looked battered, as if a giant had pummeled it relentlessly.

I screamed. The sound shattered the silence, echoing like an explosion inside me. My voice cracked and raw, I thought I heard eerie movements in the room. My body trembled, rolling from side to side, turning to stone.

Then—applause.

It rose and fell in waves. The lights came on…"

This keeps the eerie tone, smooths out some phrasing, and makes the reveal hit harder.

WriterRick (WdC SuperPower Reviewers Group)

My review has been submitted for consideration in "Good Deeds Get CASH!" .

10

Credit this reviewer

#4794997

Review of Pollution

Review by WriterRick

In affiliation with WdC SuperPower Reviewers Group

Rated: E

| (5.0)

Your poem has a sharp, rhythmic flow that effectively captures the tension between environmental concerns and economic interests. The brevity of each stanza enhances its impact, making each word feel deliberate. The rhyme scheme works well, reinforcing the cyclical nature of the issues you’re addressing.

A few things to consider:

The phrase "demanding thereof / solution" is slightly archaic in tone. You might make it more fluid by reordering it (e.g., "demanding a clear solution").
"Cash propagates / dilution" is strong, but "propagates" leans abstract. A more concrete verb might heighten the clarity.
The final stanza is particularly striking. The shift from "collusion" to "exclusion" lands well, reinforcing the idea of common sense being sidelined.
Overall, it's a tight, evocative piece with a powerful message.

WriterRick (WdC SuperPower Reviewers Group)

My review has been submitted for consideration in "Good Deeds Get CASH!" .

11

Credit this reviewer

#4794996

Review of Day 6 - 1.18.13

Review by WriterRick

In affiliation with WdC SuperPower Reviewers Group

Rated: E

| (5.0)

This piece has a stark, almost poetic quality that beautifully captures the desolation and quiet resilience of Celia and Marcel. The imagery is vivid, and despite the restrictions on words, you managed to paint a bleak yet emotionally charged setting.

Strengths:
Atmosphere & Tone – The contrast between longing for Monet-like pastels and the stark black-and-white reality is powerful. It enhances the feeling of loss and hardship.
Tension & Pacing – The short, fragmented lines mirror Celia's hesitancy and the slow, grueling passage of time.
Characterization – Even in this short piece, we understand Celia’s internal struggle and Marcel’s perseverance. Their bond is evident in the way they endure together.
Ending & Symbolism – The robin in the broken birdbath is a poignant and fitting symbol of hope amidst despair.
Areas for Consideration:
The prohibition of "cold, icy, snow" is creatively sidestepped, but phrases like “white in frigid air” and “blanketed in white” might feel like substitutes. If the prompt's intent was to avoid direct winter descriptions, you might push toward different sensory details.
The first two stanzas are beautifully poetic, but the phrasing can be slightly smoothed out for clarity without losing the artistry.
"Scarlet flash of cardinal / or was it blood?" is striking, but if "bird(s)" is forbidden, this might need reworking (though I love the ambiguity here).
Overall, this is a haunting and poetic piece that delivers strong emotions and stark survivalist imagery.

WriterRick (WdC SuperPower Reviewers Group)

My review has been submitted for consideration in "Good Deeds Get CASH!" .

12

Credit this reviewer

#4793783

Review of Book Lore

Review by WriterRick

In affiliation with WdC SuperPower Reviewers Group

Rated: E

| (5.0)

The lore you've created has a deep and fascinating foundation, full of conflict, intrigue, and moral complexity. The contrast between the Lightlings and Darklings is especially intriguing, with themes of betrayal, power struggles, and the consequences of unchecked ambition. The backstory of the entities—Corrosion, Salvation, Desperation, and Autonomy—adds a layer of philosophical depth, framing the world as a place where entities aren't just powerful beings but representations of opposing forces and ideas.

The world of Vulkon itself, with its cataclysmic events (The Volkuning) and the impact it has on its inhabitants, sets the stage for some serious drama. The fall of the Lightlings, their transformation, and the resulting backlash from the Darklings create a sense of constant tension. The Lightlings' hidden past and the inevitable repercussions of their actions offer great potential for plot development. There's a lot of potential for character-driven storytelling here, as the different groups grapple with their own histories and identities.

The introduction of unique races like the Treelings and Underlings enriches the world-building even more. The Treelings, with their deep spiritual connection to nature and their matriarchal society, feel like a people who could become a strong ally or enemy depending on the plot's direction. Their spiritual abilities and connection to their world also add an element of mysticism that balances the darker, more grounded elements of the story.

The Underlings, with their reverence for light and fire, add an interesting contrast to the other races. Their peaceful, non-confrontational nature doesn't make them weak, but rather resilient—surviving in harsh underground environments while staying true to their values.

The Lightlings’ tragic and flawed attempt to escape their past creates tension, and the gradual unraveling of their façade provides room for an exploration of guilt, denial, and the weight of history.

Your characters, especially the main characters from each group, seem well-positioned to explore these complex themes of redemption, power, and the costs of war. There's a lot of potential for intricate relationships, betrayal, and self-discovery as the characters deal with the consequences of their worlds’ past and their attempts to reshape their futures.

Overall, this lore presents a world brimming with conflict, mystery, and moral ambiguity—perfect for a rich, character-driven story with high stakes and deep emotional resonance.

WriterRick (WdC SuperPower Reviewers Group)

My review has been submitted for consideration in "Good Deeds Get CASH!" .

13

Credit this reviewer

#4793782

Review of How I found out I was going to be a Dad

Review by WriterRick

In affiliation with WdC SuperPower Reviewers Group

Rated: E

| (5.0)

This is a deeply personal and emotional piece, and the narrative presents an intriguing mix of surreal, future-oriented visions and intimate reflection. The story feels a little disjointed, almost like a dream or vision that doesn't quite follow the expected logic. The shift from a mental presentation of future technologies to the appearance of a daughter from the future is both unexpected and compelling, though the pacing of this transition feels rushed.

The idea of receiving a stock tip from a daughter who doesn't seem to exist yet is a fascinating concept, but the lack of deeper emotional development or context around this vision leaves the reader questioning the significance of it all. Why would this daughter choose to communicate with the protagonist in such a cryptic way? Was it truly a glimpse into the future, or just a figment of the mind?

The final twist, with the wife’s pregnancy and the eventual birth of Zoe, adds a beautiful sense of closure, giving weight to the seemingly fantastical experience. The emotional tone shifts here, and the reflection on the future of the daughter, Zoe, offers a hopeful, warm conclusion. However, the story would benefit from further fleshing out the protagonist’s emotional state after the vision, as the sudden switch to a routine, mundane life without much introspection leaves the event somewhat underexplored.

Overall, this is an intriguing, thought-provoking narrative about love, future possibilities, and the unknowable. It works best as an intimate, personal reflection, but could use some more depth in tying together the surreal and the real.

WriterRick (WdC SuperPower Reviewers Group)

My review has been submitted for consideration in "Good Deeds Get CASH!" .

14

Credit this reviewer

#4793780

Review of Lovestories

Review by WriterRick

In affiliation with WdC SuperPower Reviewers Group

Rated: E

| (5.0)

This piece feels like a series of poetic musings about nature, relationships, and the emotional connections between elements in the world. The imagery is strong, and the flow of thoughts feels like a journey—both literal and metaphorical. The repeated personifications of the sky, river, ocean, and darkness give these natural elements a sense of life, which adds depth to the writing.

The first section, with the sky loving the land, presents a beautiful, protective love. The metaphor of the horizon and the sky’s desire for the land works well, though I wonder if the tension between the land’s hesitation and the sky’s devotion could be explored more. The sky’s feeling of self-deception—“how much the sky will long for the love of land”—is intriguing but could be made clearer with further reflection on why the land resists.

The second section with the river giving herself to the ocean paints a vivid picture of sacrifice and transformation. I really like how you describe the river as “sweet and fresh” and how she becomes “one” with the ocean by giving up her identity. The ocean, as a figure with “many wives,” contrasts with the river’s purity, showing the dynamics of love and how different types of love exist in the world.

The transition into the ocean’s desire for light works well, adding a sense of longing. The restlessness of the ocean, yearning for sunlight, is almost poetic in its simplicity. I also liked the shift from this vast, cosmic longing to the very human experience of newlyweds separating, which feels like a symbolic moment of transition.

The flute section is a nice touch—connecting the natural and emotional worlds with music. The idea of distance being bridged through emotion, even if physically far apart, is beautifully conveyed. The ending, with the feeling of being "lost in the home," ties everything together in an ambiguous yet emotional way.

Overall, it's an evocative piece with great potential for emotional depth. It’s a lovely exploration of connections, sacrifices, and the passage of time, all wrapped up in a mystical journey through nature and human experience. A little more clarity in some of the relationships between the elements and the human scenes would make the message even more powerful.

WriterRick (WdC SuperPower Reviewers Group)

My review has been submitted for consideration in "Good Deeds Get CASH!" .

15

Only reviews from the past
14 days may be credited.

#4791920

Review of DANCING IN THE RAIN

Review by WriterRick

In affiliation with WdC SuperPower Reviewers Group

Rated: E

| (5.0)

This poem beautifully captures a spontaneous and carefree moment, embracing the joy of living in the present. The imagery of wet sneakers, darkened green fields, and quick-forming puddles creates a vivid, almost tactile sense of place. The transition from being caught in the rain to finding delight in it feels natural and heartfelt.

The line, “No reason to complain or lament,” shifts the tone from inconvenience to opportunity, setting the stage for the poem's celebratory mood. The act of removing shoes and baring red toe socks gives the scene a touch of whimsy, making it feel personal and relatable. The tango in the rain symbolizes freedom and connection, both with nature and perhaps with a partner, reinforcing the theme of finding joy in unexpected circumstances.

One suggestion for improvement might be to expand on the emotional or sensory experience of the dance itself. For instance, how does the rain feel against their skin? Is the rhythm influenced by the sound of the raindrops? This could add depth to the moment and make the scene even more immersive.

Overall, the poem’s simplicity and charm are its strengths. It’s a wonderful reminder of how life’s unplanned moments can become the most magical.

My review has been submitted for consideration in "Good Deeds Get CASH!" .

16

Only reviews from the past
14 days may be credited.

#4791918

Review of Government Control of Abortion Rights

Review by WriterRick

In affiliation with WdC SuperPower Reviewers Group

Rated: E

| (5.0)

This essay offers a detailed examination of the government's role in reproductive rights, weaving together historical context, societal governance, and the complexities of autonomy. Below are some strengths and areas for improvement:

Strengths:
Historical Context: The essay effectively uses historical examples, from ancient societies to modern policies, to showcase how governments have historically regulated reproduction. This adds depth and credibility.
Balanced Perspective: The argument is nuanced, avoiding extreme stances and instead presenting a pragmatic view of governance and societal needs.
Social Contract Framing: The connection between the social contract and government authority is well-articulated, showing how individual freedoms are balanced against collective welfare.
Contemporary Relevance: Including examples like the U.S. state-based approach and China's evolving policies makes the argument timely and relatable.
Areas for Improvement:
Organizational Flow: The essay could benefit from a clearer structure. The historical examples are rich but feel scattered. Grouping them into thematic categories (e.g., population control, ideological motives) might improve coherence.
Overuse of Examples: While the historical context is valuable, it occasionally overshadows the central argument. Fewer examples, discussed in greater detail, could make the essay more focused.
Decentralization Argument: The discussion of state autonomy in abortion policy is intriguing but underdeveloped. Expanding on how this approach aligns with or challenges the principles of the social contract would strengthen the argument.
Moral Dimensions: While the essay aims to stay pragmatic, the absence of a more explicit acknowledgment of the moral and ethical concerns surrounding abortion may make the argument seem overly clinical.
Conclusion Depth: The conclusion reaffirms the main points but could be more compelling by summarizing key takeaways and addressing potential counterarguments.
Suggestions:
Structure: Introduce the topic, provide historical context as background, and then focus on modern implications, dividing the essay into clear sections.
Clarity and Focus: Streamline the historical examples and use them to directly support the essay's central claim.
Counterarguments: Address opposing views (e.g., those advocating for universal autonomy or those prioritizing absolute government control) to reinforce the balanced stance.
Language: Some phrasing is dense. Simplifying complex sentences will make the essay more accessible without losing sophistication.
Final Thoughts:
The essay presents a thoughtful and well-researched exploration of a sensitive topic. By refining its structure and balancing historical and contemporary insights, it could become even more compelling and impactful.

WriterRick (WdC SuperPower Reviewers Group)

My review has been submitted for consideration in "Good Deeds Get CASH!" .

17

Only reviews from the past
14 days may be credited.

#4791917

Review of Government Control of Abortion Rights

Review by WriterRick

In affiliation with WdC SuperPower Reviewers Group

Rated: E

| (5.0)

This essay offers a detailed examination of the government's role in reproductive rights, weaving together historical context, societal governance, and the complexities of autonomy. Below are some strengths and areas for improvement:

Strengths:
Historical Context: The essay effectively uses historical examples, from ancient societies to modern policies, to showcase how governments have historically regulated reproduction. This adds depth and credibility.
Balanced Perspective: The argument is nuanced, avoiding extreme stances and instead presenting a pragmatic view of governance and societal needs.
Social Contract Framing: The connection between the social contract and government authority is well-articulated, showing how individual freedoms are balanced against collective welfare.
Contemporary Relevance: Including examples like the U.S. state-based approach and China's evolving policies makes the argument timely and relatable.
Areas for Improvement:
Organizational Flow: The essay could benefit from a clearer structure. The historical examples are rich but feel scattered. Grouping them into thematic categories (e.g., population control, ideological motives) might improve coherence.
Overuse of Examples: While the historical context is valuable, it occasionally overshadows the central argument. Fewer examples, discussed in greater detail, could make the essay more focused.
Decentralization Argument: The discussion of state autonomy in abortion policy is intriguing but underdeveloped. Expanding on how this approach aligns with or challenges the principles of the social contract would strengthen the argument.
Moral Dimensions: While the essay aims to stay pragmatic, the absence of a more explicit acknowledgment of the moral and ethical concerns surrounding abortion may make the argument seem overly clinical.
Conclusion Depth: The conclusion reaffirms the main points but could be more compelling by summarizing key takeaways and addressing potential counterarguments.
Suggestions:
Structure: Introduce the topic, provide historical context as background, and then focus on modern implications, dividing the essay into clear sections.
Clarity and Focus: Streamline the historical examples and use them to directly support the essay's central claim.
Counterarguments: Address opposing views (e.g., those advocating for universal autonomy or those prioritizing absolute government control) to reinforce the balanced stance.
Language: Some phrasing is dense. Simplifying complex sentences will make the essay more accessible without losing sophistication.
Final Thoughts:
The essay presents a thoughtful and well-researched exploration of a sensitive topic. By refining its structure and balancing historical and contemporary insights, it could become even more compelling and impactful.

My review has been submitted for consideration in "Good Deeds Get CASH!" .

18

Only reviews from the past
14 days may be credited.

#4791261

Review of It's Time

Review by WriterRick

In affiliation with WdC SuperPower Reviewers Group

Rated: E

| (5.0)

This short story, It’s Time, is an intriguing mix of humor, family dynamics, and relationship growth, cleverly weaving a simple event—a piece of mail—into a moment of personal revelation and shared understanding between a couple. Here’s a review:

Strengths
Engaging Dialogue: The story’s dialogue feels natural and flows well. It captures the characters’ emotions effectively, from Dan’s frustration to Jane’s surprise and eventual involvement in the conversation.
Humor and Quirkiness: The premise of a meddling grandmother resorting to "blackmail" to pressure a couple into having children is humorous and gives the story a lighthearted tone. The twist at the end, where Jane and the grandmother secretly conspired, adds an amusing layer.
Character Dynamics: The contrasting depictions of Jane’s and Dan’s grandmothers are well-done, creating a relatable scenario. The subtle fear Dan has of his grandmother is both funny and endearing.
Realistic Exploration of a Serious Topic: While the tone is playful, the story gently explores a serious and relatable issue: deciding when to start a family. It’s a relatable moment for many couples and adds depth to the humor.
Areas for Improvement
Build More Tension: The story could benefit from heightening the suspense about the blackmail at the beginning. Revealing the content of the letter a little later might draw readers in more effectively.
Develop Dan’s Perspective: While Jane’s feelings and perspective are clear, Dan’s thoughts on the topic—beyond the grandmother’s pressure—could be explored further. This would give him more depth and balance the narrative.
Smoother Transition to the Twist: The ending twist, while funny, feels slightly abrupt. A hint earlier in the story about Jane’s potential involvement with the grandmother might make the reveal smoother and more satisfying.
Tighten Sentence Flow: Some sentences, particularly during the dialogue exchanges, could be streamlined for clarity and impact. For example, “Jane immediately tip-toed on” feels a bit rushed and could be rephrased to better capture her hesitance.
Overall Impression
The story is charming and captures a slice of life with humor and warmth. It effectively portrays how external pressures can nudge a couple toward important decisions while maintaining agency and mutual respect. With a few tweaks to pacing and depth, this could evolve into an even more compelling piece.

WriterRick (WdC SuperPower Reviewers Group)

My review has been submitted for consideration in "Good Deeds Get CASH!" .

19

Only reviews from the past
14 days may be credited.

#4791260

Review of It's Time

Review by WriterRick

In affiliation with WdC SuperPower Reviewers Group

Rated: E

| (5.0)

This short story, It’s Time, is an intriguing mix of humor, family dynamics, and relationship growth, cleverly weaving a simple event—a piece of mail—into a moment of personal revelation and shared understanding between a couple. Here’s a review:

Strengths
Engaging Dialogue: The story’s dialogue feels natural and flows well. It captures the characters’ emotions effectively, from Dan’s frustration to Jane’s surprise and eventual involvement in the conversation.
Humor and Quirkiness: The premise of a meddling grandmother resorting to "blackmail" to pressure a couple into having children is humorous and gives the story a lighthearted tone. The twist at the end, where Jane and the grandmother secretly conspired, adds an amusing layer.
Character Dynamics: The contrasting depictions of Jane’s and Dan’s grandmothers are well-done, creating a relatable scenario. The subtle fear Dan has of his grandmother is both funny and endearing.
Realistic Exploration of a Serious Topic: While the tone is playful, the story gently explores a serious and relatable issue: deciding when to start a family. It’s a relatable moment for many couples and adds depth to the humor.
Areas for Improvement
Build More Tension: The story could benefit from heightening the suspense about the blackmail at the beginning. Revealing the content of the letter a little later might draw readers in more effectively.
Develop Dan’s Perspective: While Jane’s feelings and perspective are clear, Dan’s thoughts on the topic—beyond the grandmother’s pressure—could be explored further. This would give him more depth and balance the narrative.
Smoother Transition to the Twist: The ending twist, while funny, feels slightly abrupt. A hint earlier in the story about Jane’s potential involvement with the grandmother might make the reveal smoother and more satisfying.
Tighten Sentence Flow: Some sentences, particularly during the dialogue exchanges, could be streamlined for clarity and impact. For example, “Jane immediately tip-toed on” feels a bit rushed and could be rephrased to better capture her hesitance.
Overall Impression
The story is charming and captures a slice of life with humor and warmth. It effectively portrays how external pressures can nudge a couple toward important decisions while maintaining agency and mutual respect. With a few tweaks to pacing and depth, this could evolve into an even more compelling piece.

My review has been submitted for consideration in "Good Deeds Get CASH!" .

20

Only reviews from the past
14 days may be credited.

#4791258

Review of Hummingbird

Review by WriterRick

In affiliation with WdC SuperPower Reviewers Group

Rated: E

| (5.0)

This poem captures a vivid and striking image of a hummingbird in action. The title "Blurred wings" immediately sets the tone, hinting at motion and energy, and the imagery throughout is rich and evocative. The description of the bird's colors as "ruby and emerald" brings to life its vibrant beauty, making the scene feel almost magical.

Phrases like "stationary flight" and "sips lifeblood" cleverly juxtapose the bird's frantic wingbeats with the stillness of its hovering, and the metaphorical "nectar of the gods" elevates its feeding into something divine. This adds a layer of reverence, suggesting a connection between nature and the sacred.

If there's any critique, it might be that the poem is very compact, and some readers might want a bit more elaboration to linger longer in the moment. The word choice is effective, but a bit of additional sensory detail—perhaps about the surroundings or the flower being sipped—could enrich the scene further.

Overall, it’s a beautifully condensed snapshot of nature, full of vivid imagery and thought-provoking metaphors.

WriterRick (WdC SuperPower Reviewers Group)

My review has been submitted for consideration in "Good Deeds Get CASH!" .

21

Only reviews from the past
14 days may be credited.

#4790906

Review of A cry In the darkness

Review by WriterRick

In affiliation with WdC SuperPower Reviewers Group

Rated: E

| (5.0)

This piece has a strong, emotional pull, capturing a deep sense of longing and the agony of separation. The imagery of darkness, space, and the search for a lost soul is vivid and effective. The repetitive questioning about the other person adds a layer of urgency and desperation to the tone. The contrast between proximity and distance, both physical and emotional, is hauntingly conveyed, especially with phrases like "Your face hidden in shadows" and "galaxies separate us." The use of sensory details, like the "invisible silk of a spider's web" and the lingering scent, creates a strong atmosphere of longing and mystery.

The theme of searching across time and space for a connection that feels both familiar and unattainable is powerful. The idea of missing someone never met is a striking reflection of how deep emotional connections can transcend physical realities. The ending, with the faint cry from the universe responding to the speaker’s call, is a beautifully poetic way to tie together the longing and hope.

However, there are moments where the language could be tightened a bit for clarity or impact. For example, “the night clutches me in one final choking embrace” feels a bit overdone compared to some of the more subtle lines earlier. While the repetition of "How can I miss someone I have never met" is effective, some readers might want a bit more variation to avoid it feeling too repetitive toward the end. Still, overall, it’s a striking piece that evokes strong emotions of loneliness, desire, and hope.

WriterRick (WdC SuperPower Reviewers Group)

My review has been submitted for consideration in "Good Deeds Get CASH!" .

22

Only reviews from the past
14 days may be credited.

#4790903

Review of Committed to Role: Delivered Consequence

Review by WriterRick

In affiliation with WdC SuperPower Reviewers Group

Rated: E

| (5.0)

This poem has a rich, whimsical tone, full of vivid imagery and playful expressions. It seems to delve into themes of wealth, desire, and relationships, while also mixing in light-hearted commentary on contemporary culture. The structure and rhyme scheme give it a lyrical quality, though the phrasing is sometimes a bit abstract, making it feel more like a stream of consciousness.

The first few lines, "The richer that someone seemingly gets, / The beaming becomes more zoned," set the stage for a reflection on how wealth can change a person’s focus or demeanor. There's a slight sense of disillusionment here, as if success and materialism can lead to a detachment from what truly matters.

The transition into the idea of a “cruise for one’s beauteous vacation” vs. a “staycation” provides a fun twist on the typical notion of escape and relaxation, suggesting perhaps that the best moments don’t always need to be grand or far-flung.

There's also a playful tone in lines like “A trophy does imagine the graces / Of a most prosperous and extravagant future,” which brings a bit of irony into the mix. The imagery of the "trophy" seems to comment on superficial ideals of success and beauty, alluding to the way society often glamorizes wealth and outward appearances.

The later stanzas introduce an encouraging, almost uplifting tone, urging the reader to embrace youthful joy, make amends, and enjoy life in a balanced, healthy way ("Have some sober, delicate, decent fun"). This shift to a more positive outlook gives the poem depth, moving from cynicism to hope.

Overall, it has a surreal, almost satirical quality, weaving between different thoughts and ideas about materialism, love, and the pursuit of happiness. It’s an intriguing poem with a lot of potential for deeper interpretation, though its abstract nature might make it a bit challenging for some readers to fully grasp on the first read.

WriterRick (WdC SuperPower Reviewers Group)

My review has been submitted for consideration in "Good Deeds Get CASH!" .

23

Only reviews from the past
14 days may be credited.

#4790902

Review of Committed to Role: Delivered Consequence

Review by WriterRick

In affiliation with WdC SuperPower Reviewers Group

Rated: E

| (5.0)

This poem has a rich, whimsical tone, full of vivid imagery and playful expressions. It seems to delve into themes of wealth, desire, and relationships, while also mixing in light-hearted commentary on contemporary culture. The structure and rhyme scheme give it a lyrical quality, though the phrasing is sometimes a bit abstract, making it feel more like a stream of consciousness.

The first few lines, "The richer that someone seemingly gets, / The beaming becomes more zoned," set the stage for a reflection on how wealth can change a person’s focus or demeanor. There's a slight sense of disillusionment here, as if success and materialism can lead to a detachment from what truly matters.

The transition into the idea of a “cruise for one’s beauteous vacation” vs. a “staycation” provides a fun twist on the typical notion of escape and relaxation, suggesting perhaps that the best moments don’t always need to be grand or far-flung.

There's also a playful tone in lines like “A trophy does imagine the graces / Of a most prosperous and extravagant future,” which brings a bit of irony into the mix. The imagery of the "trophy" seems to comment on superficial ideals of success and beauty, alluding to the way society often glamorizes wealth and outward appearances.

The later stanzas introduce an encouraging, almost uplifting tone, urging the reader to embrace youthful joy, make amends, and enjoy life in a balanced, healthy way ("Have some sober, delicate, decent fun"). This shift to a more positive outlook gives the poem depth, moving from cynicism to hope.

Overall, it has a surreal, almost satirical quality, weaving between different thoughts and ideas about materialism, love, and the pursuit of happiness. It’s an intriguing poem with a lot of potential for deeper interpretation, though its abstract nature might make it a bit challenging for some readers to fully grasp on the first read.

My review has been submitted for consideration in "Good Deeds Get CASH!" .

24

Only reviews from the past
14 days may be credited.

#4790748

Review of Chair Rocking Kitty

Review by WriterRick

In affiliation with WdC SuperPower Reviewers Group

Rated: E

| (5.0)

This little poem paints a peaceful and playful picture of a cat enjoying its time. The rhythm flows well and captures the carefree nature of a cat lounging in a chair. The lines “Being a furry mess without a care” and “All they ask, is you let them unwind” convey the lazy, content attitude of a cat perfectly. I like how the cat's wishes for a “beautiful Spring day” give the poem a light, optimistic touch, as if the cat is subtly sharing its vibe with the reader.

However, there’s a small opportunity to tighten up some wording for smoother flow. For example, “not paying no mind” could be revised to “not paying any mind” to avoid a double negative. Also, “With that said, they turn away” feels like a bit of a jump in the narrative—it could be more natural if it tied in a bit more seamlessly with the cat’s actions or state of mind.

Overall, the poem has a charming, whimsical tone and effectively captures the essence of a cat’s relaxed demeanor. A few minor tweaks could make it even smoother, but it’s a fun and lighthearted piece!

WriterRick (WdC SuperPower Reviewers Group)

My review has been submitted for consideration in "Good Deeds Get CASH!" .

25

Only reviews from the past
14 days may be credited.

#4790747

Review of Seeds of Change

Review by WriterRick

In affiliation with WdC SuperPower Reviewers Group

Rated: E

| (5.0)

Seeds of Change

In a world of quiet beauty,
designed by loving hands,
the faerie folk and forms unknown
all populate the lands.

The majesty and magic were
quite obvious to see
brought to an end, unknowingly,
through curiosity.

As twilight changed to eventide,
a glow suffused the night
within a glade, deep in the woods,
designed to lure a sprite.

Its outward form was innocence,
temptation was its name
and the sweetness of its promise
flickered like a flame.

Bewitched, she held it in her hand.
She felt her feelings warm.
It called to her with images
designed to misinform.

It sang to her in wordless songs
of untasted pleasure.
Within her heart she held the key
to unlock the treasure.

She sat transfixed and motionless
as deep within her grew
a need for understanding of
these feelings that were new.

Temptation held her in its grasp;
she could not turn aside.
She found the seeds of change from which
she could no longer hide.

Each bore the name of jealousy,
envy, distrust, and greed
and they became a part of her
so she could spread the seed.

The changes were apparent as
soon paradise was lost.
The poison spread in minutes and
we have since borne the cost.

That far land and its denizens
are now just stories told.
We've relegated fairy tales
to no more than fool's gold.

We've lost the ancient wisdom lived
and learned in days of yore
while temptation still calls to us
to open the next door.

Within a glade, deep in the woods,
or in a quiet lab ...

WriterRick (WdC SuperPower Reviewers Group)

My review has been submitted for consideration in "Good Deeds Get CASH!" .