\"Writing.Com
*Magnify*
SPONSORED LINKS
Printed from https://shop.writing.com/main/profile/reviews/striver
Review Requests: OFF
15 Public Reviews Given
22 Total Reviews Given
Public Reviews
1
1
Review of The Lost Prince  Open in new Window.
Review by Zynab Author IconMail Icon
Rated: 13+ | (3.0)
Hi Ridom,

I saw your piece on the random read and review, I decided to put in a few 'words'. Please note that all opinions given are just mine, feel free to take what you need and discard the rest.

"Father!" Eli, a boy of ten Shouted, a boy of ten, watching as his father, the high lord of Ustia, collapsed. How aboutTen-year-old Eli screamed, as he watched his father - the high lord of Ustia bleeding on the cold hard floor. I think it flows better that way His eyes staring into nothing, his chest filled with holes. the caps The street was silent, everyone looked upon their beloved founder of the new world, bested by phantom men, lying in a pool of his own blood on the cobblestones.

Screaming and shouting, Suddenly, the street broke out in a wave of screaming and shouting, carts being trashed, people being shoved, everyone swearing to kill the Assassin of their High Lord. Eli ran to his father's corpse, tears streaming down his face as he cradled his Father's head in his arms,Period here He looked around for a familiar face in the swarming mob, but none could be seen, his Father never brought guards with him when he came to Hightown, he knew his people loved him.
"Come 'ere lad comma" a rough voice said from behind,Period here. Eli never heard him, his eyes werenow focused on the bell tower, where he could see a man, strapping his rifle to his back.

The man stopped, feeling eyes on him, he looked down to where Loras laid in his puddle of blood, head cradled by his Son Eli, The Assassin raised his hand to Eli, smirking to himself, turning away, he muttered the words for the portal to open, hoping he recited them correctly in their ancient language, sure enough he did, as what looked like a tear in the air itself opened and widened in front of him, he dived, with no fear, through the tear, and it was gone, along with the man. Run-on sentence. Perhaps you re-read, reconstruct with shorter sentences and insert periods.

Eli watched with rage as he saw him jump through and disappear
"One day, i'm caps "I'm" going to take all you hold dear, then i'm going to kill you slowly" he swore through gritted teeth, fists clenched. "ELI!" the man behind him shouted for the fifth time, starting to get impatient, he stood up and with a grunt scooped the young lord into his arms. He set of off in a hurried pace down the alleyway and around the corner.
"Let go of me comma here" Eli shouted at him, biting and kicking as he watched his fathers body disappear around the corner, "keep caps 'Keep' quiet boy, otherwise they'll come for you next comma here" the tall guy grunted,Period here
"no caps 'No' ones coming for me, i caps 'I' saw the man jump through the portal" Eli whispered as he thought back to moments before, as he watched the Assassin wave to him, like he was a friend, sparking rage into Eli as he swore over and over again that he would kill him. suddenly he was put down, and a fist caught him across his jaw.
"Sorry lad comma here" the man whispered as he carefully picked up the young boys' unconscious body, "but i need you to be quiet."


Great cliffhanger! Now I want to know what happened after.
I'll suggest you try reading up on how to use punctuations with your dialogues. I had a lat of problem with it when i just started also. And I'll suggest you look out for when to use your caps (i) instead of (I) and starting a dialogue with small letters.

It might seem overwhelming at first, but it gets easier and more enjoyable as you learn.
Good luck. Hope to read more from you


*Gold* My review has been submitted for consideration in "Good Deeds Get CASH!Open in new Window..
2
2
Review by Zynab Author IconMail Icon
In affiliation with The Newbies Academy Group  Open in new Window.
Rated: E | (3.0)
Hi,

I saw your piece on the Newbie newsletter and decided to review. Please, remember I'm a newbie like you and I'm still trying to be good at revuewing.

Your piece was quite engaging. And quite interesting. But the sentences were to choppy and made the writing seem forced. i feel you should try joining sentences together, rephrase two or three sentences and turn it into one.
For instance, you could change

His roommate sat at home watching Judge Judy reruns and chain smoking. The house smelled like an ashtray.

to


**His roommate sat at home watching Judge Judy reruns and chain smoking, ultimately leaving the house smelling like an ashtray.***

Or this,

#. He bolted from the bedroom, showered and freshly shaved for the train. He had his sketchbook in hand, along with a packed lunch. He couldn't afford the city prices on lunches. A banana, sandwich, and a Chinese fortune cookie from last week's splurge. He had eaten well that night..

To


**Freshly shaved, showered and sketchbook tucked under his arm he bolted out of his room and headed for the train station.... Along with his packed lunch - a banana sandwich and a Chinese cookie from last week's splurge'


Then, try removing the 'hads'. Work around your sentences again and do away with the 'hads', I believe they are a little much.

I'll be happy to review your edited copy.
3
3
Review by Zynab Author IconMail Icon
In affiliation with The Newbies Academy Group  Open in new Window.
Rated: 18+ | (3.0)
Hello Redlive,
I'm responding to the review request you placed on the NAG 'please review' page.
First of all, I liked your method of writing. And I like a good mystery, I like the guess and uncertainty that follows a mystery, and I particularly liked the author's note because I actually paused and re read the story to be sure I had the right culprit.

That being said, knowing who the killer is was fairly easy. And that's not what you want in your mystery. I think you should add a little something that would make us suspect cando too.
Then, the detective, I'm sorry, I didn't really like him. :( He sounded brusque and more than once a little rude. Well, that could be his character description, maybe we're not to like him.
Which brings me to my third point, the characters weren't well built, I wasn't even sure if the detective was a male or female. I feel you should give a little ridiculous bit on each of the suspects (asides their age) as they were interviewed. 'Tiffany patted her greying hair' 'Candos deep set eyes roamed around the room before it settled on me' you know, that sort of thing, give them life.

Last but not the least, The detective sounded like a magician! How had he know all that?!!! Can do hiding under the sink with the gun and all.


It was an enjoyable read. I hope to read more from you. Write on!
4
4
Review of In Chains  Open in new Window.
Review by Zynab Author IconMail Icon
Rated: 13+ | (3.5)
I'm not a professional writer, I'm a newbie and still trying to get the hang of things. Please remember all my suggestions and thoughts are just my opinions, only you you knows what is best for your piece, so please feel free to choose what you like and discard the rest.

That being said
My comments are in blue
My Suggestions in Green
What I feel you should do away with in red

Resting on my couch Italicize and put commawould have suited the description if my mind had not wandered off to thoughts of her. A master's mind captive of his slave. Her purpose was a leisure toy but now my hands begged to hold her every second away. My eyes had grown blind to the world, I could only see in her sight. What had I gotten myself into?

There she was, seated on my table. As if its sole purpose was for her to lie on. She did not even attempt to, yet comma here I felt seduced by just her existence. Were my eyes enslaved or was she the missing part of my furniture. Her presence seemed to change everything in the room in a completion kind of way. She was that final touch, my walls looked different, the air felt different, even my heart beat different. How unjust it was for me to demean her description to mere beauty. My eyes were glaring at perfection.

Overall Impression:
This was an interesting, easy read. Maybe a little more words to help us understand better. Like was the narrator hallucinating, day dreaming, or was the girl actually there?
Great use of words too. I learnt one or two things.
Write On!
5
5
Review of Todd's Awakening  Open in new Window.
Review by Zynab Author IconMail Icon
Rated: 18+ | (3.0)
I'm not a professional writer, I'm a newbie trying to get the hang of things. I'm trying to give you honest feedback and impressions of what I thought as I read your work. These are one person's opinions, and you're free to ignore any of them.

that being said
My Comments are in blue
Suggestions in Green
What i feel you could do away with in red



A going away party for an old classmate, Megan Lastname, was a the thing he needed. In the Facebook invite she said was moving to California to live with her mother's grandparents. Nothing too big comma here but she wanted to have a going away party to see everyone from her class one last time. He didn't want to go but Josie who is Josie? urged him to do so. It would be a great distraction from his ever-revolving door of unnecessary thoughts and anxiety.Nice *StarfishY*

At eighteen, he finally felt safe enough to explore his sexuality fully and to work out everything needed to do this. Those thoughts now were shoved to the back of his mind as he focused on styling his fading blue hair. Josie, his best friend, dyed it a few months ago when they were wasted. She said it "brought out the happy in his eyes", whatever that meant. The length wasn't too frustrating to work with but it just wasn't doing what he wanted. He would have chosen a distinct color, maybe a darker brown to bring out his eyes.

But she said happy italicize 'happy' not and this= brought out his eye color. Whatever she saw he couldn’t see but then she often noticed things about him that he never saw. But she was oblivious to one thing about him and his love for her.

It couldn’t be helped because they were very different people who had attached to one another each other in their freshmen year of high school. She was the an new outgoing beautiful curly haired girl who could have befriended anyone of her choice. He was the awkward, scrawny but tall faded brown haired and brown eye average looking boy who spent more time sitting alone and avoiding confrontations. I think you should consider re-phrasing this... It's could probably be broken into two sentences. She the fierce green eyed girl who could slay dragons – if they existed.

He closed his eyes stopping the self-doubt from drowning him before he even stepped out of the house. He ran a comb through it once again, flat and uninspired as always. He ran his fingers across his eyebrows and made sure he didn’t have toothpaste or shaving cream anywhere.
---

“He looks like a lost anime character.” First words from Abigail. She always made small digs at him but Josie didn’t see it that way. Abigail had the heart of the girl he loved --- Josie’s to be exact. Abigail couldn’t do anything wrong and everything she did was trying to be friendly. Ah, I'm sort of lost here, what's wrong with Josie's heart?

Abigail paused a moment, looking down at Josie lovingly moving her curly black hair out of her face. It never minded anyone but somehow listened to Abigail. Josie turned looking up at Todd – reaching out to him and pulling him toward her. Sorry, but I'm even more confused. Where are they? Who is Abigail? And from whose point of view is this part narrated? Maybe you should make this a bit clear. The names and actions are just coming in, and they are all looking jumbled up

He slowly inhaled as he entered the place. It was loud, dancing and colorful gifts piled up in the corner of the livingspaceroom. Okay, guess it's at Megans party. But I'll have preferred you mentioned it after Abigails first statement.

"Congratulations on your teen pregnancy!" A home-made banner yelled from across the room.

"I thought this was a going away party?" Todd asked.

Abigail laughed Fullstop here. that was her response to anything he said or did. Josie reassured him she meant no harm. She laughed easy, loved deeply and whatever else she said when they talked about the way she treated him Who are we talking about here? Josie? Or abigail?. He tried not to feel too bitter about it as Josie didn't see the look in her lover's eyes like he did.

“Her getting knocked up is why she’s leaving.” Josie yelled answering him, replied, her voice raised so she could be heard above the partying noise. She stepped away from him comma here pulling Abigail and pulled Abigail toward a table full of cups and bottles of alcohol. Many had bows on them brought over as gifts. He walked over and placed a five-dollar bill in one of the bags as his way of making up for not getting her anything.

"Todd! You made it. And you're alone. Poor you and your one-sided puppy love!" Megan’s high pitch scream greeted him. It slurred and when he turned around he saw the bright red cheeks that always followed Megan when she drank heavily.

"And, you are drunk." Todd replied, "Can’t even think of anyone else but yourself even pregnant. You think I’m pathetic?End quote

It amused him as the small five foot nothing Megan stomped away. Most of his friendships came through him knowing Josie. Otherwise he would have never met Megan or would be at this party. He discretely removed the five dollars he had slipped in one of the bags tucking it in his pocket.Huh- huh He scanned the people nearby to see if they saw him but no one was no one seemed to be looking in his direction. Which meant no one paid any mind to the fact that the mother to be was wasted. He hated people sometimes but he was no better as he didn’t stop her.

Megan was someone who would find any reason to drink. It was disappointing that she was picking a baby shower to be one of those occasions to suck down alcohol.

He bopped around the place for a while making his way to the food table several times. Josie frowned on at him standing by the food and eating because it made him lame. She didn’t understand that the social aspect of these events was what he’d consider lame. He loved food, especially, free food. Here there was a handful of people who camped around the food.

One of them, a man who was over dressed for the kind of event this was. His hair – full and well made, slight bushy eyebrows and at least over six feet tall. Todd had to look up to look him in the face. He avoided him but didn’t mind stealing glances when he came back through for more pinwheels and fruit punch.

Todd decided to try to see where Josie was when the slightly over dressed man stepped in front of him. Todd froze, fearful of making a fool of himself to realize the guy was grappling at the red solo cup trying to prevent it from landing on Todd.
“Dude, I’m sorry.” Overdressed guy apologized as he bumped into Todd. The cup smacked the ground, “I am so sorry.”
“Man.” Todd responded, more out of disappointment than anger and turned on his heels. He pulled at the wet shirt, fruit punch splashed everywhere. He could feel it dripping as he hurried to the hallway bathroom.
He ripped off his shirt when he entered the bathroom. Megan had a secret place where she stashed towels. The first party she ever threw in high school everyone stole all their towels from the bathrooms. At the time, it was hilarious but he couldn’t remember why now.

"Occupied!" He yelled as someone walked in. He twisted to give the person some choice words.

"I missed it!" The guy teased.

Todd gave him a confused look and started dabbing the shirt with a towel.

"missed what?" He asked when he realized the guy wasn't leaving.

"The shirt being pulled off. That's my favorite part."

Todd turned to see the guy leaning on the wall openly looking him up and down. Todd blushed.

"I am not --" Todd's caught in his throat as the guy started to unbutton his shirt. The guy had a smug smile, Todd wanted to look away to look away to not give him that satisfaction. But he hungrily watched instead. He felt frozen in that spot. The heat rising throughout he gasped when the guy walked over pushing him into the sink. The kiss hard and Todd wanted more he reached toward the guy running his hands downward. The guy pulled back and Todd leaned forwards.

The door flung open, "The hell, Derek?" He recognized Megan's voice, "You come home and jump the first stranger -oh my god, it's Todd."

"You are Derek?" Todd asked dumbly. He moved grabbing his shirt. Derek was two years older and looked more.... defined then Todd remembered.
He pushed through the two with Megan following behind. He grabbed the first cold drink off the counter. A Pepsi to his disappointment.

She waited until the kitchen cleared before approaching. Finger in the air.
"Look you ducked up fairy just because you can't have Josie doesn't mean heading after my brother. What kind of weird thing are you anyway?" She pressed that finger into his chest. Ducked up fairy was something he knew he’d have to get used to hearing.

He didn’t know what his sexuality was – bisexual? Homosexual? Heterosexual but confused? But he knew certainly it was nothing weird. He wasn’t weird in that context.

"I haven’t attacked anyone, Megan, so quit acting like I have. He’s a full-grown adult who can make his own choices – just like you have. No one should be here supporting a drunk at a baby shower. We are all stupid for being here supporting this behavior – you’re the last person who should try to take the high road.” The words louder and angrier – no he meant the anger – the stares and whispers felt louder and in his face.

He felt the heat rising inside of him as he slid away from her. He weaved dodged looks from those who heard everything as he made his way into the livingroom.

She didn't follow him.

Josie was curled up with Abigail giggling and caressing one another to the voyeuristic audience around them. He was never going to have that with Josie, he understood that now.

"Hey, Josie, I'm heading home."

She pulled away from Abigail to check on him. Her face and expression dulled by the amounts of alcohol she consumed. But her concern was genuine, however, her attention span shortened. He hugged her and hurried out of the house. He was too sober and alone for this nonsense.

What am I doing here? He parked in front of the glossy black building. It had stone benches in the front, fake trees around the entryway. It was a place advertised as "fun" but the exterior always looked more like a business where suits and filing papers happened. The interior was blue light and flashing white lights. The seats were small cubby areas tucked in for the false sense of privacy.

BLISS in bold capital letters flickered over the walls. It was a place that Josie introduced to him a few months after he turned eighteen. It's where they would go when they hadn't anything else planned. Between Josie's desk job and his in-between work moments they were spending a lot of time there.

The entry fee wasn't a lot – not as the front of the building would like you to think.

He sat in the same cubby area letting the false sense of privacy drape over him as he watched the men dance on stage.

His phone buzzed, Josie calling he let it go to voicemail. Then came the text after text after text she often does when he doesn't answer. It wasn't horrendous as he does it to her as well.

Are you ok?

Meghan said you got into a fight

Are you OK?!

He replied quickly, Megan exaggerated and she’s drinking while pregnant. Josie, no longer concerned with his well-being as she shouldn’t be but was after Megan as she should be. It felt beautiful knowing that the woman was getting what she deserved for him and the soon to be baby.

"If your phone is more interesting, then why the hell are you here?"

Todd noticeable jumped, knocking the phone out of his hand. The man picked it up.

"Oh, no you're the gay BFF."

"No, give me that back." Todd stretched his hand out.

"What if I called her now? Would she be hotter than the Sahara over your adventures? You know that's all straight girls want out of you, right?" He teased hovering his finger over the call button.

"No! Stop. Now." His words lacking emotion. He didn't want to get kicked out of the only safe place that he was familiar with.

"Give me a kiss then maybe." The guy arched his eyebrow. He kept his index over the call button on the screen.

He sat there a few seconds thinking that it wouldn't hurt and then he would not have to worry about going through the entire process of coming out to her. He didn't like the idea of a stranger taking that moment away from him either. He moved over and gave the man a slight peck – ripping his phone from the guy's hand.

"Oh, look the gay BFF got skills." The man didn't sound impressed.

"Again, no, I am not the gay BFF." He turned his cellphone off, tucking it in his pocket.

"I always see you in here with her so I assumed ----"The way the man got caught off guard relaxed Todd.

"Did you just admit to stalking me?" He leaned into the table, "How do you know I'm texting the same person you see me in here with? Buy me a drink if you're wrong"

"They don't card here, anyway, how do I know if you're going to lie?"

"You don't."

"Fine, I figured you had no one other than her. I drummed up a tale of closeted small-town boy who traveled to the largest town nearby said small town. Never initiate anything, just watches."

"You make me sound creepy."

"Your words not mine. So, how on the nose am I?"

"Ish, she's my gay best friend and she is definitely my only friend. That's like half a drink right there."

"So, you're not a closeted? Then what are you?" He leaned over, closer. Todd could tell he was working back the personality that Todd accidentally knocked off guard.

"Drink first." He traced his fingers against the man's hand. He hoped to see less of the front. The man nodded, stood up and disappeared. After a moment, he tucked his hands in his pocket debating whether to get back on his cellphone. The dude was out of the picture now.


"I figured you'd have ran by now." The same man with both hands full. Todd offered a hand taking his from him.

"I wanted to see if you'd chicken out. Not everyone handles losing very well." He smiled. He sipped whatever it was that he was handed. He craved a milkshake and fries he didn't think he'd ever get used to the taste of this. But he felt invested now.

"Lose? According to you I've half-won." The man smiled before drinking deeply from his cup. He made a face and, "Give me another chance of being right. The reward is another kiss – a better then a "get this over with" cheek kiss you give your grandma. Agreed?"

"Go for it."

The man pretended to think about it for a moment, "You're a virgin."
"That's cold and isn't true."

"No, I meant you've never been with a guy before." He smirked, running his finger across his glass, "You say you're not the gay best friend and I see you looking longingly at your friend and have no issue with eyeing the guy-candy out here."

"Not with her." Todd grabbed his glass tightly, "I don't know if I should be interested in you or a possible restraining order."

"I have a sharp eye and can read body language pretty well. You haven't answered my question."

Todd was thankful for the darkened booth and the flickering of the lights. He hoped that this disguised his embarrassment. He as awkward as possible moved over, placed his hands around the man's jaw and pulled him into a kill. He placed his hand gently against the man's inner thigh moving closer to him with every chance he could. The guy pulled away with a dreamy look in his eye.

"You've already made out with a guy tonight."

"Excuse me? Restraining order talk, much?"

"I can smell two different colognes on you unless you're a weird one. Tell me I'm wrong or we head back to my place." The guy pulled him closer.

"You're not wrong. I don't know you're a serial killer."

"You don't."


*Rainbowl**Rainbowr*Overall impressions:it would It looks like an enjoyable read. If you focus a little more on your dialogue, your transitioning and your character descriptions. I was going to do a line by line at first but I then realized it would be better if you do the changing yourself.I was confused a lot and some of the sentences didn't settle well Only you knows what's best for your story. I'll be pleased to review your edited copy

Write on!
6
6
Review of Never be the Same  Open in new Window.
Review by Zynab Author IconMail Icon
Rated: E | (3.0)
Hi Samantha,

Your story was quite touching, and at first I felt a little bit uncomfortable thinking its just a short story with a tragic end. But then I saw ;Chapter 1 and whew! immense relief.

That being said, I feel a four year old is still quite young to have such indepth knowledge about death. Maybe it would be better if you ease here into this knowledge. Like for instance, she wakes up in chapter one, and remembers the terrible accident the day before. she wonders where her mum is and then goes in search of her. jane comes in and explains. Maybe in chapter two or three as they begin to live their lives she could then begin to grasp the facts about their situation. Mother wont be around to make breakfast, mother wont comb her hair again... that sort of thing.


I'm sorry, i'm a newbie just like yourself so I'm still trying my hands at reviewing. Write On!
6 Reviews · *Magnify*
Page of 1 · 25 per page   < >
Printed from https://shop.writing.com/main/profile/reviews/striver