$\"Reading$

★★★★★ (15)

Details

18+ General Discussion Forum

by Marcia Landa

Rated: 18+ · Message Forum · Writing · #1213006

A place for adults to discuss writing and write intelligently on any topic, from E and up

<< Previous • Message List • Next >>

Reply • Post New

May 29, 2007 at 5:41pm

#1518571

Re: *** Deleted Message ***

by Budroe

When I am reviewing, I am addressing the writer from the perspective of the reader. My reviews are (usually) friendly, honest, and tactful.

When I am critiqueing, I am addressing the writer from the perspective of being an analyzer of the writing. These are, I believe, fundamental differences that should not actually be combined into the same work.

If I cannot do either honestly, I pass up the work and move on to another one. There are plenty of pieces in search of feedback, analysis, and comment. That's just how I do it.

Write Well!

M. B. "Bud" Fields, Jr.
Clarksville, Indiana USA

** Images For Use By Upgraded+ Only **

** Images For Use By Upgraded+ Only **

MESSAGE THREAD

Rating and Reviewing Discussion · 05-20-07 9:45pm
by Marcia Landa

Re: Love Reviewing - Hate Rating · 05-20-07 9:52pm
by Storm Machine

Re: Re: Love Reviewing - Hate Rating · 05-21-07 4:54pm
by A Non-Existent User

Re: Re: Love Reviewing - Hate Rating · 05-21-07 4:56pm
by sandiegoabuelo

Re: Re: Re: Love Reviewing - Hate Rating · 05-23-07 9:30pm
by bearbit

Re: Re: Re: Re: Love Reviewing - Hate Rating · 05-25-07 1:09pm
by Storm Machine

Re: Re: Re: Love Reviewing - Hate Rating · 06-04-07 9:25pm
by A Non-Existent User

Re: Re: Re: Re: Love Reviewing - Hate Rating · 06-04-07 9:50pm
by Past Member 'evilegg'

Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Love Reviewing - Hate Rating · 06-05-07 12:31am
by Budroe

Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Love Reviewing - Hate Rating · 06-05-07 3:09pm
by Past Member 'evilegg'

Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Love Reviewing - Hate Rating · 06-05-07 3:43pm
by Budroe

Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Love Reviewing - Hate Rating · 06-05-07 4:02pm
by Past Member 'evilegg'

Love Reviewing - Hate Rating · 06-05-07 4:53pm
by Budroe

Re: Love Reviewing - Hate Rating · 06-05-07 8:18pm
by Past Member 'evilegg'

Re: Re: Love Reviewing - Hate Rating · 06-09-07 6:43pm
by the1stephzen

Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Love Reviewing - Hate Rating · 06-05-07 4:02pm
by A Non-Existent User

Re: Rating and Reviewing Discussion · 05-22-07 5:50am
by qaz4

Re: Re: Rating and Reviewing Discussion · 05-22-07 4:00pm
by Past Member 'evilegg'

Re: Re: Re: Rating and Reviewing Discussion · 05-25-07 5:47pm
by Tracy63

Re: Re: Re: Re: Rating and Reviewing Discussion · 05-25-07 11:27pm
by Marcia Landa

*** Deleted Message *** · 05-26-07 4:47pm
by Marcia Landa

Re: *** Deleted Message *** · 05-29-07 5:41pm
by Budroe

Re: Rating and Reviewing Discussion · 05-31-07 9:50pm
by the1stephzen

Re: Re: Rating and Reviewing Discussion · 05-31-07 10:46pm
by Past Member 'evilegg'

Re: Re: Re: Rating and Reviewing Discussion · 05-31-07 10:55pm
by the1stephzen

Re: Re: Re: Re: Rating and Reviewing Discussion · 05-31-07 11:08pm
by Past Member 'evilegg'

Re: Re: Re: Re: Rating and Reviewing Discussion · 06-01-07 4:12pm
by pentatonic

Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Rating and Reviewing Discussion · 06-01-07 6:14pm
by Past Member 'evilegg'

Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Rating and Reviewing Discussion · 06-02-07 2:16pm
by pentatonic

Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Rating and Reviewing Discussion · 06-02-07 3:00pm
by Marcia Landa

Re: Rating and Reviewing Discussion · 06-03-07 11:33am
by A Non-Existent User

Re: Re: Rating and Reviewing Discussion · 06-03-07 8:38pm
by Past Member 'evilegg'

Re: Rating and Reviewing Discussion · 06-04-07 9:17pm
by A Non-Existent User

<< Previous • Message List • Next >>

Reply • Post New

The following applies to this forum item as a whole, not this post. Feedback sent here will go to the forum's owner, Marcia Landa.

Printed from https://shop.writing.com/main/forums/message_id/1518571