Reviewing Advice Forum

Hi Everyone
This seems like the correct place to ask my question, although there aren't any other questions like this posted in the forum.

There are a couple of Items I've come across in the Read a Newbie forum, that while enthusiastic, are very poorly written. Tbh I wondered if they were set ups (like controversial click bait posts!) but that doesn't seem like WDC's style. That said, to review them would definitely be a prize worthy challenge.

I found the reviewing handbook with advice on how to review such a piece.
"How to Review a Really Bad Item - by Lotusneko" 

However my question is: If a poorly written entry it is a writers first entry - does the group have a silent agreement to refrain review so as not to discourage?