Message forum for readers of the BoM/TWS interactive universe. |
I'll answer that first question. Perhaps not super well, but I can answer it: Because AI isn't living a person. It cannot learn like humans can, nor can it collaborate with other humans in order to write. It is not creative like we are. It has no interiority. (Even as someone who is, at best, agnostic to it, I find it really lame that AI would being treated as though what it is doing is the same as the creative process, even if the result of "words being put on a page is the end result in either case). It's not a blind spot that Noel has, it's that there's a categorical difference between a human doing something like learning or collaborating or even copying and Chatgpt doing something for you. It is cheating if you're leaning on Chatgpt to write for you; it very much isn't if you're working with or taking inspiration from others, because you're still writing. All due respect, because you *have* written things before and I think that they're good, you didn't write the magical girl story. You edited it. If you were to indeed post it or publish it somewhere, I don't think it'd be yours. And I'd think it was, by default, lame as a result, even if it was "better" than if you were write it yourself. And that's without even expanding out of the relatively narrow framework this discussion lies within. |