Perhaps it was because she was suddenly feeling really horny, but she felt like something in their relationship needed to change. It was obvious that he liked her, and she definitely liked him more than a friend, but there was something that had always confused her.
Kat leaned back in her chair, as she tried to ignore the growing pleasure in her groin, "Before I answer that, there was something I was wondering."
"Yeah," Theo said, suddenly looking at his plate sheepishly.
"Do you think I'm too thin?"
Theo's eyes suddenly darted to Kat's stomach again, practically confirming her suspicion. He was a chubby chaser.
"I, um, I don't think so," Theo said, not knowing quite what to say. He wasn't going to say more than that, though.
"So you don't think I should put on some weight?" Kat teased, though she didn't know where this was coming from.
She'd never wanted to go back to being chubby. Well, at least that's what she always told herself. Honestly, she'd been toying with the idea of putting on some weight for a while now to see if that would provoke Theo to finally make a move on her.
"I want you to be happy," he replied, reaching out to take her hand.
Kat felt her heart skip a beat as his hand developed her's in warmth and it was her turn to look away sheepishly.
"You, um, didn't really answer my question," Kat said, trying to keep him on the defensive.
Theo sighed and closed his eyes, "Promise you won't hate me?"
"Promise."
"I like fat girls, and I guess, I, um, always thought you'd look cuter if you put on some weight."
"You think I'm cute?"
"Actually," Theo said, starting to sound a little more confident, "I, um, think you're beautiful. I, um, have kind of had a crush on you for a while, but I didn't act on it because I thought you'd hate me if you ever found out about my fat fetish."
Kat's head was swimming as she tried to cope with the bombshell that Theo had just dropped on her. He really liked her, but he was worried that she would hate him if she found out he wanted her to get fat. She didn't know how to feel. She definitely had feelings for him, but she wasn't sure about the whole getting fat part. She'd been chubby before, and it had been extremely difficult for her to get in this good of shape. Though, why had she even wanted to get in shape?
She stopped, trying to remember why she'd wanted to get thin in the first place, and what it had been like when she'd been chubby. She'd been so happy with it back then. Then... She couldn't remember, but perhaps the best way to know would be to experience it all over again.
"So, what if I didn't get fat? Would you still like me?"
"Of course. I've had a crush on you since we were kids. Practically from the first time I'd seen you. Actually, that's kind of what..." Theo trailed off.
Kat and Theo had met in sixth grade, and back then, she had been quite the chubby girl. Her family loved food and she hadn't had very good self-control. She'd loved eating and it had shown. Suddenly it hit her what Theo was trying to say. He liked chubby girls because of her. He must have been smitten with her chubby body, and thought she was very beautiful.
"Wait, you actually did like me being chubby?" She asked.
"I mean, yeah. I had a hard time keeping my eyes off of you. You were always so adorable. I was definitely disappointed when you started trying to lose weight, but honestly, I care more about you being happy than about trying to please me. That's why I never brought it up. I was worried that you'd think I was going to try to pressure you into gaining weight, but..."
Kat felt her stomach twist as Theo trailed off. Was she really going to do this? Was she really considering putting on weight for him. She couldn't deny that she loved him, and the feelings in her groin seemed to be making her thinking erotic, but she was still somewhat apprehensive.
"You really think I'd look better if I put on some weight?"
"Yes. I think you'd look so beautiful with a nice curvy body. Not that you aren't gorgeous now, I just think you'd look really, really good with a bit more..." Theo trailed off as he realized what he was saying.