\"Writing.Com
*Magnify*
SPONSORED LINKS
Printed from https://shop.writing.com/main/profile/reviews/breec
Review Requests: OFF
66 Public Reviews Given
67 Total Reviews Given
Public Reviews
1
1
Review by Bree Author IconMail Icon
Rated: E | (4.5)
 Fairies and Fireflies (revised) Open in new Window. (E)
This is a Fantasy Short Story Approx. 3,575 words
#1792879 by SilverQuill Author IconMail Icon

Reviewer: Bree
Author: SilverQuill

Story Strengths: Intense opening paragraph. The description was vivid imagery. You really got into the characters head, with his thoughts and actions. Very mysterious greeting when he arrived at the manor.
Good with showing tension and mystery throughout the chapter. I like how you wrote the dreams. I have a few dream sequences in my story, as well. Intense and cliff hanger for the ending paragraph.

Suggestions: Thomas mentions chat room….a name would be nice addition. Watch using the word – was for it suggests passive voice, which I’m finding is frowned upon. But I feel sometimes, you just have to use it. Watch for repeated words, close together like-- over-stuffed, tufted leather bench and rich leather tufted sofa. Be careful when describing a room, so it’s not all telling. Try continuing exploring the room through Thomas’ eyes as you did when he opened the doors to the bedroom.

Punctuation/Spelling/Grammar: I noticed some possible missing commas. I’ve been told one way to remember, is to add them when there’s a natural break when speaking. See more through the story. Be careful of over using ‘as’.
2
2
Review by Bree Author IconMail Icon
In affiliation with The Coffee Shop for the Fantas...  Open in new Window.
Rated: E | (4.0)
Writer: Lord Michael Peasant
Hello, I’m reviewing your chapters. Keep what you want, toss the rest. Keep writing. I'l review the next piece for you as well.
Hope you can check out my port.....

Reviewer: Bree, Member of….

**Coffee Shop for Fantasy Society
**Young Adult Club
**WDC Power Reviewers Group

1 Plot: Theresa welcomes a mysterious man. He never changes, his appearance and has been away for some time. He asks for a key to his office. She’s emotional that he never has time for her. POV Theresa

2 Style & Voice: It appears that your style is perhaps the way your character would speak (Theresa).

3 Referencing: No mention of time era or location.

4 Scene/Setting: I like the word choices for describing Him and his office. Very little description of the first location, yet it doesn’t seem to be missing.

5 Characters: A name would be nice, for the man. I like how you described him. Not much description for Theresa.

6 Grammar: During dialogue, remember to use a comma after the speaking part, and the next letter is not capitalized. “Okay,” she said. I’m not 100% comfortable with commas, I was told a good rule to remember, when you pause in reading or to help in clarification.

7 Just My Personal Opinion: If I underline words, with a (?), the sentence or words could be either awkward or doesn’t sound right to me. At times, there’ll be a word inserted.

Chapter 1
The door opened. Even before the man walked into the room (comma) Theresa knew who it was. She'd always known. There was just something about him, an unmistakable presence. Anyone in his vicinity would feel it, if he wanted you to. Theresa couldn't even describe it. It was an overwhelming feeling seeing him enter a room, like if the earth trembled under his feet. All heads in the room would turn. (?) You'd do anything to be near him, despite a fear you couldn't make heads or tails of. Theresa had known him for years and still he affected her this way. Nothing about him ever seemed to change. She hoped nothing ever would. (Interesting concept of the beginning paragraph. I like your choice of words)

Thus she was not surprised as he stepped into her office. They hadn't seen each other for over a year and still he looked the same. Still he commanded the room as (repeated above) he walked in. He seemed to be in his late 20s but whenever Theresa asked him his age he would give up a small chuckle before skillfully dodging the question. Yet this time there was something about him. He seemed.. (is something missing here? Perhaps another period) darker somehow. No matter how intimidating she'd ever found him, she would never have described him as dark. He had been a bright person in every way. (Perhaps, give an example of him being a bright person, instead of telling.) From his unruly white hair to his pale blue eyes and his white row of teeth,(comma) that more often than not,(comma) shone up in a big grin. But not this time. Not today.
"I need my key," He (he) said as if greetings were unnecessary. (like it, shows his personality) He had known she had noticed him coming. He'd made sure of it.
"Okay," She (she) smiled, ignoring what she thought was a rather rude entrance.

"Wait a second." She said, turned around and started digging through her drawers. He'd just walked in one day last year, thrown the key on her desk and told her he'd be back for it. The hasty and unexplained good bye had led her to worry ever since.
"Here it is." She showed him his key with a gesture that made it seem as if she was handing it to him. Hanging on a chain (awkward, comma needed?) it was old and primitive looking, much like the jewellery he was prone to wearing. He especially seemed to have a penchant for pendants which he wrapped around his wrist. The key fit right in with these pendants and Theresa suspected there was more to it than met the eye. Just as he reached out for it, she closed her hand on the key.
"Shall we go then?" She tried, as an excuse to accompany him. She'd make sure to squeeze a few more words out of him (comma?) before she let him escape again. He seemed to deem it an acceptable compromise.
"Ladies first." He said, trying a grin. It didn't quite have his old cheerfulness, but Theresa could tell it had been even worse not long ago.
"Don't mind if I do." She returned his smile and walked past him,(comma) out the hallway.
His door was just a short walk away from hers, but it was like a different world. She'd been inside (of it ) I’d delete those words, unnecessary) many times since he ( had ) left her with the key. It was such a mysterious office he kept. Four different computer screens was (were) set up on a sturdy old desk and the rest of the room was covered in documents and pages of old books. It almost always lay in darkness. Theresa would go inside from time to time to just walk around quietly looking at everything. But never touching. That's where she drew her line of breaking his trust.
She had planned to start up a conversation as they walked, but somehow they found themselves at his door before she'd been able to say a word. Surprised at herself (comma?) she put the key in the lock and turned. When she opened the door everything looked the same as before. Not even dust seemed to settle in this room. The man beside her gave (is this necessary, for there’s no other man in the hall. Good place to add his name.) of a pleased little smile and walked into the room, leaving her standing in the hallway.
"Thank you for taking care of it, Tess. I promise we'll get a chance to talk later." He said, smiling apologetically. Her heart sank.
"Well, I'll see you later then." She sighed as she closed the door behind him. Later? She thought to herself. Will I always have to wait my turn with that man? She walked away pondering, conflicting emotions fighting in her chest.(like that sentence)

Chapter 2
Gilligan Blood sat down at his desk with a sigh. It had been thirteen months since last he'd done so and nothing had changed. (awkward) Or rather, everything had changed, it just looked the same. For all that had happened over the course of a year, not a day seemed to have gone by in this place. But he knew it wouldn't last. It couldn't last. Before long (comma?) this place, too, would be swallowed up by what was to come. And it was his responsibility to make sure it didn't. He truly wished it wasn't. He had never been good with responsibility. (I like the mystery unfolding)
Escaping himself, his mind drifted away to a sunny island somewhere in the Mediterranean some three millennia past. He thought of the feeling of bare feet touching ground (comma?) again and again as he ran, playing with his friends. He remembered his father's voice from afar. He remembered being safe.

BANG! ( Love it! What a way to bring back to reality)

He snapped back to reality as (repeated above) his chair hit the floor. He'd fallen over. With the wind still knocked out of him (comma?) he managed to get up. As he did he noticed someone standing in front of his desk. Ace. Of course. He should have known. He was the source of the noise; a tall black man now standing in the middle of the room. Ace, wearing the most expensive-looking suit Gil had ever seen, was probably the only man alive who could make dreads and pitch-black sunglasses look all business. Gil had often voiced his opinion that the getup made him look like a 'Men In Black'-reject.

The last traces of smoke were still dissipating around the man as Gilligan began to speak. (like the description of Ace appearing)
"Hi, Ace. (comma) " he managed to wheeze out as he fought to regain his breath. "Could you please, knock next time?"
"Hello, Blood." the man in black said, trying to keep cool, but Gil couldn't help but grudgingly notice the smile creeping up his face. "Heard you were back in town."
"For like an hour! God damn! Can't I get a minute before it's back to business?" He was getting agitated. He hadn't even had his coffeee yet. (lol)
"You had sixty." Ace wasn't even bothering to hide his grin anymore and was now showing a mouthful of teeth.
"Fine." Gil calmed down. "But I need my caffeine, so let's talk over coffee. And stop enjoying this so much! Damn sadist." Ace laughed at the remark and accepted the proposal.

As always, Gil didn't really have any furniture for occasions like having coffee with someone else. Ace, who had gone through this almost ritual-like order of events many times in the past, simply sat down on the soft carpet that covered the room. He had to admit to himself that he actually enjoyed this more than most of his other meetings. Sitting on the floor reminded him of simpler times, and he found the thought of a living legend making him coffee exquisitely amusing.

"So." Gil exclaimed as he finally joined the floor with cups in hand, handing one to his visitor. "Pray tell. To what do I owe the pleasure of your company tonight?" He exaggerated the words in an attempt to get another smile out of the man in black,(repeat, try different descriptor, it may work, since it was used once above) but he had significantly mellowed down during the pause in conversation.

"Lay off the faux courtesy." He managed to turn the entire sentence into a sigh. "I know you think it's funny, but it isn't." He looked tired. Really tired. He had the look of a man on the brink of exhaustion. Gilligan couldn't believe he hadn't noticed until now. (Who says this? And who’s tired-confusion)

"Everything is a mess." Ace explained. "We're preparing on every front, and not one of them is ready. Very few will be in time. Calleus is out recruiting and has had exceedingly bad luck. Cabal is likewise trying to raise an army of his own, but has so far been unsuccessful. Howard and Dawn are dead. Ariana hasn't been seen since shortly after you left and no one knows where to find her and..." He paused for a moment, reading Gilligan's face before continuing. "So basically I've come hoping to see how you've fared, and if you have any news, good or bad, on the matter?"

Gil sat in quiet shock for the better part of a minute. He took a sudden breath as if to say something, then went quiet again. Eventually he regained his composure and managed to speak with only a slight quiver to his voice. "Well. As you know I've spent the year in Egypt trying to give us some more time. I'm sorry to say that I have failed in this. I've also failed to uncover any new ways to give us an edge." Now he paused to let the bad news sink in. Ace seemed, while disappointed, to at least have expected as much. He continued. "As for good news, I was able to recruit a rather large number of allies among the people of Egypt. And I know the whereabouts of Ariana. She tracked me down and told me what her aim was. And I believe her plan might actually give us an advantage we hadn't thought of before."

A sliver of hope flickered to life in Ace's voice. "What is it? When will she be back?"

"I'm afraid I can't tell you that. Let's just hope she succeeds. And in time for it to matter." He took a slow breath collecting his courage to ask. "How did Howie and Dawn die?" Gilligan felt his throat closing up as he spoke the words.
"The way I've heard it, it was some kind of a research accident. Something about refining an energy source beyond known limits. Sounds to me like they might've succeeded."

"I can't believe it..." It was true. He couldn't. (What?) "I've known them since my childhood. And they were ancient even then."

"Death and taxes." Ace stated matter-of-factly.
And the room fell silent.

They finished their coffee without another word before Ace got up, said a quick good bye with the excuse of other business to attend to and disappeared again with another loud BANG!

Left stood Gilligan Blood. Far away were the daydreams of his childhood. Gone were the feelings of calm and safety. Left was smoke. Left was sadness. Left were useless thoughts trying to come up with an answer that wasn't there to be found. (Great ending to the chapter..)
3
3
Review of BELONGING CH 4  Open in new Window.
Review by Bree Author IconMail Icon
In affiliation with The Coffee Shop for the Fantas...  Open in new Window.
Rated: 13+ | (3.0)
Title: Belonging –Chapter 4
Chapter: 4 ID #1798981
Author: CMcMo
Reviewer: BreeC, Sept 02/11
Groups: Coffee Shop for the Fantasy Society, YA Workshop and WDC Power Reviewers



Please keep in mind, these are only my opinion. I’m enjoying your story. Details, I emailed you and its posted at YA
Keep Writing, Bree

1 Plot: Chapter splattered with back story woven into current story line. A visit to a new Doctor and the interaction between Amanda and Dr Brass. More interaction with her family.
2 Style & Voice: Honestly, at times I find your style of wording and word choice a little confusing, for example… The house sat quiet. I rubbed the back of my neck and wrote it off as dreaming. Is the POV from Amanda/Melee? Sometimes, it seems like it, others not so much.

3 Referencing: Modern day, not certain of where, but I don’t think the location is really important, or the size of the town/city.

4 Scene/Setting: I like settings and I’m seeing that you’ve added some description to your story.

5 Characters: I like how you used the room to describe Elizabeth. And how you compared her to their mother.

6 Grammar: I feel some commas are missing in this chapter. I’m still trying to totally understand the proper placement (I know weird), so I won’t add many. Just to point it out for you. I also have seen some switch from past to present tense.

7 Just My Personal Opinion: I would like to see the MC’s name mentioned again. Thanks for using it when her step dad spoke to her. I found some of the sentences a tad awkward.
4
4
Review of BELONGING CH 3  Open in new Window.
Review by Bree Author IconMail Icon
Rated: 13+ | (3.5)
Title: Belonging
Chapter: 3 1798979
Author: CMcMo
Reviewer: BreeC

 BELONGING CH 3 Open in new Window. (13+)
Melee Taria doesn't know why she dreams of her death or why she feels older than 12.
#1798979 by CMcMo Author IconMail Icon


Please keep in mind, these are only my opinion. I’m enjoying your story. Details at YAW and emailed to you.

Keep Writing, Bree

1 Plot: She’s at school, woken from a nightmare. Is this the same dreams from the previous chapter? The story then explains when she was younger and her parents were together and then when her father was captured and then killed. Plot moves to when she’s living with her grandmother in Africa and then how she returns to America (USA?). And then back at school to finish up the chapter.

2 Style & Voice: I like how you began and ended with Melee in school and the middle was backstory. I did however, at times find it difficult to follow. I like the voice of the characters and their behaviour.

3 Referencing: Modern time period.

4 Scene/Setting: I don’t see the scene. Like you mentioned in the reviews for my chapters, I do like to see the setting, and I don’t with your story.

5 Characters: Introduced to new character, Elizabeth. We’re seeing the development and change of their mother. Introduced to her grandmother. I feel like I understand Grandmother…she’s alive with personality. Better understanding of Melee’ behaviour and actions.

6 Grammar: I would still insert commas, for easier flow and better understanding of the story. Is the main story, in the present time or past tense?

7 Just My Personal Opinion: Lots of back story. Sometimes it was too much of switching to different parts of her history. I felt, at times, the story in the back flashes (back story), the flow and time line was a little confusing and out of pace at time.

5
5
Review of BELONGING CH 2  Open in new Window.
Review by Bree Author IconMail Icon
Rated: 13+ | (4.0)
Title: Belonging, Chapter 2
Author: CMcMo
Reviewer: BreeC
 BELONGING CH 2 Open in new Window. (13+)
Nightmares have plagued Melee Taria all her life--and then she learns they are memories.
#1796385 by CMcMo Author IconMail Icon


Please keep in mind, these are only my opinion, and I’m no editor, only a struggling writer, with a story to share. I really enjoyed the first chapter, so I decided to read and review the second chapter. Keep Writing, Bree

1 Plot: Many dreams are told, folding from one and into another. Is Melee always five, or only for the first dream?

2 Style & Voice: Keep in mind when using dialogue, to keep true to the characters’ voice.

3 Referencing: Her dreams appear to be centuries ago, esp. with the reference of the ancient-armor and the swords) Is this foreshadowing of the character being an old soul being re-incarnated into a modern day girl? Or something else? Something to think about.

4 Scene/Setting: Just a suggestion, when she describes the fighting, you should be looking out. One point the text reveals that your view is blocked. When using 1st person, ‘you have to be able to see everything’. I like the way you describe the scene around, not too much details. It suits the action of battle surrounding the characters.

5 Characters: I like how you continue to describe your characters, when we first see them. Does her parents and self possess magical powers, or are the actions because in dreams, anything’s possible?

6 Grammar: Is this story taking place now, as in Present Tense? Because sometimes you’re using present and then switch to past. Perhaps in the dream, you are speaking present tense, this may work, I’m not certain if the tense should be past or present, You are saying “I am a young girl”, so that would say in the past, yet you are 5 in the dream. Worded well in present tense.
Sometimes you need commas for easier flow (I learned that from getting my chapters edited from a member at another group) I placed some, but I’m not certain if that’s where they belong, read the sentences and see if the pause is correct for your character’s voice. I didn’t place all new commas, where I thought they were needed.
When using dialogue, remember the first letter after the closing quotations are small case. Watch your spelling…ax and axe, for example.

7 Just My Personal Opinion: It’s a good idea to change the format of your sentences for variety. This could have happened when you posted your story at WDC, but watch the paragraph breaks, in some places, there’s lots of space when not needed and when a new paragraph would have been needed, especially during dialogue and switching characters actions.
When battle the woman on the statue, it took be a while to figure out that the statue was not the woman, Melee was battling.
I like the words to describe the magical powers of lightning and energy. Great job!

The dreams, could be offset differently, perhaps in italics (I discovered though that italics doesn’t copy over to the WDC site easily)


Bree Proud Member of.....

CSFC
Young Adult Club
WDC Power Reviewers
6
6
Review by Bree Author IconMail Icon
Rated: 13+ | (3.5)
Context -I'm truly enjoying reading this novel, in progress, and anticipating the next chapters.
Imagery - I love the way you describe the settings and the actions of the characters.
Emotion -I can almost feel the emotions of Sean when he either remembers his uncle and their past as well as current interaction.
Grammer and Spelling - Just my opinion, I found some of the sentences rather long and perhaps could have been broken or commas placed for easier flow of the wording. Some spelling mistakes (form should have been from -I do that often)

I have a question, you place brackets around some words, are they personal notes with your writing? I find flackbacks tricky, but sometimes really needed for story telling. I'll leave the part about the time Sean attacked and killed those men. Perhaps need more work for it to work better.
Very mysterious about that The Veil doesn't know that Sean exists and that he shouldn't exist.

I hope to find out how the two met and discovered they were blood related, when the uncle is so much older.

Amazing story and will be reading the next chapter.


Keep Writing,


Bree
Proud member of CSFC
Dragon Raid
7
7
Review by Bree Author IconMail Icon
Rated: 13+ | (4.0)
I really enjoyed this story. I loved your characters mannerism and how you wrote his actions and activities. May I ask what language he chanted?
8
8
Review of Noticing Newbies  Open in new Window.
Review by Bree Author IconMail Icon
Rated: 13+ | (4.0)
Greetings,
I've been a member for a short time. I've posted my first chapter of my current project, however, I'm not sure if I even posted it at the right location. Is there a particular place where I should post it so people can read and comment? What??

Bree
8 Reviews · *Magnify*
Page of 1 · 25 per page   < >
Printed from https://shop.writing.com/main/profile/reviews/breec