Rated: E · Message Forum · Writing · #1937709

A place for discussion on poetry, reviews, contests, etc.

<< Previous  •  Message List  •  Next >>
Reply  •  Post New
Nov 12, 2018 at 6:14pm
#3229404
Re: DISCUSSION: The art of reviewing poetry.
by Tinker Author IconMail Icon
*Dollar* 1,000 GPs were sent to Dave Author Icon with this post.
Dave, Thanks for plugging the reference section at Poetry Magnum Opus. It took me 6 years to compile that information and I have continued to add or amend the information shared over the years. Since I've joined Poet's Café you've shown me new sites and I have added the new information to the site. I have also found mistakes that I made when initially posting the information and have corrected them. Thank you very much for helping me improve my research.

I love that you have chosen "Review" for topic of discussion. At WCD most "reviews" are simple commentary with positive affirmations. I am very guilty of this because I've sometimes met with an unhappy response and most reviews I receive here fall into the nice category. It is so much easier to just find something nice to say about a line or image and then move on,. To really study a poem, discover why I did or did not like specific sections and give an affirmative yet helpful analysis takes a lot of time and a lot of work.

There seem to be many poets at WCD who post their work expecting compliments and really don't want to hear a negative about their creation. Even if it is meant only to help them see through another's eyes. The real trick is sharing a negative as a positive. That is a test of our writing skills. I kind of burnt out reviewing here but with this excellent article by you, I will renew my efforts in that arena. One step at a time.

~~Tink
MESSAGE THREAD
DISCUSSION: The art of reviewing poetry. · 11-12-18 5:09pm
by Dave Author IconMail Icon
*Star* Re: DISCUSSION: The art of reviewing poetry. · 11-12-18 6:14pm
by Tinker Author IconMail Icon
Re: Re: Tink's DISCUSSION: The art of reviewing poetry. · 11-13-18 12:38pm
by Dave Author IconMail Icon
Re: DISCUSSION: The art of reviewing poetry. · 11-12-18 8:27pm
by Lisa Noe Author IconMail Icon
Re: Re: Lisa's DISCUSSION: The art of reviewing poetry. · 11-13-18 12:41pm
by Dave Author IconMail Icon
Re: DISCUSSION: The art of reviewing poetry. · 11-13-18 10:35am
by Jayne Author IconMail Icon
Re: Re: DISCUSSION: The art of reviewing poetry. · 11-13-18 12:38pm
by Tinker Author IconMail Icon
Re: Re: Jayne's DISCUSSION: The art of reviewing poetry. · 11-13-18 12:59pm
by Dave Author IconMail Icon
Re: DISCUSSION: The art of reviewing poetry. · 11-13-18 11:25pm
by 🍀Krista☘️ Author IconMail Icon
Re: Re: DISCUSSION: The art of reviewing poetry. · 11-14-18 10:58am
by Tinker Author IconMail Icon
Re: Re: Queen Kissy's DISCUSSION: The art of reviewing p... · 11-14-18 11:22am
by Dave Author IconMail Icon
Re: Re: Re: Queen Kissy's DISCUSSION: The art of reviewi... · 11-14-18 11:27pm
by 🍀Krista☘️ Author IconMail Icon
Re: DISCUSSION: The art of reviewing poetry. · 11-14-18 9:26am
by The Dark Faery Author IconMail Icon
Re: Re: Gypsy Ann's DISCUSSION: The art of reviewing poe... · 11-14-18 11:27am
by Dave Author IconMail Icon
Re: DISCUSSION: The art of reviewing poetry. · 11-14-18 4:23pm
by Past Member 'oldmonty'
Re: Re: Monty's DISCUSSION: The art of reviewing poetry. · 11-14-18 5:21pm
by Dave Author IconMail Icon
Post a reply...
Bold | Ctrl+BItalics | Ctrl+IUnderline | Ctrl+UStrikethrough | Ctrl+Shift+XHide - Click to RevealSuperscriptSubscriptColorFont TypeText SizeHighlightText AlignmentLine SpacingIndentQuote | Ctrl+Shift+Q@ Symbol - Mention User/ItemInsert EmoticonUpload Photo (Premium Required)SnippetsCreative ToolsCode ViewEditor SettingsUndoRedoToggle Fullscreen

The following applies to this forum item as a whole, not this post. Feedback sent here will go to the forum's owner, Jay O'Toole.
Printed from https://shop.writing.com/main/forums/message_id/3229404