*Magnify*
SPONSORED LINKS
Printed from https://shop.writing.com/main/profile/reviews/harryg/sort_by/r.review_creation_time DESC/page/14
Review Requests: OFF
1,432 Public Reviews Given
1,595 Total Reviews Given
Public Reviews
Previous ... 10 11 12 13 -14- 15 16 17 18 19 ... Next
326
326
Review by Harry
Rated: E | (4.5)
** Image ID #1418992 Unavailable **

Greetings, The Sybaritic Scribe ~

This was a thoroughly enjoyable look at your childhood winters in Maine. It is quite well-written, and it held my interest throughout. Being a southerner, it is hard for me to imagine that much snow! You seem to have quite fond memories of your childhood and that comes through strongly. This is a nice piece of writing!

I did find some things for your consideration:

My [D](d)ad's parents lived there, Dad was raised there, and I
>>>>> Either Dad's parents OR my dad's parents

we discovered our Pastor had >>> pastor

It took my [D](d)ad, my younger brothers, and [I ] (me) two days to shovel
>>>>> my dad // It took me, not I.

Not all our Christmas's were >>>>> Christmas's is possessive. Plural would be Christmases (?, I believe).

a sprawling(,) three-story structure with an attached(,) two-story barn/garage. Connecting the garage to the house was a multi(-)story section

Cheers!

Harry
327
327
Review by Harry
Rated: E | (5.0)
** Image ID #1418992 Unavailable **

Greetings, NickiD89 ~

This has a wonderful feel to it of family and old memories. It is quite well-written.
It gives a bit of your family's history and a pumpkin bread recipe to boot. I found the writing to be nearly perfect except for: a life of [it's](its) own.

Very nice job!

Cheers!

Harry

ASIN: 1435712420
Amazon's Price: $ 15.88
328
328
Review by Harry
Rated: E | (5.0)
** Image ID #1418992 Unavailable **

Greetings, Thayamax ~

Wow! What a heart-wrenching, poignant look at what Alzheimer's effects on a loved one can be. The writing is excellent, and the story is perfectly told. I have no suggestions for any improvement, and I commend you on the excellence of your writing.

Cheers!

Harry

ASIN: 1435712420
Amazon's Price: $ 15.88
329
329
Review of St. Dominick's  
Review by Harry
Rated: E | (5.0)
Greetings, Lou ~

I like it! It makes its point extremely well. This is a nicely written piece.

Cheers!

Harry

** Image ID #1418992 Unavailable **
330
330
Review by Harry
Rated: E | (4.5)
** Image ID #1418992 Unavailable **

Greetings, Whome ~

This was an interesting story, filled with great descriptive details. Nicely done!

I did encounter some things for your consideration:

The sun was shining[, i] (. I)t was going to be a beautiful day[. T](, t)he first day of [S](s)ummer, June 21st.
>>> Don't capitalize summer in lines 1 & 2. You didn't capitalize winter in line three.

The hike was an easy one(;)[, ]I had done it many ... semicolon here

I couldn't see it[, ](;)I more sensed [it's](its) approach.

A long(,) thin(,) gray line was

to muster up a [gail](gale) of profound proportions.

This wasn't ash[,](;) it was snow.

the wind blowing [it's](its) wrath at me

[f](F)ather [w](W)inter as he headed

Cheers!

Harry

ASIN: 1435712420
Amazon's Price: $ 15.88
331
331
Review by Harry
Rated: 18+ | (5.0)
** Image ID #1418992 Unavailable **

Greetings, Diane ~

Bravo! This is an amusing story that was extremely well-written. It held my interest throughout and left me wanting more. (What happened on that date? LOL)
I have absolutely no suggestions for improvement. It is perfect as written.

Cheers!

Harry

ASIN: 1435712420
Amazon's Price: $ 15.88
332
332
Review of The Dream  
Review by Harry
Rated: 13+ | (5.0)
** Image ID #1418992 Unavailable **

Greetings, Jaye P. Marshall ~

This was a well-told story that held my interest throughout. This is a nice piece of writing! You set the climax up quite nicely and then delivered a satisfying ending.

You might wish to consider these points:

It was a beautiful(,) hot summer day (,)and they were cooling

Suddenly(,) the tone of their voices changed

pulled on her heavy(,) woolen robe.

go swimming!" they demanded(.)

"Well," he said slowly[.](,) "I don't see any reason

"I guess," she said with a slight smile at the anxious kids[.](,) "I guess

Again, this is a nicely done story.

Cheers!

Harry
333
333
Review by Harry
Rated: 18+ | (4.5)
** Image ID #1418992 Unavailable **

Greetings, W~W ~

Your story is well-told and holds the reader's attention throughout. The twist at the end is appropriate. Your telling of the tale is fast-paced and interesting. Nice job!

I have a few things for your consideration:

Life is eternal for we dark pixies,>>> for us dark pixies

a soothing turquoise[;](,) reminiscent of a childhood room

walking alone at dusk[;](,) barefooted, wearing shorts, in the fall, will easily attract

I walk faster[, ] (;)he walks faster.

positioned myself on the floor[;](,) remaining perfectly still.

I decide[d] to open my eyes and leap upwards toward him, and finish the business.
As my eyes slowly open[ed], I see >>>>> You switched verb tense here

Cheers!

Harry
334
334
Review of For I love  
Review by Harry
Rated: E | (5.0)
** Image ID #1418992 Unavailable **

Greetings, Joy ~

This is quite uplifting and positive in tone. I particularly like the first stanza of this poem for its impact. Then, the last stanzas offer hope that goodness can vanquish evil someday. Overall, this is an excellent inspirational poem. Nicely done!

Cheers!

Harry
335
335
Review of Please Choose Me  
Review by Harry
Rated: ASR | (5.0)
Greetings, Diane ~

You have done an excellent job of describing the situation in such wonderful detail that holds the reader's attention throughout. You make the reader care about and root for Jeremy and his fate. Then you let the reader imagine his/her own ending. This is exceptional writing! I much enjoyed this.

Only found a few suggestions for you to consider:

Sure, he got into a few scrapes, what boy didn't?
Either: ....scrapes; what OR ...scrapes. What

"Hello(,) ma'am.

Tiffany closed the door behind him(,) and he could hear the women talking inside.
OR maybe separate into two sentences. ...him. He

Cheers!

Harry
336
336
Review of My Love For You  
Review by Harry
Rated: E | (4.5)
Greetings, AutumnMae ~

Your poem is intensely personal in its expression of your hurt and love. It is well-rhymed, and I found only a couple of grammatical errors:

I love the way you make me smile every day[;] >>no semicolon here
and how I have that "love sick" look

Allowing myself to get close to you I did forbid;
and I didn't want to experience pain like before.
>>>>> Either use a comma instead of semicolon OR omit the 'and'.

I didn't think I could possibly love you any more[;](,)
but with each passing day my love steadily grew.

There's only one true explanation I can implore;
is that I am so madly in love with you.
>>>>There's only one true explanation I can implore --
[is] that I am so madly in love with you.
OR
The[re's] only one true explanation I can implore[;]
is that I am so madly in love with you.

I hope the person who you wrote this for realizes your love has grown stronger. *Smile*

Cheers!

Harry

** Image ID #1418992 Unavailable **



337
337
Review of Dream Catcher.  
Review by Harry
Rated: 13+ | (4.5)
Greetings, G.A. ~

This piece captures the feelings of dispair and loneliness quite well. However, I wondered if perhaps you could avoid using these overused expressions -- I am an empty shell, balancing on a precipice, drowning in a cesspool. The last paragraph about the dreamcatcher brings a freshness to the writing that is wanting in the earlier descriptions. You are a good writer, as this piece shows.

Cheers!

Harry

** Image ID #1418992 Unavailable **
338
338
Review by Harry
Rated: ASR | (5.0)
Greetings, Legerdemain ~

Wow, what a tightly written, fast-paced ride you take the reader on in this piece.
Your descriptions are excellent. I particularly liked the line: I continue firing down the road like a rocket. You are an excellent writer.

I did note a few grammatical suggestions:

tunnel through the groping branches of the trees above(,) and I hurtle through the arched darkness

Two tiny(,) green reflections,

My heart beats even faster(,) and I can feel the perspiration

I'm within 100 yards of it[,](;) my jaw is clenched[, ](;)my teeth grind together.

I throw my head back(,) and it connects with the headrest. My leg stiffens(,) but I can't get on the brake.

This piece resonates with anyone who has ever driven down a country road at night and encountered deer in the middle of the road. A nightmare indeed.

Cheers!

Harry

** Image ID #1418992 Unavailable **
339
339
Review by Harry
Rated: ASR | (5.0)
Greetings, Countrymom ~

This poem has a warm, good feeling to it. It is well-rhymed, and, when read, it flows smoothly. The poet seems quite contented with her surroundings and peacefully at home. Overall, this is a rather nicely penned piece. *Smile*

Cheers!

Harry

** Image ID #1418992 Unavailable **



340
340
Review of Painted  
Review by Harry
Rated: E | (4.5)
Greetings, TennisPlayer ~

Sounds like you learned your lesson. Ths poem makes the important point that one must be true to his own self, rather thsn adopt false traits trying to impress others.

A few suggestions:

I [have] misled myself.
I [have] changed myself for the wrong reason[s].
>>> omit the have, omit the 's' on reasons to better rhyme with season.

No, and I would put it back on the shelf.
>>>> If not, I would...

In stanza three, you break the pattern of rhyming lines 2 & 4 as found in all the other stanzas. Why?

My new friends faded[,](;) my old ones ditched me.

But if I ever wanted to survive through this prison they called school[.](,)
I couldn’t continue living a façade.

Good luck with your schooling.

Cheers!

Harry
341
341
Review of Truman's Folly  
Review by Harry
Rated: ASR | (3.5)
Dear Elisa ~

Purely as a poem, this may be okay. As history, it is truly terrible. Truman and the U.S. won a race to develop the atomic bomb against Nazi Germany. Had Germany won that race, we'd all be speaking German today. Truman dropped the two bombs on Japan to end WWII after it became apparent that Japan was prepared to fight to the last man, woman, and child defending its shores from invasion. Dropping the bombs saved hundreds of thousands of American soldiers' lives. I would have dropped the bombs without hesitation.

Your true imperial lust
has made us xenophobic.
>>>>> What imperial lust? Japan attacked us and we defended ourselves. Likewise, North Korea, then China, invaded our ally South Korea and we came to their aid. Please show me any evidence of Truman displaying any imperial lust ever. We were attacked first. Truman was never the aggressor.

Truman was far from being a buffoon.

A poet has a responsibility to write truth in his/her work and to know something of which they write.

Cheers!

Harry
342
342
Review by Harry
Rated: E | (4.0)
Greetings, Char ~

You certainly seem joyful! The poem is a bit ragged, however. The great disparity in line lenghts is somewhat disconcerting. And maybe not start all four lines of stanzas two with I.

I swoon in joy.
I drink in the happiness of the air.
I paddle my way through in the ocean of hopes and dreams.
I have found the elixir of life.
>>>> Perhaps instead:
I swoon in joy,
as I drink in the happiness of the air.
I paddle my way through in the ocean of hopes and dreams,
for I have found the elixir of life.

The last two stanzas are too much alike. Maybe omit the next to last stanza and just keep the last stanza?
I choose[,] to dream.
To hope.
To love.
To dare.
[To live.]
I choose to live.

Do with my suggestions as you will.

Cheers!

Harry
343
343
Review by Harry
Rated: E | (5.0)
Greetings, Lou ~

This poem has such a good feel about it. I have ridden the green and red streetcars through the Garden District in New Orleans on several visits there. I too have a sentimental feeling about having them running again through the streets of N.O.

This poem has many wonderful images of N.O. in it:
trees clutching strands of Mardi Gras beads, jazz bands marching down the street, floats, balconies, etc. I particularly liked the closing lines.

Nicely written. No suggestions for improvement.

I am looking forward to receiving soon my copy of Awash With Words.

Cheers!

Harry
344
344
Review of The River  
Review by Harry
Rated: E | (4.5)
Greetings, Christopher ~

This poem evokes lovely images of life along the river -- of water, wildlife, and cool breezes ruffling the oak tree's leaves. Very nicely written piece!

I do have a few punctuation suggestions for you to consider:

where I fish for trout(,) watching water embrace
>>> Are you doing the watching (comma needed), or are the trout doing the watching (then correct without comma)?

White(,) frothy water cools the smooth(,) brown bed stone,
its eddies whirl(,) then rest in a calm, clear pool

Overall, a very nice poem.

Cheers!

Harry
345
345
Review of Seasons  
Review by Harry
Rated: ASR | (4.0)
Greetings, Shannon ~

The content is fine here. However, this is said to be an English sonnet. You have the format of three quatrains with six alternating rhymes with a rhyming couplet at the end correct. However, an English sonnet has lines of five iambic feet (10 syllables in length). Your lines do not conform to this five iambic feet requirement. Hence, to me it is not truly an English sonnet.

Cheers!

Harry
346
346
Review of The Red Knight  
Review by Harry
Rated: ASR | (4.5)
Greetings, The Pheasant ~

This is a delightful story, well-told. It held my interest throughout. You did an excellent job with the rhyming couplets. Plus it included a good life lesson at the end. Nicely written!

There were a few punctuation errors:
Here is the reason for all my commotion(.)
My mother was cursed by a grim witch’s potion(.)

“If you eat the Red Knight(,) then I’ll stop my lament!”

I enjoyed reading your poem.

Cheers!

Harry
347
347
Review by Harry
Rated: ASR | (4.5)
Greetings, Viv ~

This poem captures your feelings of pain quite well.
However, it leaves the reader wondering how you were betrayed/hurt. What is the basis for such pain?
"Now I cry because my heart is torn." is the only explanation given. A better explanation (or at least a hint as to the nature of the offense)of such hurtful pain might add to this poem.

I sit here, tears filling my breast,
clogging my throat, burning my eyes.
>>>>> I don't think of tears filling one's breast or clogging a throat. Maybe "emotion" would work better than "tears" here.

Pain, pain go away[,](;)
don’t return any other day.
>>>>> "on another day" ?? another vs any other ?

I tried to help her[,](;) I really did.

Which way to turn, where to go(?)[,]

This poem conveys a lot of pain, even anguish...without the reader understanding fully what happened to cause such strong emotion.

Cheers!

Harry
348
348
Review of Imagine a War...  
Review by Harry
Rated: 13+ | (4.0)
Greetings, Jenbo ~

I found this very interesting and quite entertaining. You created very graphic images throughout. You tell a good story! Anyone interested in a good war story would enjoy the detailed descriptions you provide.

I wasn't sure about the anthrax. If the soldier contacted it from the soil (bad camp location) as implied, why was he the only soldier to come down with it? If he got it from the undercooked food from the Kenyans, I think it would have taken longer to manifest itself. You might want to recheck this part to be sure it conforms to medical facts. Also, unless he had received an anthrax vaccine previously, he would not have anthrax-reactive antibodies after only a couple of days. Producing antibodies requires weeks usually.

Overall, you are a good writer. I did have quite a number of suggestions for proper punctuation and some word corrections: ( ) = insert // [ ] = delete

all my mid(-)air drills(,) I had

put a magazine on my weapon >>>> on or in?

'You al(l) right(,) Corporal Atkins?' he asked, pointing at my limp.
‘Landed on them damn tree stumps(, s)[S]ir,' I said.
>>>>>> Why only one ' for dialogue instead of the customary " throughout? Is this an English style?

No heroics(,) Corporal Atkins[, i](. I)f that foot gets any worse(,) let me know.'
'Yes(, s)[S]ir, I'll try and press on[,](;) maybe I can walk it off,' I said, unconvinced[, and b](. B)eneath the brow of his helmet I saw him raise a camouflage(-)darkened eyebrow

Archer's Post[, s](. S)o intense was the heat that

during the low(-)level approach(,) and(,) in the cramped, stifling, fuel(-)smelling air(,) some

anti(-)tank weapons

task of navigating(,) as A Company would be leading the battalion and our platoon would be leading the company. It came as no surprise[, t](. T)here was meant to be pockets of enemy on our advance(,) and Lieutenant Gray hated me.

under the Kenyan sun(,) and with enemy ahead we had to

during the low(-)level approach were struck down with dehydration(,) although my section was still

say ten yards [passed](past) the start line would be

crossed the border(,) and I was as surprised

dry river wadi(. O)[o]nce the water bottles had been filled(,) I went to

rucksack(,) he came across and said, ‘You too(,) Corporal Atkins.’

I sussed what >>>> "sussed" ?? What is sussed?

if I took my boot off(,) I'd never get it back on again, but he insisted, made it an order(,) and five minutes later we were watching my blackened foot swell in his red(-)filtered torchlight.

Thank you very much(, s)[S]ir.

called the medic(,) who appeared instantly.

for nothing(,) and I'd faced off with him

Having said that(,) Sergeant Cooper was

hand(.)[,] '[y](Y)ou're off to

a dirt track(,) and every rut [he](we) bounced over

The driver dipped his lights(,) and(,) as if seeing us for the first time(,) the cat darted into the bush.

dry river valley(,) but I could easily make out the ends of the low(,) two(-)man tents looking

straight from the DZ to >>>> You keep switching between DZ and drop zone throughout. After first introducing the abbreviation DZ, why use drop zone again?

After getting my foot strapped(,) I was led to my open camp bed[, a](. A)ll the tents were taken and full of snoring heat victims from the day(')s march.

brushing an inch(-)long(,) brown scorpion from under the stale(-)smelling pillow.

Once the A Company vanguard had cleared the first positions(,) B and C Companies would

I was woken an hour or so later by the crumpf of mortar rounds landing on the battalion's objectives. The mortars were due to start pounding the enemy positions at H-minus five
>>>>>> This section/paragraph is excellent in its description of the sounds and sights of the mortar barrage and subsequent action. Quite nicely written!
*Smile*

lit the far(-)off sky(,) and moments

The enemy had personnel carries(,) and I
>>>>> carries or carriers ?

blowing in the right direction(,) I might even get

the nasal(-)busting smell of cordite that eventually teased my senses, but the smell of cooking(.) [and i](I)nstantly my stomach

Some vegetables of a kind had already been pealed
>>>> peeled

Once the meat had been stripped and placed in the sizzling stir-fry(,) the remaining carcass was
dropped

'Rise and shine(,) you sickies[, w](. W)e've got a

'What'll it be(,) Andy?

My bowels(,) however(,) were playing a different game and exploded from me before I got to my feet. I was drenched in sweat(,) and my face felt too hot to touch. I'd forgotten about my sprained ankle[,](;) my legs collapsed under me as I tried to stand. I was falling forwards. Time had stopped. The mustard(-)dark earth was rushing to meet my face(,) but I couldn't

I came to[o]

>>>>> Okay. You should have had plenty of examples of the sort of corrections needed by now = run-on sentences, comma separating person addressed in dialogue, commas after clauses, hypenate compound adjectives, etc. I'll leave it up to you to find and make these corrections in the remainer of the story.
Once cleaned up, this story will be excellent.

Welcome to Writing.com! We can always use another writer as talented as you. *Smile*

Cheers!

Harry
349
349
Review of The Black Death  
Review by Harry
Rated: ASR | (4.0)
Greetings, Nekogal ~

The title of your poem caught my eye since I am a retired microbiologist. Your bio says you are a fairly new writer and desire critique of your work. Please take my comments to follow as merely my opinion for you to do with as you please. *Smile*

In the first line, "Her" refers to whom? I assumed from the title, it meant Black Death, but it appears to be an unidentified woman. This was confusing to me.

You need either a semicolon after line two or a period, with "They" capitalized in line three.

chaos fills the worlds peaceful order.>>>> world's

Evilness sheds its darkness >>>> sheds or spreads

Semicolon after line three, second quatrain.

The form of this poem is quite jumbled. The first two stanzas are long-lined quatrains. Then, the next stanza has much shorter line lengths. Then, you abandon the quatrain format all together. The constant variation in format of stanzas was confusing.

Also, is this a rhymed poem or not? Some stanzas have rhymes; others don't. You should strive for a consistent pattern.

hoping that the sickness had not reached these bounds.
>>>>> much longer line than rest of this stanza's lines. Split:
hoping that the sickness
had not reached these bounds.

that he cannot flee Death, for he is everywhere.
Split into two lines:
that he cannot flee Death,
for he is everywhere. >>> The "he" here is confusing. The man or Death is everywhere? Maybe "it" referring to death would read better.

I like the story you tell. Just clean up the presentation and you'll have a winner.

Cheers!

Harry
350
350
Review of Never Leave Me  
Review by Harry
Rated: 13+ | (5.0)
Greetings, Viv ~

This is an excellently written short story. It is easy to see why it placed third in that national contest. It really held my onterest throughout.

I have only one suggestion: Do not capitalize such titles as sir, miss, ma'am, or honey in dialogue (see examples below):

“Ah, Honey, we didn’t do anything except love him

“Howdy, Ma’am, Miss.”

“Thank you, Sir, for offering
“You are right, Sir.”
You are rather naive, Sir.

It was a pleasure reading your story!

Cheers!

Harry
483 Reviews · *Magnify*
Page of 20 · 25 per page   < >
Printed from https://shop.writing.com/main/profile/reviews/harryg/sort_by/r.review_creation_time DESC/page/14