*Magnify*
SPONSORED LINKS
Printed from https://shop.writing.com/main/profile/reviews/ion_7/sort_by/r.review_creation_time DESC/page/8
Review Requests: ON
1,587 Public Reviews Given
1,588 Total Reviews Given
Public Reviews
Previous ... 4 5 6 7 -8- 9 10 11 12 13 ... Next
176
176
Review of The Mirror  
Review by brom21
In affiliation with Fantasy and Science Fiction So...  
Rated: E | (4.5)

The following are my own observations and opinions that are intended to improve your work. Take and leave what you will. Below, your words are in parenthesis mine are not.


This review is done to celebrate your WdC anniversary! Congratulations!


(She was there, again, that girl, with long, dark hair that swished against the wind.)
Usually when we speak of a mirror, it is indoors yet there is wind and no indoor air current could actually move hair around. If this is outdoors, than indicate it with a brief mention like-“…wind in the forest” or what have you.


(The haunting girl had a small nose from which I could somehow feel the warm air delicately coming out. Her lips were thin and colourless but strangely beautiful. She had the palest skin I had ever seen, almost white as in shock, but if shock had been the cause of this, she stood behind a veil of indifference.)
By this paragraph, I am not sure if she is seeing a reflection of herself or another person. At the beginning, I thought it was a self-reflection.


(“we are strangely apart, yet strangely close together.” She then vanished making everything disappear with her and I found myself staring at the ceiling of my bedroom, in my freezing, uncomfortable bed…)
Only her is it obvious it is another person in the mirror.


(…what I felt was as if a puddle was splashing me with unhappiness, insipidness, melancholy… )
Here, as in other times, it is best to show and not tell the emotion the narrator is feeling. Use the five senses or metaphors or similes to make something like-“…with a numbness in my heart and I felt like a rotting gangly tree. My was void of anything that would lift my soul out of its dark trench…”


(…soaked with rain and saw myself laughing meanly at the grey clouds…)
Just a little snippet of advice - try to use more succinct, simpler words. For example, you could have-“…and I saw myself scoffing at the grey clouds.” Usually you get plenty of chances to do this.


(Sensations began to surround me, I felt the humidity of a shop full of people refusing to stand in the rain, I took my T-shirt off, trying to release myself from that horrible yet adorable (just a few days ago) sensation.)
Here, the two commas should be semicolons. Also, the use of the parenthesis is stilted. You could say something like-“…, I took my T-shirt off, trying to release myself from that horrible yet adorable sensation that started a few days ago.” From the best of my ability, this is what you meant.


(I began conscious of the rain reaching my roof and I felt as if every droplet was a sharp knife thrown at high speed from somewhere up there, from someone who wanted to kill me, to torture me, to simply destroy me… I couldn’t stand the noise any more, I screamed as if wanting the rain to shut up, but nothing happened.)
First, this should start like “I began to be conscious…” Next put a dash between “wanted to kill me” and “to torture me.” Lastly, put a semicolon after “any more.”


(I felt strange, why was I suddenly feeling like this? Why did all the wonderful things I used to love about rain make me feel like this? What was happening to me? Why wasn’t rain lending a hand to me and guiding me into a world of happiness, as it used to do? Every answer to these questions was a salty, warm tear that rolled down my freezing cheek. I sat on my bed wanting to disappear into thin air, asking myself the same questions over and over again trying to gain an approvable answer. Suddenly I knew why… there was something I needed tremendously… I needed her… She was the only person that could make me happy nowadays, and at night time when everything vanished and I found myself back in my bed it seemed as if half of me died… the only thing I could do was step inside the mirror and leave my life, but I didn’t care, I didn’t care about my family anymore, nor my friends, I didn’t care if rain was ever to cross my life again, I simply didn’t care… I just wanted to be with her…)
What you have above is excellent! It clearly illustrates the person’s desperation and longing for the woman in the mirror. You delve into the mental and emotional affliction of the narrator. I can see the apathy and self-torment of the person. This was a diamond in the rough of your story thus far.


(I knew what this meant, she was outside and I was inside the mirror… Tears began to invade my eyes, but it wasn’t because I was no longer with her, I felt something else… I felt betrayed, angry, sad, trapped… but what I most felt was what I had to do. Go for the next victim…)
A very a clever twist at the end. I would again say to show the betrayal, anger and sadness but I honestly this it fits in this instance.


Overall, my interest was piqued at the middle I would say. The beginning segment was a little stilted and confusing. But you really came through at the end. There were points where you just named an emotion rather than show it. This is easily fixed as you will see. Great work and happy WdC anniversary!




Anniversary Reviews email siggie
177
177
Review of Freedom's Crown  
Review by brom21
In affiliation with Fantasy and Science Fiction So...  
Rated: E | (4.0)
Great poem. I’ve never come across a contest where there are words that can’t be used. I guess it makes you dig deeper into your creativity. I really liked the forth stanza because of the last two lines. Nice work and keep writing.
178
178
Review of Faceless Moon  
Review by brom21
In affiliation with Fantasy and Science Fiction So...  
Rated: 13+ | (4.0)
The following are my own observations and opinions that are intended to improve your work. Take and leave what you will. Below, your words are in parenthesis mine are not.


This review is done to celebrate your WdC anniversary! Congratulations!


One thing I like about your poem was how you showed each line varying from short to long in length. The way you set up the reader with a complex musing then give a plain, deep reaction in one or few words is quite alluring. The whole piece can be summed up in one word-longing. Great job and happy WdC anniversary!





Anniversary Reviews email siggie
179
179
Review by brom21
In affiliation with Fantasy and Science Fiction So...  
Rated: E | (5.0)
The following are my own observations and opinions that are intended to improve your work. Take and leave what you will. Below, your words are in parenthesis mine are not.


This review is done to celebrate your WdC anniversary! Congratulations!


(He tried distracting himself, thinking about his homework, his TV shows and games, his art, but inevitably his mind kept drifting back to his backpack, or, more specifically, to one of its contents in particular.)
Very good second opening paragraph! I am very interested and curious at this point.


(He had found it during recess.)
Nice way to allude to a past experience that this sentence gives. It draws the reader in.


(The way that it moved looked exactly like the way a human being runs, supporting his suspicion that it was, in fact, a bug-sized human being.)
Here, Joshua reacts too casually to seeing a shrunken human being. How would you react?


(Josh's mind snapped back to the present, suddenly aware that the bus had almost arrived at his home.)
I think it was very unique and clever to go from a short recollection then return to the present like you do in the paragraph beginning with the above sentence.


(…anticipation, and when the bus pulled up in front of his house, he stood up and got off.)
Here, just chop words and say something like -“he exited” or “he stepped out.”


This was truly a captivating first chapter! The flow and simple comprehensive manner really brought me into me into Joshua’s mind and his environment he interacted with made vivid scenes and actions. There were only one or two grammar blips through the whole chapter! Great job with that! If this was the original draft, you’re really blessed person. Happy WdC anniversary!





Anniversary Reviews email siggie
180
180
Review of Water's Test  
Review by brom21
In affiliation with Fantasy and Science Fiction So...  
Rated: E | (3.0)
The following are my own observations and opinions that are intended to improve your work. Take and leave what you will. Below, your words are in parenthesis mine are not.


This review is done to celebrate your WdC anniversary! Congratulations!


I did like your poem but the length of each line and the complex abstractness made it hard to hear the rhyming and discern the meanings of your poem. Personally, my favorite poem type is couplets. But I would suggest putting this in stanzas by putting every couplet by itself spaced from each other. This will really help to bring out the rhyming and absorb what you are saying. I can tell there is a lot of untapped potential given the extent of your lines. Juts try to make it more coherent. I think it would simplify things if you shortened your lines but that is my personal palate. I’m sure you could work out a really good poem with longlines but more comprehendible. Happy WdC anniversary!





Anniversary Reviews email siggie
181
181
Review by brom21
In affiliation with Fantasy and Science Fiction So...  
Rated: E | (4.0)
The following are my own observations and opinions that are intended to improve your work. Take and leave what you will. Below, your words are in parenthesis mine are not.


This review is done to celebrate your WdC anniversary! Congratulations!


(That's when the idea popped into her mind: "Every child deserves a teddy bear.")
Just a head’s up, put thoughts in italics.


You definitely gave a spot on sweet personality. It was fascinating to see her daily regimen with the opening sentences. Your flash story was not confusing in the least either. I love how you end this. It piqued my interest. I wonder what will happen next for this kind old woman. You had great description as well. One suggestion I do have is to break the block of text into smaller paragraphs and lines. Happy Wdc anniversary!








Anniversary Reviews email siggie
182
182
Review by brom21
In affiliation with Fantasy and Science Fiction So...  
Rated: 13+ | (4.5)
The following are my own observations and opinions that are intended to improve your work. Take and leave what you will. Below, your words are in parenthesis mine are not.


This review is done to celebrate your WdC anniversary! Congratulations!




Great story - so short but so interesting and vivid. Great idea with the character reflecting on the brief account that was to be narrated. It draws the reader in and sets up the story to follow. One thing I noticed was the strong, realistic personalities and voices of the characters. They really pop out especially at the beginning prelude – nice and gritty! You really show powerful emotion too. I could not find any errors or sentence level stuff that was amiss. This was very well written. Now this is not just a simple pat on the shoulder with no constructive feedback. No wonder you have a perfect five star average. This was excellent! And what a hook at the end! Happy WdC anniversary!





Anniversary Reviews email siggie
183
183
Review of What The...?  
Review by brom21
In affiliation with Fantasy and Science Fiction So...  
Rated: 13+ | (4.0)

The following are my own observations and opinions that are intended to improve your work. Take and leave what you will. Below, your words are in parenthesis mine are not.


This review is done to celebrate your WdC anniversary! Congratulations!


(“Thanks, butthead,” she muttered with a fond smirk.)
Here, I would show how she smiled that way. Maybe you could have something like-“…a coy grin met with glistening eyes that reflected from her brother.


Congratulations for making such a complete and interesting story in so few words. I have trouble with doing this myself. The thing I like about very short stories is that they linger in the mind than longer pieces. I am curious as to what will happen next and how the two siblings will spend the money. You did a nice job with this.I also like how there were no spelling or grammar issues. Kudos for that! Happy WdC anniversary!




Anniversary Reviews email siggie
184
184
Review by brom21
In affiliation with Fantasy and Science Fiction So...  
Rated: E | (5.0)
The following are my own observations and opinions that are intended to improve your work. Take and leave what you will. Below, your words are in parenthesis mine are not.


This review is done to celebrate your WdC anniversary! Congratulations!


(“You are not as funny as you think you are Case.” Talia groaned, watching with the same brown eyes as her brother over-dramatized his voyage across her room.)
Here, show and don’t tell what this-“… over-dramatized his voyage across her room.” means.


(He was wearing his pre-worn out jeans, and a navy blue sweater that read "Bayside Commodore's" across the chest in gold.)
With this, just say something like-“…old worn out jeans. Also, put this-“Bayside Commodore's" in italics since it is not being said or stressed. Finally, say “Casey” instead of “He” as it sounds like the father is being described with the father being the preceding noun in the previous paragraph.


("Dad left this." she held up the note for Casey to see.)
Here, ”she” should in caps.


("Nothing O, it's okay." She put on a barely brave face.)
Here, I would show how Talia put on a brave face. Put something like-“She struggled to keep her face from grimacing or shedding tears. It was the best she could do.” This is, of course, my own little example but you could easily come up with something richer.


(She quickly put on some simple make-…)
Here. I think you mean “makeup.”


(…, hoping adding some normal to this mess of a morning would help her feel better. It did not.)
Above, it sounds like you mean ,…hoping that adding some normal mess…”


This was very well written. And that means something coming from me because I am quite the stickler. The few blips I mentioned above did not get in the way of how sad and deeply engrossing this was. I loved it! It was also easy to follow. Did you do any revising to this? If this was your first draft it was very good. You must read a lot. Happy WdC anniversary !



Anniversary Reviews email siggie



185
185
Review of Round 1: Coe Luna  
Review by brom21
In affiliation with Fantasy and Science Fiction So...  
Rated: E | (3.0)
The following are my own observations and opinions that are intended to improve your work. Take and leave what you will. Below, your words are in parenthesis mine are not.


This review is done to celebrate your WdC anniversary! Congratulations!


(She lowers it back down, intending to leave it, but the thought of pirates gives her pause, and though she has more valuable items in her possession (the modest amount of coins, the medical herbs, and the identity papers that gain its owner safe passage through certain soldier infested large cities and capitals), it’s the horse whose absence would sear a hole in her heart.)
This sentence is too long.


(Above them, a melody of bat wings and soundless song, guided by their vibrations that strike obstacles in their way, flapping hard and keeping to their dark stone sky.)
This is a fragment. I would just say something like-“… by their vibrations that strike obstacles in their way causes them to keep flapping hard and to continue under their dark stone sky.”

(…,watching as the Guide straightens up to his full height, and immediately begins to shrink. Dark brown hair sprouts into long ruby locks descending in waves over a slim distinctly feminine frame. A rich blue texture drapes the woman’s body, and one of the bats flapping overhead suddenly descends with a soft, crooning call, and lands on her shoulder.)
Here, what exactly is happening? The Guide shrinks then suddenly you describe dark brown hair forming. Also, there is contrast between dark brown and the red color of a ruby. Also, I would explain more where pirates come into play in this round rather than do so later.


(“I - you - what are you?” Besa trembles, frightened.)
Here, you should say something like “I - you - what are you?” Besa utters, as she trembles, with fright” to show she is talking.
Overall, I would advise condensing your sentences. They tend to carry on too much with lots of commas. There were times when I had to re-read things and it was hard to picture scenes and images frequently. However, what you successfully described was done quite well. Good job for that. Just go back and proofread a bit more so you spot long or awkward points. Happy WdC anniversary.





Anniversary Reviews email siggie
186
186
Review of Life The unknown  
Review by brom21
In affiliation with Fantasy and Science Fiction So...  
Rated: ASR | (5.0)
The following are my own observations and opinions that are intended to improve your work. Take and leave what you will. Below, your words are in parenthesis mine are not.


This review is done to celebrate your WdC anniversary! Congratulations!


Although poetry is not my strong point, I do think this poem lacks proper punctuation. I have done the same thig with my poems.
If there are three words that describe this poem it would be complexity, depth and variation. A particular thing I like in poems, and what you show as well, is that things are happening and a story of sorts is being told with emotions interwoven into an experience. The brevity of each line makes the poem linger in the mind and makes one reflect in wonder. Beside this is an experience, it does not read like a big paragraph broken into lines. There are pauses, reflections and points that are carried alone in single lines. The heart of the narrator is richly displayed and very exceptionally artful. Fine work. Happy WdC anniversary!


Anniversary Reviews email siggie
187
187
Review by brom21
In affiliation with Fantasy and Science Fiction So...  
Rated: E | (4.0)
The following are my own observations and opinions that are intended to improve your work. Take and leave what you will. Below, your words are in parenthesis mine are not.


This review is done to celebrate your WdC anniversary! Congratulations!


There are a few things I like about this poem. First it really drives in the pain that fear creates and I love your use of the repetition of the one line (I forget what it is called in poetic terms.) I think, as is obvious, that your crowning part was the last stanza – very affective and succinctly put! Also the brevity makes the meaning and emotion linger in the mind. You really made be reflect how simple and short it is. Great work and happy WdC anniversary!





Anniversary Reviews email siggie
188
188
Review by brom21
In affiliation with Fantasy and Science Fiction So...  
Rated: E | (4.0)
The following are my own observations and opinions that are intended to improve your work. Take and leave what you will. Below, your words are in parenthesis mine are not.


This review is done to celebrate your WdC anniversary! Congratulations!


(This makes me think of the book of Ecclesiastes. At the end it says life is hard and that life is but a breath and to live happily and to enjoy the fruits of one’s labor is the best thing you can do. Just to live life and “enjoy the sun” as you so eloquently put it, is what is all about and also to fear God too. My favorite lines are-
My heart is warm.
I feel so alive,
But what about when I die?
What will the world be like?
Did I affect it in any way?
Will my life mean something?

I think there were some grammar blips. I’ve already marked the changes to the above stanzas. Poetry grammar is by no means my forte but I believe I got it right. This was a lovely poem! Thank you and happy WdC anniversary!




Anniversary Reviews email siggie

189
189
Review of Snowball Fights  
Review by brom21
In affiliation with Fantasy and Science Fiction So...  
Rated: E | (3.0)
The following are my own observations and opinions that are intended to improve your work. Take and leave what you will. Below, your words are in parenthesis mine are not.


This review is done to celebrate your WdC anniversary! Congratulations!


I think you have your general concept laid out but it was a little too cut and dry. It basically reads like a paragraph broken into lines. I think your poem would really be good if you focused on more poetic elements like imagery and symbolism. It would really shine of you put in some similes or metaphors. I’m not saying this would be easy but of you took your meaning and experimented a bit; it would draw out the reader and affect his emotions. All in all, you have the backbone of a really good poem. Happy WdC anniversary.





Anniversary Reviews email siggie
190
190
Review by brom21
In affiliation with Fantasy and Science Fiction So...  
Rated: 13+ | (4.0)
The following are my own observations and opinions that are intended to improve your work. Take and leave what you will. Below, your words are in parenthesis mine are not.


This review is done to celebrate your WdC anniversary! Congratulations!


(I wanted to argue. I had, in the past, and always got the same answer. She had no choice. We shared the same body, and as much as I might want to put an end to it, she couldn't. It wasn't allowed. She needed my consciousness. It was part of what allowed her to exist. In return, I existed perpetually. Or nearly so.)
This paragraph is a little extravagantly obscure. Explain is simpler up front terms of the relationship of two people and the single body and how it works. Also, the last sentence (Or nearly so) is a fragment.


(I used to think it was a boon; immortality.)
Remember a semicolon joins two complete clauses so it will not work here. What you’re looking for is a dash.


(Again, I cursed her for choosing me. She'd been given thirty or so men before me, and she had killed them all for being 'unsuitable'. I wondered if she ever had second-thoughts about her choice. Of course, now it was too late. For either of us. )
Once again, you’re being too vague. I get that you want foreshadowing and mystery, but you need more clarity. Again, the last sentence is a fragment.


(I allowed her to tend to us without complaint until,…)
Here, specify that she is tending to the joint body they both share. What you have is confusing. Put something like-”She cared patiently for the body we both dwelled in,…)


("Why don't you fly?" she asked.
"Afraid I'll starve to death before we get there?" I replied sourly.
Quietly, "You used to like it.")
Above, ether change what you have for explaining things better or explain things right after you have from these three dialog lines. The paragraph following this does not do so.


("Afraid I'll starve to death before we get there?" I replied sourly./ "Where do you want to go?" she asked.)
In the first sentence, it seems they are headed to a sure destination. Then you have the next line later on inferring they’re not.


(As my body changed, so did my perception. No longer was I limited to the visible spectrum of light, but every spectrum of light and energy. Infrared, ultraviolet, electromagnetic, radio. I could even tune in to gamma and cosmic radiation if I wanted. Despite being in the middle of the Himalayas, the silence turned into a static of chattering voices, in every conceivable language, as I began to intercept stray broadcasts, bouncing off the ionosphere. I boosted off the ground and gained altitude rapidly, the signals getting clearer as the horizon extended further away.)
This paragraph really puts the sci-fi element into the whole character intro. It is very precise and descriptive. The only error is with this sentence-“Infrared, ultraviolet, electromagnetic, radio.” It is a fragment. To fix it, put a dash before it and after the second sentence. I thought this story was very alluring and it plays with my sense of reality. Like a stated before, it is just a little too obscure at times. I think you have a great imagination, just interpret it a bit more clearly. Happy WdC anniversary!






Anniversary Reviews email siggie
191
191
Review of Tea  
Review by brom21
In affiliation with Fantasy and Science Fiction So...  
Rated: 13+ | (3.0)
The following are my own observations and opinions that are intended to improve your work. Take and leave what you will. Below, your words are in parenthesis mine are not.


This review is done to celebrate your WdC anniversary! Congratulations!


(Her hundred and seventeen year old hands could feel the pain from the arthritis.)
Here, I would reword it to make it more effective and precise. Maybe something like-“Her hundred-and seventeen-year old hands ached with pain from the arthritis.” Notice that I put dashes to show they go together.


(It all pasted with time.)
Here, “pasted” should be “passed.”


(Hell, even her arthritis was sixty years old.)-( even the sixty year old arthritis would give up and go away.)
Above, it sounds like the woman is sixty years old too. But what you mean to say is it started sixty years ago. Clarify this and say something like-“Even her arthritis that started when she was 57, was old like her.” It would be a good idea to state it when she first mentions her arthritis rather than state it later like you do in your other sentence.


( " That is what thought, Arthi", she giggled out as she looked at her hands. She had named and started talking to her arthritis back in 1979.)
Here, the first sentence makes no sense. Also, you use the word “she” too many times in succession.


(If she crossed names between the coffee maker (Fred) and the trashcan (Roger), no one would fret.)
With this, you need to clearly state who “no one” is and that they know she has Alzheimer's.


(The coffee maker and the trash can usually took such things in stride.)
Here, I would refer to the coffee make and the trash can by Fred and Roger so it is apparent we are in the old woman’s mind. It draws the reader in more.


At this point, it sounds like she is in a home or a hospital when you prior say “no one would fret.” It adds to the thought that people are with her.


(Well that was then, it is now.)
The end should read “this is now.”


(She smiled when she thought of the time after the Great War and the Great Depression.)
Here, I would specify more clearly the woman is smiling about the peace and return to prosperity AFTER the Great War and the Great Depression.


(It came to pass that after awhile,..)
“Awhile” should be “a while.”


(…he would drink that Tea like was water.)
An “it” is needed after “like.”


(Then the dark cloud loomed over them, at the age of sixteen she had to see your love go overseas.)
A semicolon or a period is needed where the comma is.


(Soon it was her, little Ralphy in her belly, and her Tea.)
Above, specify Ralphy is her unborn child and not her husband by immediately calling the child Ralphy Jr. Also you need to reword it to flow more coherently like this-“Soon, along with her tea in her belly, was little Ralphy Jr.”


(She raised Ralphy Jr,)
Put a period in place of the comma.


(…recalled Ralphy Jr graduating and leaving for college.)
Put a period after “Jr.”


(…beautiful gal, a red head with a smile that could melt the polar icecaps.)
Here, I believe a dash is needed after “gal.”


(…from the image of Emiy being too weak…)
Here you misspell Emily’s name.


(How long can one live in darkness she thought. Not too long she answered herself back in silence.)
Here, it is a good idea to put thought dialog in Italics.


(Oh, dear it is almost noon.)
Again, put a “Oh dear” in italics and put she though as a tag.


(Her guest are almost here.)
Above, it should read like this-“Her guests were almost here.”


(…some cups and place them on the table.)
“Place” should be “placed.”


(Little David in a car crash during his senior in college.)
This is not a complete sentence. We also need to know David died. Just put “died” after “David.”


(She was now alone. Only her Tea and memories.)
Here, join the two sentences and put “with” where the period is. The second one is a fragment.


(She poured the Tea into the cups. Five cups in total.)
Here again the second sentence is a fragment. Put a dash where the period is.


(Her guest walked in smiling,)
Here “guest” should be plural.


This story could be so nostalgic. There were so many grammar and spelling issues that it got in the way of enjoying it. I don’t think you proofread this. The mistakes were very simple, easily identified and able to be fixed. Just go over it again. I really think this could be very moving and captivating if it were spruced up some. Also it is a good idea to put spaces between dialog and paragraphs. All in all I see a story with great potential. happy WdC anniversary!






Anniversary Reviews email siggie
192
192
Review of Prolouge  
Review by brom21
In affiliation with Fantasy and Science Fiction So...  
Rated: E | (3.0)
The following are my own observations and opinions that are intended to improve your work. Take and leave what you will. Below, your words are in parenthesis mine are not.


This review is done to celebrate your WdC anniversary! Congratulations!


(The dinner dishes are patiently waiting for me in the yellow sink, they need washed, dried, and put away.)
With this, a semicolon is needed where the first comma is. Next, the part after where the semicolon is supposed to be should read-“;They need to be washed, dried and put away.”


(“Lisa, will you remind me to check on Kris tonight.)
A question mark is needed at the end.


(“What was that all about? I thought you were going to drive Kristen crazy with all those questions.” David my youngest brother looks at me with lines burrowed into his forehead.)
Above, I would put the tag after the dialog first.


(“She drew a picture of her Dads family and on the Grandpa she left out the nose.” I explain.)
Here, I don’t know what you’re saying. Also, “Dads” should be “Dad’s.”


(“You guys stop it! I don’t believe it, that would be to uncanny” I chastise.)
Here, I would choose another word than “uncanny.” It sounds awkaward.


(“You know what I heard once. I heard that the devil is as powerful as God!” David’s piercing blue eyes, stare into me.)
With this, a question mark should be where the first period is. Next, omit the comma.


(“No way, David it can’t be every time.” I say glancing down at my cards on the table, the four of hearts, four of clubs, and the four of diamonds, now seem magnified under the dim light.)
Here, the last part should be “…, and the four of diamonds [that now seemed] magnified under the dim light.” The needed words are in brackets.


(Lisa looks at me with her hazel eyes, dark skin, and long brown hair, and stretches, “I am getting tired of playing this funky old game.” Lisa yawns, and throws her cards in the middle of the table. Collecting all the cards from the table I return them to there case, not knowing that would be the last time I ever played rummy.)
with this paragraph, it sounds like her “dark skin and long brown hair are looking at Jenn. Instead , make it something like-“ Lisa looks at me with her hazel eyes accented by her dark skin, and long brown hair, and stretches,…) next “there” should be “their.”


(David now standing in the small paneled living room, hands in his tan kaki pants, with one of those, we have to talk, looks on his face. “You know what Jenn, I have woken up at 4:44 for the last three nights,” David stares intensely at me.)
With this, something should be done with “, hands in his tan kaki pants, with one of those, we have to talk, looks on his face. I think David’s supposed word should be in quotes like this-“…with one of those “we need to have a talk” looks on his face.” Also “kaki” should be “khaki.”


(My six-month-old orange and white kitten jumps up on the arm of the couch her green eyes bulging at me, her ears laying flat against her skull.)
Here, the word “with” is needed between “couch” and “her.” You could also use a punctuation mark too. It could be a semicolon, a dash or soothing else. I’m not sure. Lol. Lastly, the comma might not be correct.


(“David give me a minute I have to put her outside she is acting crazy. I think she will be okay. What is wrong with her she never acted this way?”)
Here, a comma should go between “minute” and “I” as well as between “outside” and “she.” Another one needed between “her” and “she” in the second sentence.


(Swirling around and around in the middle of the living room, was a white mist. I feel myself drifting away. A younger David is standing in the middle of the mist. His blonde hair is pure white. He is staring out of a small window. White thin curtains are blowing softly inward. Clear deep blue sky is all that is outside. Behind David moving slowly towards him, I see two lightning bolts of gold. Behind the golden bolts, are two white eyes? The wind is constantly blowing. The mist is evaporating. Lisa begins pulling frantically at my arm she is saying, “Jenn that’s it, that’s it!” I try to focus on her face but she seems so far away. Our eyes lock onto each other’s but only for a brief moment.)
Excellent reflective paragraph! Very nostalgic!


(I roll over and look at the clock it is 9:30 am.)
A semicolon is needed after “clock” and “it” should be in caps.


(“I’m up honey.” I say. The bedroom door burst open, and in runs, my special blue eyed girl with faint freckles covering her nose and cheeks. Placing her hands on her hips,)
Above, omit the first two commas and make the last comma a period.


(…I put it on hoping to stop the shaking inside of my.)
Here, I think you just meant to put “head” or “mind” at the end. No biggie.


(“Well no wonder he is crying” David giggles. Laying his head back in the brown recliner, feet raised, hands crossed over his stomach. Distinct dark circles under his eyes. Obviously, he did not get much sleep. More then likely he did not get any sleep.)
Above, combine the last two sentences to make it simpler like so-“Obviously, he got little or more likely no sleep at all.”


I think most if not all of the problems could be spotted by a one or two quick proofreads. Also, put spaces between dialog and paragraphs. The huge block of text is overwhelming to the eye. A little tweaking and this could be even more captivating. It has good potential. Happy WdC anniversary!






Anniversary Reviews email siggie
193
193
Review by brom21
In affiliation with Fantasy and Science Fiction So...  
Rated: E | (3.5)
The following are my own observations and opinions that are intended to improve your work. Take and leave what you will. Below, your words are in parenthesis mine are not.


This review is done to celebrate your WdC anniversary! Congratulations!


(I got up to find myself sleeping on the couch downstairs,…)
This sounds like the narrator is literally unaware how he got on the couch. Is this what you mean?


(I slowly and reluctantly dragged my feet up the stairs…)
This sounds a little repetitive and odd. Just alter it some to make it like-“I drudgingly dragged my feet up the stairs…” I think this more effectively combines the two adverbs to a simple single verb.


(I then closed the door and went into my daughter, Rebecca’s room. She was almost ten years older than her brother. Then I walked into my bedroom.)
Here, omit ‘then” and change the rest of the sentence to something like-“… and went into the room of Rebecca, my daughter.” Do you see how this way is smoother? Also notice how you use “I” and “then” too close together.


(I then got a call from my sister-in-law that my brother had gotten sick and wasn’t going to work.)
Above, you again use “I then” too close together. I would also quote what the sister-in-law said. Show don’t tell. Begin with “I then got a call from my sister in law.” Then put what she says and then say “She had said” as a tag.


(I walked into the underground house of odors, which was the subway station.)
This sound a little stilted. Reverse it to make something like-“I walked into the underground subway station which was a house of odors.”


(On the display screen it showed my balance and it let me go through. How we can control machines just by the swipe of a card amazed me.”
With this, the display can’t let you go through. Just say something like-“…and the computer let me through.”


(The subway station was the trash can for the commuters, if you litter there you’re not hurting the environment, although I never littered there.)
Here a semi-colon would best fit where the first comma is. I’d also change the proceeding clause to something like-“ Although I never littered there, doing so wasn’t really hurting the environment.”


(I saw an ant walk right past my foot, the gentle creature just doing it’s days work by carrying a small piece of lettuce from a turkey sandwich that someone had dropped. The ant was minding it’s own business…)
Here, you first you need a “was” between “creature” and “just.” Next “days work” should be “day’s” work. Then “it’s” should be “its.”


(. I was wondering why people invented rush hour, because it was really annoying.)
Here, no person “invented” rush hour. It is a by-product of being busy. I would put it something like-“I was wondering how people adversely caused rush hour, because it was really annoying.”


(…a slightly overweight Greek lady who had a polished red pursed softly coated with blue diamond-shaped sequins.)
Maybe it’s just me, but what does a Greek lady look like? Oh, “pursed’ should be “purse.”


(By the time we had reached Time Square there was actually room to stand on the train. I finally saw an empty seat, sat down, and fell right to sleep.)
At this point, you use “seat” and “sleep” too frequently.


(I slowly exited through the doors and then went a little quicker and got up the stairs.)
Here, keep it simple and put it something like-“I slowly exited through the doors then sprinted up the stairs.”


(I walked out the store with an apparently sad face.)
How is a sad face “apparent?” If she could feel her face making a sad face, then just say so.


(But today he had a different smile, he had one of his “special surprise” smiles.)
Once again, a semi-colon is needed after “smile.”


( It wasn’t really that much but it looked like a lot because I was a very messy worker, but I always got the job done.)
Here, “but” is used too close together.


(But, I knew that if I paniced, I wouldn’t be able to absorb the whole story of what was happening and my senses might be blocked out by fear.)
Here, things are said too casually. I would use at least one described emotion of how he is trying to suppress fear.


(That’s when a little bit of panic started to build inside of me. I was lying to myself when I said a little bit however; it was a lot of panic, enough panic to make a person crazy enough to lose his mind. I didn’t lose my mind though, but I didn’t keep calm either. I started out the office again and then started walking down the steps. Debris was falling from everywhere. In all the panic someone had pushed me down. Someone was in a big hurry to get out, and I should’ve been too. I started to get goosebumps on my arms and my neck. I could feel a gut-wrenching feeling inside my stomach that made me realize exactly how scared I was. I got back up and started at a slow run avoiding the falling debris, and also avoiding knocking anyone else over. I kept going and realized a little later that there was a big gash on my arm, I had gotten hurt but was too scared to think anything of it. I guess I was too scared to think at all.
(GREAT and believable description of emotions!! Very nice!


Honestly, the first half of the story was very, very rocky. There were spelling and grammar issues, awkwardness and boredom. But after the above paragraph, things really picked up and I was really enjoying myself. You have great climactic skills. I would use more of your emotional showing in the first half of this story. All in all, you did quite a decent job! Happy WdC anniversary!








Anniversary Reviews email siggie
194
194
Review of Another Day  
Review by brom21
In affiliation with Fantasy and Science Fiction So...  
Rated: E | (3.0)
The following are my own observations and opinions that are intended to improve your work. Take and leave what you will. Below, your words are in parenthesis mine are not.


This review is done to celebrate your WdC anniversary! Congratulations!


(He twisted around in the tight space to orient himself to the other occupant in the small cramped Communications center; Cosmonaut Ivanovich Kovski.)
Here, the semicolon needs to be a dash.


(“Make what out? Is the link in the crapper again?”)
Here, what exactly is the “link?”


(Jimmy deftly snatched it out of the air as it slowly floated toward him.)
Above, “deftly” sounds awkward. I would choose another.


(Jimmy raised an eyebrow at that.)
With, this just omit “at that.”


(If the echo was static then there was something interfering with the signal.)
This does not sound like third person narration. It sounds like it’s originating from a person’s head.


(He strapped in to the second seat and…)
“in to” should be “into.”


I think you did a good job of making a very brief story. I did not expect the ending. It was very happy. lol. All in all, a nice flash fiction piece. Happy WdC anniversary!







Anniversary Reviews email siggie
195
195
Review of The Lost Island  
Review by brom21
In affiliation with Fantasy and Science Fiction So...  
Rated: E | (3.0)
The following are my own observations and opinions that are intended to improve your work. Take and leave what you will. Below, your words are in parenthesis mine are not.

This review is done to celebrate your Writing.com anniversary. Congratulations!


(The rough waves were pounding the deck, the iron plated ships' hull groaned as it was relentlessly tossed around on the open sea.)
Here, either put a period or a semicolon where the comma is or change it to something like this-“The rough waves were pounding against the groaning iron plated hull of the ship as it was relentlessly tossed around on the open sea.”


(Nine hundred metres from stern to aft, ninety metres from port to starboard.)
This is a fragment. Simply put a dash before the first word of the sentence.


(Whistling he turned on the sonar to check for…)
a comma is needed after “Whstling.”


( Stepping into the sut he remembered all the times men and monsters…)
Here, “sut” should be “suit” and a comma comes after it.


(Stepping outside of the bay he grabbed his plutonium powered laser cannon, grinning under his helmet like a boy with a new toy he headed up to the prow of the ship to get first site of the new land if there was any to be seen at all.)
This sentence in too long and there are punctuation errors. I would split it up into something like this-“Stepping outside of the bay, he grabbed his plutonium powered laser cannon. He grinned under his helmet like a boy with a new toy. Then he headed up to the prow of the ship to get first site of the new land if there was any to be seen at all.”


(Meanwhile up in the laboratory, Elizabeth was packing all the medicine and napalm she could possibly carry in her pack.)
Why would Elizabeth be collecting explosives with medicine?”


(…she stooped over picked up her bag and put it on, on her way out she grabbed her purse.)
Above, recast the sentence to something like-“…she stooped over picked up her bag and put it on as she grabbed her purse on her way out.” Your sentence is a little cumbersome.


(For good luck.)
This is a fragment. Just make it something like this-“She did it or good luck.” Very simple right?


(…of the ship to pick up explosives she heard her father's panicked cry over the intercom…)
Here, a comma is needed after “explosives.”


(…forceful ripped apart and the almost sonic boom like sound of the ship's reactor cores…)
With this, a dash is needed to make “sonic boom-like.”


(Moments ago up on the bridge Tchovski was wrestling with…)
Comma after bridge here.


(…trying to keep her on course, when the ship's early…)
Omit the comma.


(…what the threat was, to his horror there were several unknown…)
Here put a semicolon where the comma is.


(…the ship's cannon, he managed to reach…)
Once more, change the comma to a semicolon.


(…as he saw three double explosions lighting up the rainy sky.)
Here, what do you mean by “double explosions?” Also when did it start raining?


(He breathed in the salty tang of the ocean through his nose and sighed.)
Good use of the sense of taste and smell and the sigh at the end.


(This was beauty he thought to himself, this was power.)
It is usually a good idea to put thoughts in italics. Turn this into-“This was beauty he thought to himself, this was power.”


(His eyes were drawn to several explosions he saw lighting up the atmosphere and roared battle had begun!)
Here, simply put a period after “explosions” and make “he” in caps.



The best suggestion I could give you is to build upon what you know. Use more sentences like this one which I pointed out-“He breathed in the salty tang of the ocean through his nose and sighed.” Try to make more use of the senses and feelings more often. All in all, a story full of action and suspense! Happy WdC anniversary!





Anniversary Reviews email siggie
196
196
Review of The lottery win  
Review by brom21
In affiliation with Fantasy and Science Fiction So...  
Rated: 13+ | (3.0)
The following are my own observations and opinions that are intended to improve your work. Take and leave what you will. Below, your words are in parenthesis mine are not.

This review is done to celebrate your Writing.com anniversary. Congratulations!


(…big, transparent pot filled with dozens of white paper sheets. )
I think you could change “dozens” to “hundreds” or “thousands” of pieces of paper. Such a big lottery would have more entries.


(He needed a moment to fully realize what he was holding in his hands.)
This is a good example of showing emotion instead of telling it. You could have-“He kept glancing back to the screen then to his ticket as he breathed heavily in a jittery sweat.”



Okay, I have two overall suggestions: add more descriptions of Karl’s emotions that reflect his emotions and put spaces between each dialog and between paragraphs. As the story is, the narration is a little dry. You did describe his emotions a little like his shaking while he was typing and when he shouted. Also I would add more to the ending. Furthermore, I think it would be good if you put in a twist. Maybe have him think he wins then have the computer crash at the end right when he is typing in the numbers. Mainly though, this needs some spicing up. Finally, have Karl think more. Perhaps have him fantasize what he plans to do with the money and have him think something brash against someone he doesn’t like. For instance he could say-“All those people who think I’m a failure will eat their hearts out! I’ll rub it in their faces!” This short story has potential to be a good gem of a work. I hope you go back and make this piece gleam. Happy WdC anniversary!





Anniversary Reviews email siggie
197
197
Review by brom21
In affiliation with Fantasy and Science Fiction So...  
Rated: 13+ | (5.0)
The following are my own observations and opinions that are intended to improve your work. Take and leave what you will. Below, your words are in parenthesis mine are not.

This review is done to celebrate your Writing.com anniversary. Congratulations!


(Not all stories have happy endings, just some, mine didn’t. As all stories start there was a main character,…)
Here, the first sentence is garbled. Instead of using the commas, just leave them out and put something like-“Some stories have happy endings but mine didn’t.” Also change “was” to “is.”


(But what was different was the person who was born, me.)
Above, In between “bro” and “me” there should be a dash to set off the pause.


(My parents christened me Elizabeth Margaret Sarah Smith good strong name as…)
Like above, this sentence part needs a tad of recasting. It should read-“My parents christened me Elizabeth Margaret Sarah Smith - a good, strong name as…” Notice the dash and the letter “a” after it.


(I grew up in the rural regions of Vermont with a barn out back and a swayed back out mare which I…)
Here, you use the words “out back” too close together even though the order is switched.


(I shall dwell little on the memories of my early childhood for they are somewhat superficial to my memoirs though we could spend long hours in happy remembrance of my earlier days, that is not why I am writing this.)
This sentence is too long. Maybe something like-“I shall dwell little on the memories of my early childhood for they are somewhat superficial to my memoirs. But I am not writing this to reminisce of my happy earlier days.”


(…started taking me to psychiatrist whose…)
“Psychiatrist” should be pleural.


(My friends one by one left me as I delved deeper into the…)
Here, it would flow better if you swapped words to read-“ My friends left me one by one as I delved deeper into the…”


(complexities of neuro surgery; the intricacies of the brain, and the what it needs to survive; robotics; computer programming; and the quest for a useable power source.)
Here the first semicolon should be a colon. The part after the comma should read-“… and what it needs to survive like robotics: computer programming and the quest for a useable power source.”


(Besides once I had gained eternal life, didn’t I have all the time in the world to learn what I wanted to know?)
Above, a comma need to be after “Besides.” Next change “didn’t to “Shouldn’t.”


(and number two I was a young eighteen.)
Comma after “two.”


(…old woman who many in the circles I would have to travel in wouldn’t hesitate doing things to me I would regret.)
Here, I would recast the sentence and restate what you mean. It’s a bit garbled.


(…technology of immortality, it seemed fitting at the time.)
Above, the comma should be a semicolon.


(I had got through the arduous part...)
“Got” should be “gotten.”


(…the subject not to panic, for it the subject did the operation would be jeopardized.)
Here, “it” should be “if.” Also, a comma is needed after “did.”


(For the chemical imbalance in the brain would cause the sensitive machines I used to read the chemical balance within the brain would misread the balance.)
This sentence is a fragment. Instead, begin the sentence like this-“It was for this reason the chemical imbalance…”


(They often go mad at this point, tearing themselves apart, or at least trying to, for in the later subjects I have inserted controls…)
Great sentence. It is very grizzly and vivid. It also shows how heartless the woman is.


(…this is the time when they shout at the ceiling, “Why me? God, Why me?”)
It may be inappropriate, but this line made me laugh out loud! The woman’s apathy to this response is sadistically funny I might say. Kudos for inserting this humorous one liner!


(…when I showed them they went mad.)
Comma needed after “them.”


This was excellent! The woman was very emotionless in her search for immortality. She did not care by what means she would achieve her goal. Likewise, she was immoral dealing with a shady person. The entertain factor was not diminished by any mistakes or shortcomings. I thoroughly enjoyed this. Thanks for taking me into the mind of a heartless but brilliant woman. Happy WdC anniversary!






Anniversary Reviews email siggie
198
198
Review by brom21
In affiliation with Fantasy and Science Fiction So...  
Rated: 13+ | (3.5)
The following are my own observations and opinions that are intended to improve your work. Take and leave what you will. Below, your words are in parenthesis mine are not.

This is done to commemorate your Writing.Com anniversary! Congratulations!


(Then he screamed at himself that it is not his nerves that something watched him last night.)
Here, I would just let Talanka actually say what he says to himself then put an exclamation point at the end. Also you might put a tag about how he says it like “he said as his words echoed in the air that filled his head with a searing ring.”


(As the sun cracked the horizon he talked himself into…)
Put a comma after “horizon.”


(…looking for any hint of what stood there.)
Above, it seems something is standing there in the immediate present. Instead put “had stood there.”


(There was something odd about the tree. It was oddly shaped and really did not resemble any tree he had ever seen except its pointed top.)
With this, you use the form of “odd” too closely together. You also kind of state the same thing in both sentences. You could do some chopping and put something like-“The tree was oddly shaped with its pointed top.” See, simple and easy.


(With no breeze rustling through the forest the top of the tree tilted sideways.)
Here, you need to restate things to better say what you mean. You could have-“The top of the tree tilted sideways on its own without any wind moving it.” Remember, say what you want in the least amount words and a simply as you can.


(It was a deep roar that was bestial and human at the same time.)
Above, describe the roar. Maybe something like-“The roar was deep and guttural like an animal’s but it had the desperate, doleful, mourn like a sad human.”


(The tall grass whispered to him as he ran through it.)
Here, just describe the sound the grass made. If I understand you, you could have-“The grass made a wisp sound that was like a small cry.” I did use a simile but I think that could still work.


(He ran with the grace of a gazelle, bobbing up and down as he ran. He went up and down,…)
Here, you use “up and down” too close together. You’re restating it.


(They herded him all day that way. By night fall he heard the sounds of rushing water.)
Here, there is a gap in time where something should have happened. You go from one occurrence to another without explanation.


(Feeling no eyes on him he set to making snares to catch a rabbit for he had not eaten in days.)
Above, you can do some chopping/condensing. Maybe-“He had starved for many days. Certain he was not being watched, he began setting rabbit snares.” Again, simple and easy.


(Making a bed out of pine branches he laid and slept soundly through the night, exhausted.)
Put a comma after “branches.”


(Madness gripped Talanka; he pulled his flint dagger from his belt and rushed at the beast.)
Describe how Talanka’s madness affects him. Maybe something like-“He screamed wildly as his heart raced with curses spewing from his mouth, picturing himself leaping upon the beast.”


(Preferring death over being hunted anymore, he attacked the giant, stabbing it over and over.)
This sentence is a little weird but I do get what you’re saying. Recast it to something like-“ Talanka was tired and full of an aching yearn to be free from being hunted for what seemed like forever. He carelessly dashed at the giant then began hacking repeatedly at it.”


(The sight of red blood drove him on, knowing that if it bled it could die. It did not struggle; rather it moaned and cried in pain.)
This is a little scant. Male it something like-“ Talanka saw blood pour from the beast, and he kept attacking, hoping to bleed it dry. It was being overpowered as it could only cry in pain.”


(He awoke back in his own village and listened to the tale about his return.)
Here, there is a gap in between him being returned to his village and listening to how he got returned. I would state how he recuperates and is dumbfounded why is back home – then say how he learned of how he was returned.







Anniversary Reviews email siggie
199
199
Review by brom21
In affiliation with Fantasy and Science Fiction So...  
Rated: E | (3.0)
The following are my own observations and opinions that are intended to improve your work. Take and leave what you will. Below, your words are in parenthesis mine are not.

This is done to commemorate your Writing.Com anniversary! Congratulations!


I skimmed over this some and I want to start and say that you could omit a lot of words. I’ll point out as many as I can.


(…,Chris yelled, exasperated by what he was seeing in front of him.)
Here just put “…,Chris yelled, exasperated by what was before him.”


(…his dad yells to him while worrying for his daughter's health.)
With this, you could have-“…his dad yells, worrying for his daughter.” Here, it is understood the dad is yelling at Chris and that the dad is concerned for her Health.


(The ride to the hospital was full of intense emotions that spread throughout the entire vehicle.)
Here, you could put-“The ride to the hospital was full of intense emotions that filled the vehicle.”


(Chris muttered to himself on the way there.)
Here, it is understood that they are going to the hospital. Just put-“Chris muttered to himself.”


(Assisted by nurses who came out with him, he helped his daughter into the wheelchair.)
Above, it could be-“The nurses came out with him and helped his daughter into the wheelchair.”


(Chris exits the car and begins to assist them as well.)
Here you could have- “Chris exits the car and starts assisting them.”


(“No!”, Chris yelled, crying for relief. )
Here, you can omit the comma. I would change the words after the comma to-“…crying, aching for relief” or maybe “Chris yelled, crying as he wished for the cause for his tears to disappear.” This is of course longer, but I think it more accurately says what you meant by “crying for relief.”


(he cried out, grasping ahold of her hand.)
Make this-“grasping her hand.”


Chopping words can be helpful. You always want to say what you want to say in as less words as possible. The only general I think exception would be giving description where making things short robs the reader of picturing what is written. My final suggestion is break your story up into paragraphs and put spaces between them. The same thing goes with dialog. This was a nice read. Happy WdC anniversary!






Anniversary Reviews email siggie
200
200
Review of A Stony Heart  
Review by brom21
In affiliation with Fantasy and Science Fiction So...  
Rated: E | (4.5)
The following are my own observations and opinions that are intended to improve your work. Take and leave what you will. Below, your words are in parenthesis mine are not.

This is done to commemorate your Writing.Com anniversary! Congratulations!


(His legs were not made for leaping or his arms not made for holding.)
Here, things contradict themselves with the second use of “not.” Just omit it.


(There was silence around, eerie and eldritch, broken only by the very faintest of tinkling.)
Above, a dash is needed after “around” rather than a comma.


(He did not know how, he did not care how.)
A semicolon should be where the comma is.


This was excellent! The way you “played around” with the gargoyles emotions and thoughts left me at a loss for words. My heart went out to the gargoyle. I loved the beautiful but melancholy atmosphere of this whole piece. You also made a lot happen in the amount of words you used. Likewise, you generated a lot of emotion with the length. The only suggestion I have is a personal one. I would like to see some backstory of the gargoyle. Maybe tell how he was created and why he is alive. Your whole story was virtually without any disruptive errors. All in all, splendid work! Happy WdC anniversary!





Anniversary Reviews email siggie
859 Reviews · *Magnify*
Page of 35 · 25 per page   < >
Printed from https://shop.writing.com/main/profile/reviews/ion_7/sort_by/r.review_creation_time DESC/page/8