*Magnify*
SPONSORED LINKS
BY ONLINE AUTHORS
Printed from https://shop.writing.com/main/profile/reviews/shadowsnflames/sort_by/r.review_creation_time DESC/page/11
Review Requests: OFF
968 Public Reviews Given
968 Total Reviews Given
Public Reviews
Previous ... 7 8 9 10 -11- 12 13 14 15 16 ... Next
251
251
Review by Siobhan Falen
In affiliation with WdC SuperPower Reviewers Group  
Rated: E | (4.0)
Well, hello there: I found your story on the sidebar and thought I'd give it a peek.

What I love about your work: You've got to love children. I found the interaction between Nana and her grandbabies to be cute and absolutely a loving relationship.

Why I could relate to your work: As a mom of three young girls, I've often encountered the "I didn't do it" scenario myself. Drives me crazy. So, I can definitely relate.

My suggestions: I wouldn't mind seeing a little more interaction between everyone, for this story only allows us a very small view of the characters. Otherwise, I don't really have anything to add.

Any noticeable typos: I did not see anything that grabbed my attention from your words.

My favorite line(s): "I thought nothing of it but my husband, George, made a comment that the girls were throwing the Styrofoam from the torn water absorbers that he used to prevent rain from coming into the covered patio." Again, I can relate, just felt this made you both realistic and relateable.

In conclusion: This was a cute story about a lesson needing to be taught and I think you did well capturing the moment.


** Images For Use By Upgraded+ Only **


*Gold* My review has been submitted for consideration in "Good Deeds Get CASH!" .
252
252
Review by Siobhan Falen
In affiliation with WdC SuperPower Reviewers Group  
Rated: E | (4.5)
Well, hello there: I saw a review of your work on the public reviews page and was drawn in by the title. It promised to be good and it did not fail.

What I love about your work: This was a perfect, eerie piece that really did very well at setting the tone. Admittedly, the picture helped too, but your words were well done. It felt bleak, ominous, and somehow, hungry.

Why I could relate to your work: I love horror, that's one of my favorite genres. So, I absolutely love when I find a piece that leaves me wishing there were more to read, or a followup story or something, so nicely done.

My suggestions: My only complaint, which is mild to say the least, is that I couldn't establish a rhythm as I read this. I'm one of those poetry readers who, while I don't like rhyming poetry much, like to have a rhythm to read with. Just a personal preference.

Any noticeable typos: I didn't see anything that took my attention from the words.

My favorite line(s): "I will never let them go.
I will never be abandoned.
I will live forever." Some places are just bad, bad... baaaaaad.

In conclusion: I really liked the mood you created with this, it just came across as perfectly dark. An invitation into the frightening hallways of a damned place. Well done, glad I took a peek.


** Images For Use By Upgraded+ Only **


*Gold* My review has been submitted for consideration in "Good Deeds Get CASH!" .
253
253
Review by Siobhan Falen
In affiliation with WdC SuperPower Reviewers Group  
Rated: 13+ | (5.0)
Well, hello there: I found you on the random review and really thought you handled the subject matter beautifully.

What I love about your work: You've taken an awkward situation and penned it in such a way I don't feel uncomfortable reading it, as if I should avert my eyes from something dirty. Often times, when I've seen other writers approach similar subjects, I've found myself laughing or shaking my head, not sympathizing, but you wrote this well.

Why I could relate to your work: While I am the opposite gender of the protagonist of your poem, I certainly feel his pain. Sometimes, sleep just has to take the priority, old age or not.

My suggestions: I do not have any. I feel this flowed well, you caught the emotions well without making the audience uncomfortable, the wording was just right. Nothing to add.

Noticeable typos: I did not see anything that pulled me from the poem.

My favorite line(s): "but such thoughts are all rather quickly killed
by old age’s truth. Turning over, he sighs." Poor guy, what a way to end the night.

In conclusion: I enjoyed this quite a bit and found myself aching for the poor guy. It was well done and somehow sweet, even if it ended in frustration.


** Images For Use By Upgraded+ Only **


*Gold* My review has been submitted for consideration in "Good Deeds Get CASH!" .
254
254
Review of The Scream  
Review by Siobhan Falen
In affiliation with WdC SuperPower Reviewers Group  
Rated: 13+ | (4.5)
Happy Anniversary this month!!!

What I love about your work: I loved the descriptions of her audience, all hanging on to her words and reacting to the eerie tale. I could totally picture it in my mind.

Why I could relate to your work: Every time I've been pregnant, I have had the most vivid, horrific dreams that shook me to my core. I would have a hard time discerning reality and dream when I would wake up cause they felt so real. So, I can completely understand the husband thinking she was just having a bad dream.

My suggestions: When you write small digits, smaller than a hundred, it is better to write them out. Such as "7 months" would read better "seven months". It's a mild distraction from the story when you run into those numbers.

Any noticeable typos: I didn't see anything that leaped out at me.

My favorite line(s): "Beside me stood a gangly, skeleton of a woman, cigarette hanging from her bright red lips." I just love the image, I can see her in my mind. And she probably has badly dyed hair to go along with it :P.

In conclusion: This was a fun read, I think perfect for your campfire addition. Nicely done and happy anniversary.


** Images For Use By Upgraded+ Only **


*Gold* My review has been submitted for consideration in "Good Deeds Get CASH!" .
255
255
Review of No Takers  
Review by Siobhan Falen
In affiliation with WdC SuperPower Reviewers Group  
Rated: ASR | (4.0)
Well, hello there: I'm swinging by from WDC Power Reviewers and thought I'd give you a review on this piece.

What I love about your work: I like the development of your characters. Both girls have the potential to come out really strong and grow our attachment.

Why I could relate to your work: I had friends who tried setting me up thing and it never worked, I had to find my happiness and what worked for me. But, boy, when your friends are determined, there's no saying no.

My suggestions: I felt the opening was really strong but the ending, not so much. It feels like you built up these characters and then plunged us into an accident with no explanation as to why, showed us that Madonna wants to die with no explanation as to why, and brought her back but left us hanging. There was not a clear goal or conclusion, it just felt a bit incomplete. I think if you wrapped it up a little more, gave us some idea of what the point of her second chance is, it would read better.

Any noticeable typos: I didn't see anything that pulled me away from your words.

I take that back, as I was scanning for my favorite lines, I found this error "She stopped in the bathroom for her bedtime routine, before ending in the bedroom where she completed her nighttime routine of punching pillows, tossing and turning, and then getting up for a second tour to make sure that all the doors were lock and all the appliances were turned off." "to make sure that all the doors were lock" should be "locked".

My favorite line(s): "With an exasperated sigh, Madonna returned to the bedroom and opened the closet to see what would do for one of Trisha’s parties." And game, set, match; nothing like your friends to steal sleep.

In conclusion: I really feel this has a lot of potential as you start out so strong with the character building. I just think you need to give a little reason on why things occurred and give us a point to her return. Anyway, it was a very enjoyable read and I wish you the best of luck in the contest you have entered.


** Images For Use By Upgraded+ Only **


*Gold* My review has been submitted for consideration in "Good Deeds Get CASH!" .
256
256
Review of Memoir of a Cat  
Review by Siobhan Falen
In affiliation with WdC SuperPower Reviewers Group  
Rated: E | (4.0)
Well, hello there: I saw a review of this on the public review and thought I'd take a peek, what a cute story.

What I love about your work: I love the questioning our way of life, it cracked me up. I loved the description of everything and it just was a cute story, albeit a little sad in the beginning.

Why I could relate to your work: My first cat and the love of my animal life was a kitten my father found in our driveway at only a few weeks old. We had her for nine years and she was awesome, so this made me think of her. Wonder if she saw the world similarly.

My suggestions: I think you may want to try to eliminate some of the passive voice to make this stronger. I think it would really pop if you did that.

Any noticeable typos: I did not see anything that leaped out at me.

My favorite line(s): "Why am I forbidden to enter Closet? Is Vacuum afraid of me?" I just picture this cat twining around his owner's ankles, trying to see into the closet and get a peep of the mysteriousness of it. Cutely done.

In conclusion: This was a cute read, a lot of fun. Glad I took a peek.


** Images For Use By Upgraded+ Only **


*Gold* My review has been submitted for consideration in "Good Deeds Get CASH!" .
257
257
Review of Hanukkah  
Review by Siobhan Falen
In affiliation with WdC SuperPower Reviewers Group  
Rated: ASR | (4.5)
Well, hello there: I found you on the random review and I'll be honest, I immediately was going "ahhhh, how cute" just from your intro. Darn impressive work for a nine year old.

What I love about your work: Not too shabby, the rhymes work and it definitely shows an enthusiasm for Hanukkah. The words flowed well and it was just cute.

Why I could relate to your work: My mom's best friend was Jewish when I was little so I remember going over there and partaking in their traditions. I loved the lighting of the menorah, always thought it was so pretty. And she did the prayer in "Yiddish" (can't remember how it's spelled) and I just thought it was the most lovely thing I'd ever heard. Anyways, this adorable poem called that to mind and made me have warm, fuzzy childhood memories.

My suggestions: I do not have any. It flowed nicely and made me laugh a couple of times, well done.

Any noticeable typos: Didn't see anything that jumped out at me.

My favorite line(s): "Many kids think it's all about,
The eight days worth of presents!
But I assure you that's not how it is,
For all those poor old peasants!" That just made me crack up. I love the "poor old pheasants". Very cute.

In conclusion: Being the mom of a nine year old, I'm pretty impressed. This came together very nicely and was certainly worth reading. Well done and best of luck to your son in his future writing career.


** Images For Use By Upgraded+ Only **


*Gold* My review has been submitted for consideration in "Good Deeds Get CASH!" .
258
258
Review of Finger Food  
Review by Siobhan Falen
In affiliation with WdC SuperPower Reviewers Group  
Rated: E | (4.5)
Well, hello there: Swinging by from the WDC Power Reviewers, and lol, eeeew.

What I love about your work: His logic is sound, it makes sense in a horrible way, but oh, eeeew and eeeew again. This made me laugh in a twisted kind of way and thank the lucky stars I'm not smelling barbecue right now.

Why I could relate to your work: I've grown up on horror stories so I always enjoy something that makes my stomach flip flop a little. And something that leaves a man who isn't a monster out to hunt some more :D.

My suggestions: I did not have any. This flowed nicely, had a good rhythm, was gruesome without being so, well done.

My favorite line(s): "Oh my, oh me, what's that up the road?
It's not a rabbit for it's too big.
It's not a deer for it's too small.
What could it possibly be?
Finger food anyone!" Delighted chuckle, oh dear, and the hunt is on.

In conclusion: This was wickedly twisted, hilariously gross and just a fun read.


** Images For Use By Upgraded+ Only **


*Gold* My review has been submitted for consideration in "Good Deeds Get CASH!" .
259
259
Review of Asylum  
Review by Siobhan Falen
In affiliation with WdC SuperPower Reviewers Group  
Rated: 13+ | (4.0)
Well, hello there: I'm visiting you from the WDC power Reviewers and thought I'd give this story a peek.

What I love about your work: This was certainly a horrific, adrenaline packed journey that left me wondering at the end, was it real or in her head? That's kind of the fun of an asylum piece is that unless there is another witness, you can never tell what's real or what's fantasy.

Why I could relate to your work: I love stories that leave you questioning reality at the end, and aren't tied up with a pretty bow. So, this was right up my alley.

My suggestions: There were a few spots where you had a bunch of fragmented sentences in a row. This just made me stumble as the reader and trip up a bit. If you could blend them together or reword them a bit, smooth them out, I'd have no complaints.

Any noticeable typos: There were a couple minor things, but I wanted to reach the climax of the story too much to really take note of what they were. I wanted to see her escape or see if the beasties were real, so I had to follow it through :D.

My favorite line(s): "But her pursuers were too late; she had finally reached the sanctuary of the river that awaited her. " Here I am, thinking she's going to go for a swim, escape their ability to smell her, get carried away; so I'm going heck yes, she's escaping. Little do I know how you're going to dash those hopes into a million pieces, smoothly done.

In conclusion: This was quite a read that left me thinking and questioning at the end, always a grand way to end a story. It was very interesting and I liked the details you put in there, really helped bring the tale to life. Well done.


** Images For Use By Upgraded+ Only **


*Gold* My review has been submitted for consideration in "Good Deeds Get CASH!" .
260
260
Review of A Humbling Start  
Review by Siobhan Falen
In affiliation with WdC SuperPower Reviewers Group  
Rated: E | (4.0)
Welcome to WDC!!!

What I love about your work: You certainly opened up my eyes to something I've never thought about. When you hear about HIV, adults come to mind not children who have been inflicted, but damn, my heart aches for the little ones. What a horrible prognosis, by no fault of their own, to have to learn to live with.

Why I could relate to your work: As a mom with three small children, my heart just bleeds for these kids. Bad enough to be orphans, but orphans with such an illness to shoulder... again, damn.

My suggestions: I would recommend writing out the ages. Typically, when writing formally, whether an essay or a story or even a letter, you want to write out any number less than a hundred. It looks better, reads better, and does not detract from your words.

Any noticeable typos: I did notice a few that might be caught if you read the piece out loud, but your message came through loud and clear.

My favorite line(s): "And this young man knows this; I do not detect the slightest anger or hatred in him." Wow, I don't know that I could not harbor anger or hatred over such a diagnosis. I've been in chronic pain for the last two years thanks to being an experiment for birth control and recently had to have a hysterectomy before I turned thirty, and I am furious over it. But I still have a full life ahead of me and no fear that it will eventually bring about my death, so wow, kudos to Z.

In conclusion: This was a touching essay that really showed us a darker side of life that too often gets brushed under the rug. I think with a little bit of polishing, this would be an incredible read, but even as it is, it still speaks to me. Nicely done. And of course, welcome to the WDC.


** Images For Use By Upgraded+ Only **


*Gold* My review has been submitted for consideration in "Good Deeds Get CASH!" .
261
261
Review of Ten  
Review by Siobhan Falen
In affiliation with WdC SuperPower Reviewers Group  
Rated: E | (3.5)
Welcome to WDC!!!

What I love about your work: Your character feels so alone and lost from the beginning, just kind of drifting along without a clue how to see shore. The story definitely felt sad and broken.

Why I could relate to your work: I remember in third grade or about that age, my two best friends jumped me at the water fountain and started beating me up. I fought back and was holding my own, and eventually we made up, but to this day, I still have no idea why they did it. So, I understand being a target like Evie.

My suggestions: There were a few sentences that felt choked up. For example: "I was so shocked and so stunned, at this point you could literally have knocked me down with a feather." "at this point" would be better left out and shocked and stunned feel redundant, it would read easier with only one of those in there. You don't want to use synonyms to describe feelings in the same sentence.

Also, you start out the story focusing on the bombshell dropped in class but never expand upon it. It feels like the point of the story is around that bombshell, but we're left hanging. I would suggest taking some of the focus off that situation or at least revealing what the discussion was about.

The end of this story doesn't feel right with what you've started us out. Evie, first off, talks about herself as Evie but it seems to me that if she'd bounced around in ten homes with ten different names, she would not be referring to herself as Evie. At least not in self reflection mode. And you have her talk about family life, being the middle child, and make it seem as if she's been a part of her friends' life for a long time, but at the end, you drop us into the idea that she's not had a stable life at all, especially not family life. It honestly feels as if you started out the story with the intent of taking her in one direction, but at the end, suddenly decided to take it another. Make sure you stay consistent with the character's life throughout the whole story.

Any noticeable typos: There were a few but what I listed above distracted me more than the typos. But, something I've learned, to help me catch some of my awkward sentences and errors, is to read my story out loud. It might help you out, too.

My favorite line(s): "Giggle, giggle, giggle. Whisper, whisper, whisper. Secret after secret after secret." When you feel like an outsider, this captures everything perfectly.

In conclusion: I think your concept has a lot of potential, but it needs some polishing to really make it shine. Remember, when you're writing a story, especially a short story, you need to make sure to tie up the loose ends and stay consistent with your character's details. I wish you the best of luck in the contest and welcome to the WDC.


** Images For Use By Upgraded+ Only **


*Gold* My review has been submitted for consideration in "Good Deeds Get CASH!" .
262
262
Review of The River  
Review by Siobhan Falen
In affiliation with WdC SuperPower Reviewers Group  
Rated: 13+ | (4.5)
Well, hello there: I found your story in the horror newsletter and thought I'd give it a peek, so very glad I did it.

What I love about your work: In such a short story with so little interaction between the two main characters, you managed to show a loving relationship and make me care about both of them. I love the creepy feel to this, it really worked out well.

Why I could relate to your work: Having grown up on Greek myths (family is quite a bit Greek), I loved this rendition and knew instantly what was going on, though it still broke my heart and I was eager to find out what was going to happen next. And that's one of the things I liked, is that I knew she wasn't going to make it, but yet I still needed to reach the end of your story to see how it played out.

My suggestions: I don't really have any. It's hard to build up so much in so few words, but again, you made me care about both characters. Well done.

Any noticeable typos: I did not see anything that yanked me out of the story.

My favorite line(s): "She unbuckled her safety belt and reclined the seat, stretching out.

"I won't go to sleep... I'm just going to rest my eyes for a minute."" I read the first line and shook my head, thinking how very unsafe for some mild comfort. The second line is one I've used against my husband in long drives :D.

In conclusion: I very much enjoyed this river tale. Well done.


** Images For Use By Upgraded+ Only **


*Gold* My review has been submitted for consideration in "Good Deeds Get CASH!" .
263
263
Review by Siobhan Falen
In affiliation with WdC SuperPower Reviewers Group  
Rated: 13+ | (4.0)
Well, hello there: I found your story in the horror newsletter and thought I'd check it out.

What I love about your work: I liked the idea of the seven parties and each one progressing to the final dark ones. It was fun.

Why I could relate to your work: I love horror movies and admittedly have daydreamed of being one of the heroines to make it out of one. So this was something I enjoyed.

My suggestions: “Let me understand this ... You're telling me, if I attend these parties, I’ll earn one million dollars?” I asked, taken aback. “What’s the catch?” This line is just fine, if the man had mentioned a million dollars but that fact is neglected from their conversation and it feels like she pulled it out of the air. I would suggest having him mention it.

I also feel like the end was too wrapped up and pretty, all things considered. After all, she just possibly killed someone through voodoo, did kill Dracula, almost died, and though you have her saying she'll have nightmares, her emotions feel very nonchalant.

I also feel that your story would resonate a bit better if you gave us some more descriptions. For instance, we have no idea what the contest arranger looks like yet she stares at him in her lit house. We get to know what some of the other characters look like, but we never find out anything really about her appearance or his.

Plus, this left so many questions unanswered. What was the point of the parties? Entertainment? Why did the others seem normal? Were they demons? Something less? Something more? I think this has a lot of potential but it could do with some more explanations of the events.

Any noticeable typos: "Tugging on it, I looked back and saw that the dark angel was walking towards me." Dark Angel has been used as a title the entire time so having it not capitalized here feels wrong.

"Vampires and Dark Knights weren't supposed to be real, but I know now they are." I could be wrong, but I think you might have meant Dark Angel not Knight.

"I counted out one hundred dollar bills." One hundred dollar bills is only a hundred dollars. I'm pretty sure a million dollars would not simply fit in an envelope but at only a hundred dollar bills, I would think she'd be angry she got jipped. She held up to her end of the deal like a champ.

My favorite line(s): "“I think my friends and I fell a little bit in love with you.” He turned and walked away." Lol, and what does one say to that? An interesting ending to her dealings with her mysterious benefactor.

In conclusion: Like I said, I think this has a lot of potential. The idea of the parties having a dark side totally holds appeal to me. I think with a little bit of polishing and further development, this could really be quite a gem. A fun read.


** Images For Use By Upgraded+ Only **


*Gold* My review has been submitted for consideration in "Good Deeds Get CASH!" .
264
264
Review by Siobhan Falen
In affiliation with WdC SuperPower Reviewers Group  
Rated: E | (4.0)
Well, hello there: I found you on the random review and found this to be quite an intriguing read.

What I love about your work: I felt like I'd read this before, only in the sense that brainwashing us into perfect little drones does seem to be the intended purpose of many of our schools. Individuality is not encouraged and certainly, not ever, questioning the books' version of things.

Why I could relate to your work: With three daughters of my own who all come with their quirks and interesting little ideas, I've gotten to firsthand witness how our education system is not quite doing what it should. And as any parent can attest, the mystery on how to fix something that feels so broken is not an easy one to solve.

My suggestions: I would simply suggest reading through your work out loud to hopefully catch any errors that might have snuck in. It's one of the best pieces of advice I've encountered, though I hardly ever use it myself and it shows :P. There were a couple of typos, listed below that might now have made it into the final cut otherwise.

Any noticeable typos: "We have access to modern technology don’t we?" Should be a comma between technology and don't.

"The trouble was that no matter how many issues we spotted no solutions came to me. " I'm pretty sure there should be at least one comma in that sentence.

My favorite line(s): "And then it hit me, brainwash the prisoners too! Then they too will be good and productive citizens lazing about and relying on others’ ideas." You've got some productive ideas here.

In conclusion: This was an interesting read, glad I found it.


** Images For Use By Upgraded+ Only **


*Gold* My review has been submitted for consideration in "Good Deeds Get CASH!" .
265
265
Review of Black Coffee  
Review by Siobhan Falen
In affiliation with WdC SuperPower Reviewers Group  
Rated: 13+ | (5.0)
Happy Anniversary this month!!!

What I love about your work: I may be biased, coming from a military family, including being married to a former Marine, but I really liked how this reached out to the idea that you just never know who your words may be a slap in the face to. You may not agree with the war going on, but you need to remember the troops fighting it are still very much in need of respect and understanding.

Why I could relate to your work: Thankfully, my husband never went overseas but his high school friend has been multiple times, my first kiss has been over multiple times, one of my boyfriends, etc., so to say I know many people who need to have us at their back is just an understatement. They don't deserve the blatant disrespect that so many people feel is acceptable to just throw in their faces and it ticks me off. Anyway, off my tangent, I certainly felt for Vince.

My suggestions: I did not have any as I felt your words did great to bring to life this moment in time and show us a bit about all involved. Nicely done.

Any noticeable typos: I did not see anything that grabbed my attention away from your story.

My favorite line(s): "Vince noticed that her clothes were designer label and probably cost at least as much as his whole month's groceries." It's always fun to judge someone's priorities from a distance when we can't keep our own straight :P.

In conclusion: I enjoyed this. I enjoyed the mood and the character buildup. This was well written and drew our attention to the unintended suffering our words can cause someone. Nicely done and happy anniversary.



** Images For Use By Upgraded+ Only **


*Gold* My review has been submitted for consideration in "Good Deeds Get CASH!" .
266
266
Review by Siobhan Falen
In affiliation with WdC SuperPower Reviewers Group  
Rated: 18+ | (4.0)
Well, hello there: I saw a review of your poem on the public review page and the title grabbed me.

What I love about your work: Lol... wow, sounds like quite a mostly true experience. That would certainly be awkward and humiliating and frustrating. Certainly had me cracking up... I'm laughing with you, with you I swear.

Why I could relate to your work: I've never used craigslist to date as I found it through my husband, but being a seller and buyer on there, I can attest to the interesting folks you meet. Sometimes, so interesting you pray you never meet them in a dark alley, unarmed :P. So, I could certainly relate to the surprise discovery that the other craigslister was not quite what they presented themselves to be.

My suggestions: I know we got an apology for the meter, but the first couple stanzas really tripped me up. I had a hard time getting into a rhythm reading it, though of course, once I found my footing, it flowed well, but those first two were a bit difficult to find my rhythm on. I know, not necessarily a suggestion, more of an observation that would help if you could tweak it a bit.

Noticeable typos: Asides from that first section, there was nothing that jerked my attention away from the poem.

My favorite line(s): "I'm sure if I looked I would have seen I was blushing
but my cheeks weren't the only place my blood was rushing." Cracking up, yeah, I'm sure it wasn't. Poor feller, I'm sure she really liked you but she had a price to ask.

In conclusion: This was absolutely hilarious. I loved the story you wove and although I was laughing, I did feel bad for you too. It's not fair to mislead those seeking a romance, not just a fling... unless you were just seeking a fling than you basically got what you were looking for, just had to pay for it :P. Anyways, I enjoyed how you played a truthful lesson into this and shared a mostly true moment of your life. Nicely done.


** Images For Use By Upgraded+ Only **


*Gold* My review has been submitted for consideration in "Good Deeds Get CASH!" .
267
267
Review by Siobhan Falen
In affiliation with WdC SuperPower Reviewers Group  
Rated: 18+ | (5.0)
Happy Anniversary this month!!!

What I love about your work: I like that this contest helps us to embrace the LGBT community and explore that side of ourselves without making the focus all about romance. After checking this out, it's something that certainly attracts my attention and makes me want to write an entry.

Why I could relate to your work: As a bisexual woman who came out to my family over ten years ago, I still find it difficult to put into writing that side of me. For some reason, it always frightens me like I'm doing something forbidden, so I really like the idea of a contest that will test my boundaries and dare me to step outside of my comfort zone.

My suggestions: Um, I don't really have anything I'd suggest yet, as I haven't participated but as it stands, it all looks good.

Any noticeable typos: I didn't notice anything that pulled my attention away from the details.

In conclusion: I think this is an intriguing contest that certainly invites me to use my imagination and dare to share. I like it and have it set aside in my favorites for when I pick up the quill for contest entries again. Well done, and happy anniversary.


** Images For Use By Upgraded+ Only **
268
268
Review of Revenge  
Review by Siobhan Falen
In affiliation with The Steampunk Authors' Gui...  
Rated: 13+ | (4.0)
Well, hello there: I am reviewing you work as one of the judges in the StAG Fireside Contest. This does not reflect the results of the contest, but is simply a courtesy review to let you know that I have gotten a chance to check out your great tale.

What I love about your work: The idea that this fellow does not have to be trapped forever by his rage, but simply help on the next poor soul was interesting. I also like that it shows, you can never know how accurate someone else's opinion is. You must learn for yourself who others truly are, and if they're willing to stab you in the back to achieve their goals.

Why I could relate to your work: Being on non-speaking terms with my grandfather, I can simply relate to that family member who may allow their opinion to taint everything and isolate you from other family members. Wasn't sure who to root for in this story thanks to that :P.

My suggestions: I would suggest, if you are to use this idea more, that you do a much more in depth development of the characters. As it stands, I found them all a little hard to feel attached to. I would also recommend exploring why the spirits get trapped waiting to help out other spirits in order to move on.

Any noticeable typos: I didn't see anything that really pulled my attention from the story.

My favorite line(s): "As a child, I spent a lot of time with Grandfather. I realized that I had been blinded by Grandfather's prejudice against Uncle John." It's hard to ignore that we allow family to color our views and distort the facts. It's often hard to see through the veil that love puts upon our eyes.

In conclusion: I firmly believe there is nothing quite as deadly as family greed. It can tear apart families, make cousins bitter enemies, and sometimes, sever spinal chords; all in all, family greed is not something you want to tangle with. I felt this was an interesting exploration into that idea and showed that everything is not just black and white. Best of luck.


** Images For Use By Upgraded+ Only **


*Gold* My review has been submitted for consideration in "Good Deeds Get CASH!" .
269
269
Review of To Save a Patient  
Review by Siobhan Falen
In affiliation with The Steampunk Authors' Gui...  
Rated: E | (4.0)
Well, hello there: I am reviewing you work as one of the judges in the StAG Fireside Contest. This does not reflect the results of the contest, but is simply a courtesy review to let you know that I have gotten a chance to check out your great tale.

What I love about your work: I like your development of the main character, how she's a woman standing tall in what's clearly a man's world. It's always nice to see strength and triumph.

Why I could relate to your work: I absolutely love strong female protagonists, and love to see stories where they bite their thumb at the idea of a prim and proper lass. This was fun, plus it was a vampire tale, so right up my alley.

My suggestions: My only suggestion is that I was not necessarily a fan of the last line. It felt a little too forced, and her monologue explaining the bullets felt a bit out of place. I think if you were to develop this further, it would probably flow smoother. Otherwise, I didn't really see anything I would change.

Any noticeable typos: I did not see anything that pulled my attention from the story.

My favorite line(s): "Elizabeth knew her brother-in-law disapproved of her. Few men accepted a woman who practiced medicine, much less one who drove their own steam car." And my "hurrah, show them what's what" side kicked in after I read that :P.

In conclusion: I thought this was a fun tale that has a lot of potential to be expanded into more. Victorian era vampire stories are an enjoyable read and a kick ass chick makes it more appealing. Nicely done, and best of luck.


** Images For Use By Upgraded+ Only **


*Gold* My review has been submitted for consideration in "Good Deeds Get CASH!" .
270
270
Review of PENdemonium  
Review by Siobhan Falen
In affiliation with WdC SuperPower Reviewers Group  
Rated: E | (3.5)
Welcome to WDC!!!

What I love about your work: I like the idea that you wish to do good for others through your writing, I thought that was a very nice touch.

Why I could relate to your work: I can certainly relate. When I write, it is with the hope that it touches someone's life. I'm pretty sure most writers have that goal, so you did well capturing that concept.

My suggestions: With the first two stanzas rhyming and the last one not, it felt a little disjointed. It's been ages since I've written formal poetry so I don't remember if that's an actual format, but if it's not, you might want to reword it ever so slightly so it flows better with the rhyming scheme.

Also, make sure to reread your work so you can hopefully catch any errors made. I find that often times, if I read out loud, I can catch most of my mistakes. I'm just admittedly often too time crunched to do it.

Any noticeable typos: "What shall I write wit this pen?" "wit" should be "with".

"May i write with all courage," Make sure you capitalize your "i" when using it as a personal pronoun.

My favorite line(s): "Hope and light for the ones in grief,
Encouragement and a little bit of relief." Think that captures a writer's hope quite well.

In conclusion: I think this pretty little piece has a lot of potential, it just needs a little more time invested into it. Make sure you try to proofread before posting, and this was an enjoyable read. Nicely done.


** Images For Use By Upgraded+ Only **


*Gold* My review has been submitted for consideration in "Good Deeds Get CASH!" .
271
271
Review of Let Them Burn  
Review by Siobhan Falen
In affiliation with WdC SuperPower Reviewers Group  
Rated: 13+ | (4.0)
Well, hello there: I've had this open on my computer for a couple of days, meaning to review you, so I don't remember how I found it. But, at least the review's coming.

What I love about your work: I enjoyed all the references you put in there, and if liked "Let it Go", I totally would have sang this out loud as it is has a nice flow to it.

Why I could relate to your work: I love the series, though admittedly I enjoy the show more than the books. The books take a lot more focus than I want to give :P. So, I had to read it based on that love alone. Glad I did, it was quite enjoyable.

My suggestions: I would recommend some punctuation. I know it's song lyrics, but it helps the flow run a bit smoother.

Any noticeable typos: "Don’t resist Visery, don’t start to believe" Did you mean Viserys?


"‘A horselord slut,’ brother said, Dany
Obey, don’t make the dragons awake" These lines just bothered me because you have his first quote in apostrophes but don't carry them over to the rest of what he says. It made me stumble as a reader and I reread it a couple of times.

My favorite line(s): "Let them burn, let them burn
Viserys has his golden crown" Still one of my favorite deaths. Plus, as much as I dislike Elsa's song, I did sing the chorus in my head. I mean, how can you go wrong with "Let them burn"?

In conclusion: This was a really fun piece and well thought out. To understand it completely, you definitely need to have some understanding of the series, but I don't think it's unreasonable to say that someone who doesn't know the series would still enjoy it. It has a pretty flow and is nicely worded. Well done.


** Images For Use By Upgraded+ Only **


*Gold* My review has been submitted for consideration in "Good Deeds Get CASH!" .
272
272
Review of A Faery's Tale  
Review by Siobhan Falen
In affiliation with WdC SuperPower Reviewers Group  
Rated: 18+ | (4.0)
Well, hello there: I am reviewing you for the "I write in September..." activity.

What I love about your work: I enjoyed this quite a bit more than your previous erotica that I've read. I felt you described the acts without bringing in awkward terms and it worked really well for this piece. It was sensual without being flustering and that is a fine line to straddle (yeah, I totally went there). I also enjoyed the imagery of the females waiting in their flowers, their desire blossoming as their flowers. Just kind of a pretty image.

Why I could relate to your work: I love the world of faeries and have my own novel taking place in the tiny world. It's always fun to read someone else's exploit into the fantasy world and see what their take is on it.

My suggestions: The storyline was interesting, but my biggest complaint was Diana's name. I realize Diana is the name of a flower, but considering you used very generic names for the main characters, it just kind of stuck out. You had these very obvious flower part names, and then Diana, it took me out of the faerie realm every time I read it.

Noticeable typos: "“Can I give you and answer after you’ve spoken with Seed?” Petal inquired." Minor error, "and" should be "an".

My favorite line(s): "This was unconventional among faeries his age." I can't help but wonder, why is he so different? This story intrigued me and made me speculate. Especially since Petal, though she did agree to marry him, did not have the same reservations.

In conclusion: This was an interesting tale that was woven around fertility and magic. It held some interesting personalities and a pretty story line. Nicely done.


** Images For Use By Upgraded+ Only **


*Gold* My review has been submitted for consideration in "Good Deeds Get CASH!" .
273
273
Review of Shipwrecked  
Review by Siobhan Falen
In affiliation with WdC SuperPower Reviewers Group  
Rated: 18+ | (4.0)
I am reviewing your work for the hydro package on "Invalid Item" 

What I love about your work: I really love the details you put into their struggle for survival. I could picture this in my head and it felt like a helluva unpleasant experience. They felt real and I thought the ending was fun, left so many opportunities.

Why I could relate to your work: I wrote for the contest too, but life was too hectic for me to post up my work (sniffles). Anyway, my shipwreck experience was completely different, so it was kind of fun to see the direction your story took. I also like the ending cause I'm a slasher fanatic and I totally pictured that their ideal rescue was not as sweet and friendly as it seemed.

My suggestions: There were a few awkward sentences such as this one: "Exploding into a roll that sent them on their back staring up at me with wide eyes full of unbridled fear." I'm not sure if it needs commas or a rewording, but it caused me to stumble. I know these are quick writes, but sometimes, reading it out loud will help catch spots like this.

Any noticeable typos: I did notice a few comma errors and a couple of misspellings, but the content held me enough that they were only worth mentioning in passing.

My favorite line(s): "“Daddy will want to know all about your adventure.” Bridget told me as she sat back down and dug some fresh fruit out of their cooler." I'm telling you, this just begs for Daddy to be an chainsaw wielding, face wearing crazy man who feeds his daughters a steady diet of ship-wrecked fools :P.

In conclusion: This was a fun tale that had such a realistic feel to it. All the little details about texture and the hunt for food, it just felt like you'd stepped into a very miserable moment in life. Nicely done.


** Images For Use By Upgraded+ Only **


*Gold* My review has been submitted for consideration in "Good Deeds Get CASH!" .
274
274
Review by Siobhan Falen
In affiliation with WdC SuperPower Reviewers Group  
Rated: ASR | (4.0)
Happy Anniversary this month!!!

What I love about your work: I enjoyed the story telling aspect, it felt very dreamy. I also got a kick out of the younger sailor witnessing the "sea witch" at the end.

Why I could relate to your work: Always a sucker for a ghost story, and love tales revolving around the ocean, so you had my attention.

My suggestions: There's a point that bothers me. You have the story being the Old Man was more or less rescued by the Sea Witch, yet he insists she's something to fear, and upon calling her a sea witch. Seems to me if a creature rescued you, no matter how horrible or alien it was, it would be deserving of some respect. So either she's a loathsome being worth being terrified of or the old man's horribly ungrateful and unkind. It just feels like the details don't fully mesh up.

Any noticeable typos: My biggest complaint is your verb tenses. You alternate between present and past tenses, and in order to keep the reader immersed in your story, you need to keep it consistent.

My favorite line(s): "He watched as the figure seemed to ride the waves up to the beach, and then slowly disintegrate, only to be seen again, approaching the beach.

Young sailor (whispering)“The sea witch.”" I always like when the end leaves you wondering what is real and what is not.

In conclusion: I think there's a lot of potential with this, it just needs some polishing. Anyways, as they say, write on and happy anniversary.



** Images For Use By Upgraded+ Only **


*Gold* My review has been submitted for consideration in "Good Deeds Get CASH!" .
275
275
Review of Chivalry  
Review by Siobhan Falen
In affiliation with WdC SuperPower Reviewers Group  
Rated: E | (4.0)
Well, hello there: Found you on the random reviews and this greatly entertained me.

What I love about your work: I could picture this in my mind (they were Betas in my head), and I loved the personality you imbued in Charlie. Feisty little fellow, though can't help but wonder if he's thought it all through :P.

Why I could relate to your work: There are no less than five running aquariums in my house, so needless to say, we love fish. So, I could easily envision this scene, silly fish.

My suggestions: Nothing really stood out to me. I didn't see any obvious typos or spots I would change.

My favorite line(s): "Next, he dropped down behind the book and found a toothpick he could use as a sword." Silly fish, doesn't he know toothpicks are what humans put fish on, not the other way around?

In conclusion: This was an entertaining, cute read that held my attention. I enjoyed the development of Charlie, nicely done.


** Images For Use By Upgraded+ Only **


*Gold* My review has been submitted for consideration in "Good Deeds Get CASH!" .
415 Reviews · *Magnify*
Page of 17 · 25 per page   < >
Printed from https://shop.writing.com/main/profile/reviews/shadowsnflames/sort_by/r.review_creation_time DESC/page/11